This really is an insensitive and completely inappropriate video. To play off the Death Star destruction as a tragedy while completely overlooking the destruction of Alderaan is just wrong. How insensitive College Humor! Shame on you.
Frankly, this is distasteful, disgusting, disturbing, and disrespectful. Eight years ago, as a psychologist in an elementary school where many parents worked in the World Trade Center area, I did not know if I would be trying to help respond to a few, dozens, or hundreds of deaths of parents, relatives, and friends of young children. The aftermath of this horrific terrorist event continues to impact the lives of so many children and families to this day. This "spoof" is horrible. It is like trying to find humor in the Holocaust. Please remove it, in the name of human decency.
@VilleNike: The thing is, people need to let the past be the past. Sure it was a horrible event, will it happen again, most likely, there's nothing anybody can do to stop someone from doing something again. Yea that's vague, which is why it can happen again. The only direct connection with the event my family had was my cousin and I both got sent to the desert, my cousin several times. If you can't make fun of the past, then all you have left to make fun of is dick and fart jokes.
@VilleNike: Oh give it a rest. Like you haven't EVER laughed at a joke around the subject of death.
I live within walking distance of Ground Zero. Does our proximity somehow make us suddenly more worthwhile of righteous indignation?
This is a very funny video, which manages to approach a very difficult topic in a non-insulting and carefully worded way. Not only do they avoid making fun of anyone who was hurt or directly affected by the attacks, they also cover many of the opinions and points of view people have afterward.
The worst way to get over a tragedy is to continue to be bitter and tragic. The people I know who have lost loved ones but maintain a sense of humor about them, even about their deaths, are far more comfortable in their lives after that loss, and are far more capable of fondly remembering them, rather than remembering them with constant pain and anguish.
The very reason we New Yorkers managed to pull through 9/11 so well is because of our ability to use that terrible event as a driving cause for betterment, not a lingering cause for misery.
@jacksonwhole: "The Jews were horrified. I received resentful letters of protest, saying things like: "How can you make jokes about Hitler? The man murdered 6 million Jews." But "The Producers" doesn’t concern a concentration camp or the Holocaust. ...Of course it is impossible to take revenge for 6 million murdered Jews. But by using the medium of comedy, we can try to rob Hitler of his posthumous power and myths." - Mel Brooks in a 2006 interview with Spiegel
@jacksonwhole: "The Jews were horrified. I received resentful letters of protest, saying things like: "How can you make jokes about Hitler? The man murdered 6 million Jews." But "The Producers" doesn’t concern a concentration camp or the Holocaust. ...Of course it is impossible to take revenge for 6 million murdered Jews. But by using the medium of comedy, we can try to rob Hitler of his posthumous power and myths." - Mel Brooks in a 2006 interview with Spiegel
@VilleNike: Guess what? I'm a firefighter. The number 343 means a hell of a lot to me. I have several (now former) co-workers who were deployed to NYC as part of a FEMA Task Force immediately after 9/11. All of them have been forced into early retirement and a couple of them are in the process of dying from lung diseases they got there.
All that is to say this: this clip is funny as hell. If you ask nicely, I might tell you every firefighter's favorite knock knock joke.
@smcallah: Actually, when you put it that way, I guess I actually do...
Seriously though, I think people need to respect that many people here have different experiences around 9/11; some witnessed it, some responded to it, some lived through it, some watchedit on tv, and some lost friends and family. I am not saying that this video should be taken down or anything, and I agree that good humor sometimes has to push bounderies, but for me this video is just touches a nerve that is still a little too raw.
Wouldn't it be more like the Storm Troopers' Pearl Harbor? How many civilians, other than the contracted construction crews were in the Death Star? (please consult Clerks for further clarification) They knew the score. It was a combat vessel. I say boo-freaking-hoo Galactic Empire.
@Kaiser-Machead: The Death Star was, clearly, a combat vessel, but in "reality", it probably functioned more as a mobile city than anything. I'd be willing to bet that there were a number of civilian business operating on the Death Star to serve the needs of the stormtroopers stationed there. They all died just because they had a little entrepreneurial spirit and wanted to make a little money.
@92BuickLeSabre: I know your kind. Buncha lib'ral potheads, sitting on a fire escape, smokin' that junk and slurpin' your freak juice while real men go out to die for the greater good.
@kylenalepa: And then there's the maintenance workers that know the duct system. Surely someone saw that there was a huge vent that lead all the way to the core of the station.
@lostarchitect: I'm going with sketch served two ways. On one side of the plate, they've served it funny, on the other side the dish is done offensive.
