Just have the browsers presented in a circle. Better yet, a circle that rotates, so any future complaints about Firefox not getting a dominant position on the circle can be hushed before they're spoken. #browserballot
What a whiny bitch. If people want firefox for its features and ease of use, they will click on it. If they want IE because they don't know any better, they will click on it. If they want adherence to web standards, or are lazy, they will click on safari. If they want a browser that guests won't use cause they have never heard of it and don't know its a browser, they will pick opera. Plain and simple. #browserballot
Since Opera started all of this I would guess the only reason we haven't heard anything from them yet is because they are still drafting up a response.
This is absolutely ridiculous. It's bad enough that MS is being forced to do it in the first place, but now they even have to put themselves further down the list?
If Opera and onecorewonderZilla keep this up maybe the EU will can the idea all together.
Personally I think MS should have just stuck with the "no browser" option and send IE cd's to stores like they were going to do. Make Mozilla, Apple, and Opera do the same. Case close. #browserballot
I love FF (keywords + xmarks FTW), but seriously Boriss wouldn't be bitching if Firefox were first in the list.
Just seems a tad hypocritical. #browserballot
@The Lab: If someone paid me enough, I'd say that "X" Corp.'s products are better than Jesus and Unicorns combined, and anyone who says otherwise is a slanderizin' sonofabitch. #browserballot
i think it's absurd that anyone would select a browser based on an arbitrary ordering. does she think we're retarded?
people who would choose IE probably don't give a shit about their browser. people who choose safari will do so because it's an apple program. but the others? those are the domain of those of us who DO give a damn about our browsers, who actually are familiar with them, and have rational reasons for choosing one over the others.
fans of firefox didn't get to be fans of firefox by randomly downloading it one day because it was the first in some irrelevant list. we heard good things about it and made a concerted effort to check it out.
lastly, where's the victory in duping people into using firefox by way of psychological trickery? isn't this about choice after all? and isn't choice only choice when it's informed, comprehended and consensual? #browserballot
@nutbastard: Ha.. You obviously don't know my friend then. When playing Marvel Vs. Capcom 2 she always chooses her characters based on "cuteness and sparklyness" as she likes to call it.
Some people who might not be so familiar with all of these browsers would pick the one that is first, since it would seem like they put it first since it is the best choice, not because of alphabetical order. I mean, come on. #browserballot
@nutbastard:
It's not completely unheard of to select an item arbitrarily. If you're talking about knowledgeable computer techs, that's one thing. If you're talking about the more average consumer, it's another.
If someone were asked to select one of 5 HTTP Web Server programs, and they weren't familiar with any of them, then the first one in the list would most likely be the best bet. #browserballot
Is this list in order of developer? sorted alphabetically? I think that's fare enough. I mean IE doesn't have flashing lights on it or anything #browserballot
Microsoft should just take a representative from each browser out for Happy Meals. Whoever yells shotgun first on the way back to the van gets first position. #browserballot
Because it's been proven by Internet science that people who like a certain thing will be more prone to select something else if it's first on the list. #browserballot
Without more information to base your decision, you're going to accept the default pretty much every time. That is just how our brain works.
What many on Giz consider as a "no brainer", really isn't for the average person faced with a technology decision. There is real anxiety caused by needing to make this choice. #browserballot
@Lite: hates Illinois Nazis: I rarely choose the default. When something lacks information, choosing the route to gain more of it should be 2nd nature. If you're not using such a process to make the best possible decision, you're making foolish choices in consistency. #browserballot
@Lite: hates Illinois Nazis: Well then its settled. Mozilla should force the EU to change how human brains work, in order for Firefox to be represented fairly on this browser selection screen. #browserballot
@Lite: hates Illinois Nazis: It may be a real concern for Firefox or it may cause anxiety to people .... it is still NOT valid to sugest that a multiple choice install is flawed because MY product is not first on the list. #browserballot
@Falsoman: I didn't say it was honest. I said it was a valid concern for Firefox. Not that their concern was in the best interests of the customer.
