Senior Contributing Editors:
Jesus Diaz
| AIM | Twitter
Mark Wilson, Reviews
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editors:
Matt Buchanan | AIM | Twitter
Adam Frucci | Twitter
Sean Fallon | Twitter
Jack Loftus | Twitter
John Herrman | Twitter
Dan Nosowitz
Chris Mascari
Kat Hannaford | Twitter
Rosa Golijan | Twitter
Chris Jacob
I could probably do without the blur, but I'm guessing this will be upgradable to Android 2. I like the look of the keyboard of the Cliq better than the Droid - much better for emulators/games with the d-pad on the left. #nowshipping
$120? Really? Just buy a $30 receiver off ebay if you REALLY need XM radio. Other wise just invest in Slacker (music and comedy) and Wunder Radio (sports and news). #nowshipping
We've been here before... face to face with the Cliq; I'm still on the fence though and wary that I may never see Android 2.0 on that thing. #nowshipping
@En0s1: The Cliq is going to be Motorola's flagship GSM phone for a while. Given that fact, they probably will do what they can to keep the flagship current. (I hope).
Why is it that mobile manufacturers don't recognize the #1 annoyance? Response time. If I have to wait 0.5s for the thing to respond, it feels like a laggy POS. This should be the #1 requirement in all smartphones - no lag, instant response. Forget about the cheesy animations, just make the thing quick. #motorolacliqreview
Ah Cliq. Perfect name...I no part of it. Alas, I wait for the perfect communication device...hope she is from New Zealand and cute! #motorolacliqreview
This looks interesting. I'll be looking for a new phone when my contract expires next summer and I really want something running android. I would get an iPhone but until Apple decides I can develop for it without buying a Mac I'd like something where I don't need to buy a load of proprietary hardware just to run the SDK.
‘dat is one ugly phone. How many logos, icons, buttons, and status lights does one need before it’s time to say "enough"? And that's just the faceplate.
Like it or not, industrial design and build quality counts these days. The RAZR had it, so what happened here? (Actually, the RAZR hardware had it. The software and UI blew chunks.)
This looks like it was designed by a committee equiped with an "everything but the kitchen sink" feature checklist.
Motorola has really been behind the curve with smartphones. That is an understatement. The company was in the dumps before the RAZR and I would not be surprised if this turned things around. They found a niche (social networking) for their phone to fulfill and executed it beautifully. Hopefully they will hire some *real* marketing people because their best left the company.
As far as the keyboard goes, they have been doing awful keyboards with terrible buttons because of Six Sigma and making the keyboard a solid strip. They desperately needed to ship this phone and much like the off centered design of the CDMA Q, they shoved it out the door knowing that it would take ages to re-design the hardware. I know they are
"used" to making their own phones, but the keyboard is such a stretch from their previous phones it goes without saying that they would struggle with a new design with better "feeling" keys versus their past "one solid piece" keyboards which were hard to type on.
This is very very positive for a company that has failed in the consumer sector for so long with handsets. It should strengthen the brand name in general. Given the phones offered on T-mo this should do quite well given that they will probably subsidize it more within a month. I know the MyTouch is a competitor, but for social networking and texting a physical keyboard is much much better.
I am not saying this phone is perfect, but this is the direction they are going with their handsets. Variants of this phone with different price-tags etc. should really get the phones selling rather then collecting dust. They already do so well with Boost from Sprint, I can only imagine how many more people would get those phones if it was based on the same platform as the Cliq.
@LindsayJoy's MBP is into S+M: They must be doing something right to tempt me to dump my little SE (admittedly it's not the best phone itself). But I'm glad to see T-Mo is getting more interesting offers in their stores. I'm hoping that the hardware complaints are more of a nitpick than an actual concern. [gizmodo.com]
Whether or not this phone succeeds in the marketplace relies solely on whether or not Motorola or T Mobile are really going to push this phone through advertising and marketing. Electronic markets in general have so much noise, you have to be the loudest voice to be heard. And because of the perpetual change and ubiquitous upgrades and remakes in the marketplace, you gotta get in their and grab a share of the market like it's the last piece of pizza you'll ever eat in your life. So, T Mobile and Motorola, there's 10 seconds on the clock, you've got one chance to make the touchdown, the balls in your court (or whatever sports metaphor works best here...)