@92BuickLeSabre: As tragic as 9/11 was (and I saw this without actually have knowing anyone directly involved in the attack) there comes a point in time where you need to be able to make some sort of light of situation. In many cases humor is a great stress relief. Was it offensive? Hell yeah it was, but it wasn't meant to piss people off.
@Matthew Rebmann: Exactly, you gotta make light of the situation.
If it still offends you for somebody to make an off -color parody of the situation 9 years later, then consider yourself defeated by the terrorists... because that's what they WANT. They want you to live in fear and be hurt about it for the rest of your life, but I'm not going to let them get to me.
I say it was a fucking hilarious take on a previously undiscovered coincidence. I really enjoyed it.
huh...People still believe that Bin Laden was responsible for 9/11? Saying 9/11 was "an attack on the US" is like saying "a kid was attacked by dogs" although the kid actually bit himself so he could convince his parents to buy him candy.
happy 9/11! glad to see this event has brought peace to the gizmodo commenters. you all get points for having the same eight year old argument about the iraq war too. how can anyone say we evolve when you could have copied and pasted the same thread from 02.
@Zordon i'll call a terrorist whatever i fuckin want. lol
@briansaysdie: "Terrorist" and "Terrorism" are nothing more than the new buzz words for the younger generation to replace "Commie" and "Communism".
The Gov needs to maintain the fear of outsiders in the population to control them. As long as we have a name (terrorists) for the "outsiders", we can point a finger and rally behind the flag and Randy Travis. It keeps us happily chewing our cud and not questioning the dubious agenda of the people in power as they systematically strip away every right you USED to have.
Feel empowered. It's inherent to the plan my good lemming.
Do you even know? I am a soldier, I fight for our country. If you really want to know what our Military is doing in this war, then go to Iraq or Afghanistan and see the faces of these people we are helping. Hear them thank you for giving them hope. The thought of people like you makes me sick. I have fought for this country in ways you people joke about.
Our government has done the best it could in this situation. If someone walked up to you on the street and slapped you, you would not idoly sit by and let them walk away, you would fight back.
Until you have truely done something for your country, until you have truely done something for man kind, you have no room to say/type anything negative about this war or the people involved.
Please, I challenge you, go over ther as a tourist and see what we see. Feel what we feel and tell me this war is wrong. Tell me that we are not making a difference.
If you don't like the decisions of our government, make a change. I dont mean type something in a blog. I am talking run for office. If you think you could do a better job, then go do it.
If you don't like this war, too fucking bad. We are here, have been for 8 years and will be for another 8. This is the second most important war this country has ever fought. The first being the Revolutionary War.
This war is important. This war is bringing freedom and peace of mind to hundres of thousands of people who have lived under tyrany their whole lives. This war is putting a stop to terrorism. This war is saving the lives of civilians around the world.
We are keeping the extremests so busy over there, they have not had a chance to attack anywhere else. You talk about 9/11 as if it were something in a history book. Something that happened and we should get over. 9/11 was an act of war. They started this shit, we are finishing it.
Don't patronize people, don't talk down to people, and don't talk shit about the people who keep you free and safe.
Go on and live your life, as I know you will not take me seriously. You will undoubtadly think that this is silly and I don't know what I'm talking about. The next time you think to question your nation's military, then question everything you have. If it were not for us, then you would have nothing. You would be nothing. Your entire life as you know it, is a direct result of what we do every day.
You might watch movies and play video games and think because of that you know war. You don't.
@mazwoz: hmmm, interesting. I can understand the passion coming from a soldier. My father was drafted in Vietnam over 30 years ago and he still remembers what he saw overseas as if it happened today. He has some interesting stories.
But I have to disagree with you on one point. WWII and the Civil War I believe are the two most important wars this country fought. I'm sure that there are people overseas in the battle ridden areas that are grateful for the US's involvement but charity begins at home and spreads abroad. I can't have faith in the US government's "intentions" with the conflicts and invested time and money in helping other countries when equal inspiration and dedication isn't given for jobs, education, health care and homelessness right here in the US. It seems suspect. I'm not saying that the conflicts are utterly pointless (although that argument can be made) but...
It's seems too easy to point at problems abroad than deal with problems in our own house. Have you been to the inner city neighborhoods in some US cities? "Warzone" comes to mind.
Mark Wilson approved this comment
Striderhayasa - Can we get some damn m/kb support?! was starred
Striderhayasa - Can we get some damn m/kb support?! was unstarred
09/15/09
09/15/09
09/14/09
09/15/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
I live within walking distance of Ground Zero. Does our proximity somehow make us suddenly more worthwhile of righteous indignation?
This is a very funny video, which manages to approach a very difficult topic in a non-insulting and carefully worded way. Not only do they avoid making fun of anyone who was hurt or directly affected by the attacks, they also cover many of the opinions and points of view people have afterward.