Setting something as a "default" effectively precludes choice for roughly 80% of people.
Your brain processes information in a certain way, and lacking data up-front before confronted with the decision, it's difficult to make a choice. If you are not required to make a choice, you will more often than not accept the default. #browserballot
@Lite: hates Illinois Nazis: @Lite: hates Illinois Nazis: I hate Illinois Nazis! There's a helpful More Info button below each browser.
And really when you get down to it, what difference does a browser make for a non-tech savvy person in the first place? The person who picks Safari because it is first isn't someone who is going to go "You know, I like the sandbox structure in Chrome," or "Oh man, why WOULDN'T I want to run Greasemonkey scripts? Firefox it is!"
Sure, you could make a case for stability and proper rendering of sites, but for most people, like you said, it doesn't matter. They pick whatever comes first.
And besides, if we let everyone pick Firefox and use adblocker, what would happen to internet commerce without all those idiots buying ways to brighten their yellow teeth and get those abs they've always wanted! Think of the lost commerce, man! #browserballot
@CrimsonKnight13: So, if you're given a choice on a form regarding painkiller after surgery where the default is Ibuprofin, and checking the checkbox gives you heroin instead. And you know nothing about the difference between heroin and Ibuprofin, you would choose heroin?
Got it.
Most people make foolish choices consistently. Which includes you, and I. It's just that most of the choices you make on a daily basis have little chance to kill you. #browserballot
I look at this like a menu: I pick what I like, not just what's first on the menu. I think that most non-techie users will probably do things the same way and pick IE because they're familiar with it - it's what they "like."
I don't pick the first item on the menu at some restraurant because I'm not familiar with it, and I wouldn't pick the first item in a list of browsers because I wasn't familiar with some of them either.
I would predict that since most users would be at least a little familiar with IE, that's the one they would pick if they weren't familiar with some of the choices.
@Lite: hates Illinois Nazis: I don't see how choice #2 means I'll automatically chose it. Just because its the only other choice doesn't mean that I'll jump on it. I don't see how your logic is sound. #browserballot
@IsabelCordus: Right but you are assuming that you can read the menu in a meaningful way. If someone asks you what kind of oil do you want in your car, and says "this is the default...." Most people say "OK". Then there are people when offered, a choice as a "premium" they will take that. Without any knowledge that it is actually any better than the non-premium item. They just feel better because they pay more. (See: Monster Cable)
@CrimsonKnight13: You just said, you tend to not take the default. Which is it, do you make an educated decision? IN this case, you don't have an education about the decision you are making... Or, do you not pick the default?
Both of you are arguing against me, because you don't want to be generalized. And really, who does. However neither of you appears to have done the research. The first thing I did was link to someone who HAS done the research. Maybe you should go give it a shot, and ponder what he's saying about how the human brain makes decisions. #browserballot
@CrimsonKnight13: More research based upon his personal experience in having bandages ripped off of his burned skin in the hospital on a daily basis...
@Lite: hates Illinois Nazis: I tend to take a long time to decide when I don't really know what I'm going to choose. Yes, I don't like to be generalized at all. I just do my best to bring an alternate view to the table even when research shows how things work MOST of the time. We all have the ability to break the mold & do something different. #browserballot
@Lite: hates Illinois Nazis: Knock 'em dead Lite. Although, Dan Ariely is using a Macbook. Is this your attempt at persuading us to Safari side? Shame, shame. #browserballot
@CaptainKyle: As a Macbook user I'm insulted by your insinuation. The first thing I do upon getting a Mac is remove Safari from the toolbar and install Firefox! RAGE! #browserballot
10/17/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
Yes, but wich browser starts at the top? #browserballot
10/16/09
10/17/09
But then someone will start whining about wich of 'em will reach the top first...
Sigh... #browserballot
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
This is absolutely ridiculous. It's bad enough that MS is being forced to do it in the first place, but now they even have to put themselves further down the list?
If Opera and onecorewonderZilla keep this up maybe the EU will can the idea all together.