P.s. Marketing a phone is one thing that Gizmodo doesn't really go over when talking about a phone and whether it'll succeed or fail. I know your a tech blog, but this is a major part of the industry, and your review on how slow a phone can be is only half of the story...just sayin'...
I kind of want this (that D-Pad looks great for emulators), but at the same time, I don't give a flying fuck at a rolling doughnut about Twitter, Facebook, or any of that crap.
How does this phone compare to the myTouch 3G? It doesn't have a slider, but heck if it's not a nicer looking phone all around than this thing, while also being $50 cheaper with the discount.
I really want to take the android leap. The Cliq seems like a good option. Word is its more responsive than the Hero but it's still using old hardware. Is there anything just over the horizon worth waiting for?
@JayD16: Honestly, I'd wait til closer to the end of the year. Google was talking this summer about there being close to 20 different Android phones on the market by the end of 2009. Now, there's no telling what that's including (Europe does seem to get a bit more Android love than the U.S. for example), but in any case, waiting until October or November, you'll see plenty of other things pop up to consider. Also, there will be more than plenty of hands-on reviews of many of the handsets by then.
Also, don't forget, Android is supposed to get at least two new upgrades by years' end. Now, while Android has been known to have release delays, it's likely we'll at least see some Donut (1.6) action before 2010. Some rumors have even said that Eclair (2.0) will include some more social networking-centric features, which may take away some of the special allure of the CLIQ.
Normally, I'd say just buy what looks good now, but this season, I'd really think waiting a few months on Android would be your best bet.
That's way too much. T-Mo: I don't know what you're thinking but you can't sell a phone with only a few subtle improvements over the G1 at a price that's higher than the G1 was when it came out and a year later and expect it to sell well. The freaking iPhone 3GS costs the same amount and it's running with a Cortex A8 and OpenGL 2.0 graphics. Gah!
@MarcusMaximus: Yeah, I kind of agree. I know Motorola's trying to make back some money with this thing, but honestly, it seems a bit much. The CLIQ seems more like the G1's slightly younger brother than it does a whole fantastic new revision. And for all that does, I admit, look good about this phone, it's not nearly as stunning as the Hero.
Then again, there's still a long way to go yet. Maybe we'll hear about a price-drop for this thing. But honestly, T-Mo....as exciting as this phone is, it's not a $200 phone.
Just to fuck with Moto, Palm will drop the Pre to $100 while Apple announced some upgrade to one of its MacBooks, all while Microsoft runs the Windows 7 ad blitz.
@OMG! Ponies!: But people will still ignore the Pre, complaints about the sacrifices in the newer Macbooks will hit the internets the second day, and Windows 7 ads will amount to little more than youtube videos and updated laptop hunter campaigns.
@laptopmemo: I'm not trying to dump on Moto that much. It's just that the Pre is still a darling, Windows 7 has good buzz, and Apple keeps itself at the forefront of people's consciousness.
The beginning of November is when companies make the push to be the big present for Christmas. We're still in a recession and people are likely to be thinking about which gadget to go with for holiday shopping. On the cellphone front, it's all about iPhone, the Pre, and the Android platform. On the computer front, Microsoft is launching its OS just in time for the season and Apple is going to want to counterprogram.
Moto has to cut through all this other buzz. The Cat Stevens myTouch ad is getting heavy airplay (and is wonderfully Applesque) and Kylie is just the first salvo from Redmond. Palm lucked out; they promised and delivered at the same time as Apple letting down the market both with the 3GS (the iPhone 2.5) and the lackluster iPod lineup.
@laptopmemo: You wanted to know why I was dumping.
Hi. You must be new here. I'm OMG! Ponies! and in case you haven't noticed, I'm not a drive-by commenter. Someone wants me to back up what I say, I generally try to pick up the gauntlet.
@booyahku: I'm so pissed off I couldn't register. I totally wanted to host an Install Party just to show that installing Windows was so easy, it could be done blind, stinking drunk.
People don't leave my parties until they've slept it off on my couches and/or floor.
"the Pre is still a darling" Really? By "darling" do you mean lousy sales and no buzz with consumers? And on what planet is anyone waiting for a Windows Mobile phone??