The worst way to get over a tragedy is to continue to be bitter and tragic. The people I know who have lost loved ones but maintain a sense of humor about them, even about their deaths, are far more comfortable in their lives after that loss, and are far more capable of fondly remembering them, rather than remembering them with constant pain and anguish.
The very reason we New Yorkers managed to pull through 9/11 so well is because of our ability to use that terrible event as a driving cause for betterment, not a lingering cause for misery.
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/15/09
All that is to say this: this clip is funny as hell. If you ask nicely, I might tell you every firefighter's favorite knock knock joke.
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/15/09
Seriously though, I think people need to respect that many people here have different experiences around 9/11; some witnessed it, some responded to it, some lived through it, some watchedit on tv, and some lost friends and family. I am not saying that this video should be taken down or anything, and I agree that good humor sometimes has to push bounderies, but for me this video is just touches a nerve that is still a little too raw.
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
Win.
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
Funny video, BTW.
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
I found my self busting my gut the whole time.
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
09/14/09
If it still offends you for somebody to make an off -color parody of the situation 9 years later, then consider yourself defeated by the terrorists... because that's what they WANT. They want you to live in fear and be hurt about it for the rest of your life, but I'm not going to let them get to me.
I say it was a fucking hilarious take on a previously undiscovered coincidence. I really enjoyed it.
09/11/09
09/11/09
09/11/09
@Zordon i'll call a terrorist whatever i fuckin want. lol
09/11/09
The Gov needs to maintain the fear of outsiders in the population to control them. As long as we have a name (terrorists) for the "outsiders", we can point a finger and rally behind the flag and Randy Travis. It keeps us happily chewing our cud and not questioning the dubious agenda of the people in power as they systematically strip away every right you USED to have.
Feel empowered. It's inherent to the plan my good lemming.
09/11/09
Do you even know? I am a soldier, I fight for our country. If you really want to know what our Military is doing in this war, then go to Iraq or Afghanistan and see the faces of these people we are helping. Hear them thank you for giving them hope. The thought of people like you makes me sick. I have fought for this country in ways you people joke about.
Our government has done the best it could in this situation. If someone walked up to you on the street and slapped you, you would not idoly sit by and let them walk away, you would fight back.
Until you have truely done something for your country, until you have truely done something for man kind, you have no room to say/type anything negative about this war or the people involved.
Please, I challenge you, go over ther as a tourist and see what we see. Feel what we feel and tell me this war is wrong. Tell me that we are not making a difference.
If you don't like the decisions of our government, make a change. I dont mean type something in a blog. I am talking run for office. If you think you could do a better job, then go do it.
If you don't like this war, too fucking bad. We are here, have been for 8 years and will be for another 8. This is the second most important war this country has ever fought. The first being the Revolutionary War.
This war is important. This war is bringing freedom and peace of mind to hundres of thousands of people who have lived under tyrany their whole lives. This war is putting a stop to terrorism. This war is saving the lives of civilians around the world.
We are keeping the extremests so busy over there, they have not had a chance to attack anywhere else. You talk about 9/11 as if it were something in a history book. Something that happened and we should get over. 9/11 was an act of war. They started this shit, we are finishing it.
Don't patronize people, don't talk down to people, and don't talk shit about the people who keep you free and safe.
Go on and live your life, as I know you will not take me seriously. You will undoubtadly think that this is silly and I don't know what I'm talking about. The next time you think to question your nation's military, then question everything you have. If it were not for us, then you would have nothing. You would be nothing. Your entire life as you know it, is a direct result of what we do every day.
You might watch movies and play video games and think because of that you know war. You don't.
Seriously, just leave this issue alone.
09/11/09
But I have to disagree with you on one point. WWII and the Civil War I believe are the two most important wars this country fought. I'm sure that there are people overseas in the battle ridden areas that are grateful for the US's involvement but charity begins at home and spreads abroad. I can't have faith in the US government's "intentions" with the conflicts and invested time and money in helping other countries when equal inspiration and dedication isn't given for jobs, education, health care and homelessness right here in the US. It seems suspect. I'm not saying that the conflicts are utterly pointless (although that argument can be made) but...
It's seems too easy to point at problems abroad than deal with problems in our own house. Have you been to the inner city neighborhoods in some US cities? "Warzone" comes to mind.
09/12/09
You are delusional if you think you are / were there for "freedom". 2nd most important war? Hardly.
"They started this shit, we are finishing it."
That's the kind of thinking that got us into an illegal war, and the kind of thinking that keeps us in one.
09/11/09
"We will never forget."