Fatal flaw? I'm gonna go with Tsunami/Perfect Storm for #1. Pilots having to qualify for landing on an aircraft carrier to get a route into San Diego (ask one how it is to land on one in rolling seas...) for #2. And finally, the need for water taxis to get me and my luggage back to my car as #3. Yeah, this will happen.... not. #floatingcaliforniaairport
A tsunami would more likely destroy a traditional airport, especially a coastal one. At 10 miles out to sea, a "normal" tsunami wouldn't appear any different than a normal wave. the floating tarmac itself would suffer practically no damage at all. A mega-tsunami (like in the movies) would destroy everything either way so your point there is moot
To your second point, carrier landings are so difficult because of how short the landing deck is. A pilot has to land on essentially a floating postage stamp, --in fact landing near one edge of said stamp. This airport will be full-sized with 747-capable runways which are is 17,000+ ft long, almost 30 times longer than a supercarrier's total deck length (about 700ft).
I am also thinking that a full-sized airport has got to weigh many orders of magnitude more than a supercarrier and if it will have 4 stories worth of retail and service space above the water, then dealing with 20 ft-plus storm waves should not be a problem.
I have to agree that getting to and from the airport itself would be an unnecessarily long, expensive, and dangerous process.
@AaronProtesilaus: Also note that on a carrier the runway is moving away from you - forwards AND sideways, in addition to pitching and yawing. #floatingcaliforniaairport
If there is a fatal flaw it's that there don't appear to be plans to ferry passengers off the island. For the first year or so of operation, it's easy to see how something like that could be overlooked, with passengers simply booking rooms in the hotels and taking classes at the university to fill up their time. But at some point, the platform will be saturated with passengers, and they'll need to develop some system for either accommodating larger numbers of arriving passengers indefinitely, or moving them to another location. #floatingcaliforniaairport
@frigg: I could envision a vast complex of warehouses to house the passengers, and perhaps a carrier-style hangar system for the mounting number of idling jets. Actually, the maintenance on the jets alone would employ hundreds, and stimulate the regional economy. #floatingcaliforniaairport
Can they not build a peninsula into the ocean instead of this free-standing floating doohickey? I was in Korea last summer where they also have trouble finding places to put things, and they built an airport in the sea as well, but with a man-made peninsula.
You know if they build this thing, some guy will eventually put a strike team together to capture it, and take it for an expensive joy ride. #floatingcaliforniaairport
Um have any of you heard of the Osaka airport, so this Mr. Englund didn't come up with this. The Japanese made a massive island to make the Osaka airport, its even a modern marvels episode or something.... #floatingcaliforniaairport
As a native San Diegan, I can tell you that this idea has been around for awhile. I remember reading an article about it in the 4th grade, some 13 years ago. Interesting to see it pop back up though. #floatingcaliforniaairport
They don't have any other options. Lindbergh sure as hell isn't expanding downtown, and using Miramar isn't going to be allowed by residents. They are stuck between a rock and a hard place. #floatingcaliforniaairport
If you can't tell from the "@%*$ing," I'm obviously kidding. : P
-------------------------------
But seriously, how the hell are you going to do an evacuation plan if a tanker crashes into it? (Obviously the space around the airport would be restricted.) Plus, transportation by ferry would be SLOW. Passengers would get pretty pissed off alright.
EDIT: Hoorah, I've done and created another useless tag.
@spannu: Touche, but at least when we sink, everything's all gonna be abandoned anyways and new airports will be built.
Meanwhile, a tanker hits the airport, and then everyone is still on it. They all die, but on your plus side, it'll become the Atlantis of the West Coast! #floatingcaliforniaairport
I live in San Diego they've been talking about this for years. This city's government is "Enron" by the sea. This will never happen although it would be awesome to see.
Same basic concept as Kansai International in Osaka, although they built an artificial island as opposed to the "oil rig" design here. Given the land options in San Diego, this might not be a bad idea. #floatingcaliforniaairport
@Ehrich Blackhound: Ding.
3rd Parties started offering this as an option when the Mini was refreshed this year and Apple moved to a SATA SuperDrive. If true, it'd be nice if Apple would offer it with a sealed drive slot. #apple
@GitEmSteveDave_Hates #DoucheDad: Oh my god, are you serious? The iPod event was like a month ago. Also, I'm new here, and to the earf, so I can't tell sarcasm. #apple
@GitEmSteveDave_Hates #DoucheDad: A new iTouch would be nice, but the iTouches were upgraded not long ago so I don't suppose we'll be seeing anything new on the iTouch end.
10/27/09
10/27/09
A tsunami would more likely destroy a traditional airport, especially a coastal one. At 10 miles out to sea, a "normal" tsunami wouldn't appear any different than a normal wave. the floating tarmac itself would suffer practically no damage at all. A mega-tsunami (like in the movies) would destroy everything either way so your point there is moot
To your second point, carrier landings are so difficult because of how short the landing deck is. A pilot has to land on essentially a floating postage stamp, --in fact landing near one edge of said stamp. This airport will be full-sized with 747-capable runways which are is 17,000+ ft long, almost 30 times longer than a supercarrier's total deck length (about 700ft).
I am also thinking that a full-sized airport has got to weigh many orders of magnitude more than a supercarrier and if it will have 4 stories worth of retail and service space above the water, then dealing with 20 ft-plus storm waves should not be a problem.
I have to agree that getting to and from the airport itself would be an unnecessarily long, expensive, and dangerous process.
It might not practical now but it isn't undo-able or ridiculous. #floatingcaliforniaairport
10/28/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
You know if they build this thing, some guy will eventually put a strike team together to capture it, and take it for an expensive joy ride. #floatingcaliforniaairport
10/27/09
Um have any of you heard of the Osaka airport, so this Mr. Englund didn't come up with this. The Japanese made a massive island to make the Osaka airport, its even a modern marvels episode or something.... #floatingcaliforniaairport
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
... that and a Chargers stadium. #floatingcaliforniaairport
10/27/09
"Meanwhile we've got 3 fucking airports! Airports! FUCKING! Hell yeah!!"
If you can't tell from the "@%*$ing," I'm obviously kidding. : P
-------------------------------
But seriously, how the hell are you going to do an evacuation plan if a tanker crashes into it? (Obviously the space around the airport would be restricted.) Plus, transportation by ferry would be SLOW. Passengers would get pretty pissed off alright.
EDIT: Hoorah, I've done and created another useless tag.
10/27/09
10/27/09
Meanwhile, a tanker hits the airport, and then everyone is still on it. They all die, but on your plus side, it'll become the Atlantis of the West Coast! #floatingcaliforniaairport
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/27/09
10/20/09
10/20/09
10/20/09
No ODD = "No Optical Disk Drive"??? #apple
10/20/09
10/20/09
3rd Parties started offering this as an option when the Mini was refreshed this year and Apple moved to a SATA SuperDrive. If true, it'd be nice if Apple would offer it with a sealed drive slot. #apple
10/20/09
A real "upgrade" to the TC would be fan-assisted cooling, cuz that mamajama gets hot.
10/20/09
10/20/09
10/20/09
10/20/09
10/20/09
iTouch. #apple
10/20/09
@GitEmSteveDave_NodsHisHeadLikeYeah: Unbelievable. It works every time. #apple