Personally I think MS should have just stuck with the "no browser" option and send IE cd's to stores like they were going to do. Make Mozilla, Apple, and Opera do the same. Case close. #browserballot
10/17/09
10/18/09
The big boxes would make the layout decision. #browserballot
10/18/09
10/18/09
10/19/09
10/16/09
Just seems a tad hypocritical. #browserballot
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
people who would choose IE probably don't give a shit about their browser. people who choose safari will do so because it's an apple program. but the others? those are the domain of those of us who DO give a damn about our browsers, who actually are familiar with them, and have rational reasons for choosing one over the others.
fans of firefox didn't get to be fans of firefox by randomly downloading it one day because it was the first in some irrelevant list. we heard good things about it and made a concerted effort to check it out.
lastly, where's the victory in duping people into using firefox by way of psychological trickery? isn't this about choice after all? and isn't choice only choice when it's informed, comprehended and consensual? #browserballot
10/16/09
10/16/09
Some people who might not be so familiar with all of these browsers would pick the one that is first, since it would seem like they put it first since it is the best choice, not because of alphabetical order. I mean, come on. #browserballot
10/16/09
It's not completely unheard of to select an item arbitrarily. If you're talking about knowledgeable computer techs, that's one thing. If you're talking about the more average consumer, it's another.
If someone were asked to select one of 5 HTTP Web Server programs, and they weren't familiar with any of them, then the first one in the list would most likely be the best bet. #browserballot
10/16/09
then i'm going to have to assume that's why people vote democrat. #browserballot
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
[www.ted.com]
Without more information to base your decision, you're going to accept the default pretty much every time. That is just how our brain works.
What many on Giz consider as a "no brainer", really isn't for the average person faced with a technology decision. There is real anxiety caused by needing to make this choice. #browserballot
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
And why is Microsoft ordering it by company name alpha instead of browers name alpha?
This whole situation is stupid. #browserballot
10/16/09
Setting something as a "default" effectively precludes choice for roughly 80% of people.
Your brain processes information in a certain way, and lacking data up-front before confronted with the decision, it's difficult to make a choice. If you are not required to make a choice, you will more often than not accept the default. #browserballot
10/16/09
And really when you get down to it, what difference does a browser make for a non-tech savvy person in the first place? The person who picks Safari because it is first isn't someone who is going to go "You know, I like the sandbox structure in Chrome," or "Oh man, why WOULDN'T I want to run Greasemonkey scripts? Firefox it is!"
Sure, you could make a case for stability and proper rendering of sites, but for most people, like you said, it doesn't matter. They pick whatever comes first.
And besides, if we let everyone pick Firefox and use adblocker, what would happen to internet commerce without all those idiots buying ways to brighten their yellow teeth and get those abs they've always wanted! Think of the lost commerce, man! #browserballot
10/16/09
Got it.
Most people make foolish choices consistently. Which includes you, and I. It's just that most of the choices you make on a daily basis have little chance to kill you. #browserballot
10/16/09
I look at this like a menu: I pick what I like, not just what's first on the menu. I think that most non-techie users will probably do things the same way and pick IE because they're familiar with it - it's what they "like."
I don't pick the first item on the menu at some restraurant because I'm not familiar with it, and I wouldn't pick the first item in a list of browsers because I wasn't familiar with some of them either.
I would predict that since most users would be at least a little familiar with IE, that's the one they would pick if they weren't familiar with some of the choices.
10/16/09
10/16/09
@CrimsonKnight13: You just said, you tend to not take the default. Which is it, do you make an educated decision? IN this case, you don't have an education about the decision you are making... Or, do you not pick the default?
Both of you are arguing against me, because you don't want to be generalized. And really, who does. However neither of you appears to have done the research. The first thing I did was link to someone who HAS done the research. Maybe you should go give it a shot, and ponder what he's saying about how the human brain makes decisions. #browserballot
10/16/09
[www.ted.com] #browserballot
10/16/09
10/16/09
10/16/09
08/14/09
08/14/09
08/14/09