11/02/09
11/02/09
11/02/09
11/02/09
11/02/09
11/02/09
10/20/09
10/15/09
Pffffft I thought you dropped it in a toilet and couldn't photograph it any other way while it was drying. #motorolacliqreview
10/15/09
10/15/09
10/15/09
10/15/09
Like it or not, industrial design and build quality counts these days. The RAZR had it, so what happened here? (Actually, the RAZR hardware had it. The software and UI blew chunks.)
This looks like it was designed by a committee equiped with an "everything but the kitchen sink" feature checklist.
10/15/09
As far as the keyboard goes, they have been doing awful keyboards with terrible buttons because of Six Sigma and making the keyboard a solid strip. They desperately needed to ship this phone and much like the off centered design of the CDMA Q, they shoved it out the door knowing that it would take ages to re-design the hardware. I know they are
"used" to making their own phones, but the keyboard is such a stretch from their previous phones it goes without saying that they would struggle with a new design with better "feeling" keys versus their past "one solid piece" keyboards which were hard to type on.
This is very very positive for a company that has failed in the consumer sector for so long with handsets. It should strengthen the brand name in general. Given the phones offered on T-mo this should do quite well given that they will probably subsidize it more within a month. I know the MyTouch is a competitor, but for social networking and texting a physical keyboard is much much better.
I am not saying this phone is perfect, but this is the direction they are going with their handsets. Variants of this phone with different price-tags etc. should really get the phones selling rather then collecting dust. They already do so well with Boost from Sprint, I can only imagine how many more people would get those phones if it was based on the same platform as the Cliq.
10/15/09
10/14/09
P.s. Marketing a phone is one thing that Gizmodo doesn't really go over when talking about a phone and whether it'll succeed or fail. I know your a tech blog, but this is a major part of the industry, and your review on how slow a phone can be is only half of the story...just sayin'...
10/14/09
Here's to some more competition and the expanding of a good smartphone platform.
10/14/09
10/14/09
10/14/09
09/29/09
Wonder if this can run the Cyanogen ROM?
09/30/09
And please stop bitching about Twitter and Facebook. If you don't want to use them, fine, but others have quite a bit of fun with them. :)
09/30/09
09/29/09
09/29/09
09/29/09
Also, don't forget, Android is supposed to get at least two new upgrades by years' end. Now, while Android has been known to have release delays, it's likely we'll at least see some Donut (1.6) action before 2010. Some rumors have even said that Eclair (2.0) will include some more social networking-centric features, which may take away some of the special allure of the CLIQ.
Normally, I'd say just buy what looks good now, but this season, I'd really think waiting a few months on Android would be your best bet.
09/29/09
09/29/09
Then again, there's still a long way to go yet. Maybe we'll hear about a price-drop for this thing. But honestly, T-Mo....as exciting as this phone is, it's not a $200 phone.
09/29/09
09/29/09
Wow. Harsh words uh?
09/29/09
09/29/09
The beginning of November is when companies make the push to be the big present for Christmas. We're still in a recession and people are likely to be thinking about which gadget to go with for holiday shopping. On the cellphone front, it's all about iPhone, the Pre, and the Android platform. On the computer front, Microsoft is launching its OS just in time for the season and Apple is going to want to counterprogram.
Moto has to cut through all this other buzz. The Cat Stevens myTouch ad is getting heavy airplay (and is wonderfully Applesque) and Kylie is just the first salvo from Redmond. Palm lucked out; they promised and delivered at the same time as Apple letting down the market both with the 3GS (the iPhone 2.5) and the lackluster iPod lineup.
09/29/09
My response:
That's a long response!!!!!
09/29/09
Hi. You must be new here. I'm OMG! Ponies! and in case you haven't noticed, I'm not a drive-by commenter. Someone wants me to back up what I say, I generally try to pick up the gauntlet.
09/29/09
[consumerist.com]
09/29/09
People don't leave my parties until they've slept it off on my couches and/or floor.
09/29/09
"the Pre is still a darling" Really? By "darling" do you mean lousy sales and no buzz with consumers? And on what planet is anyone waiting for a Windows Mobile phone??
09/29/09
Reading is so truly fundamental...