Senior Contributing Editors:
Jesus Diaz
| AIM | Twitter
Mark Wilson, Reviews
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editors:
Matt Buchanan | AIM | Twitter
Adam Frucci | Twitter
Sean Fallon | Twitter
Jack Loftus | Twitter
John Herrman | Twitter
Dan Nosowitz
Chris Mascari
Kat Hannaford | Twitter
Rosa Golijan | Twitter
Chris Jacob
Yet more shoddy science from people that should know better. This octopus is NOT using a tool, it's simply exhibiting nesting behavior. The creature is neither modifying the coconut, nor using it to accomplish a task.
Birds, mice, chimps and gorillas all nest. None of them do anything more than collect materials and arrange them to do so.
Call me when the octopus breaks off piece of coral and uses it like a rasp to reshape the coconut, or uses the coconut like a shovel to dig a hole in then sand. THEN we'll talk about tool use.
There ARE animals that make and use tools - there's a finch that breaks the thorns off a cactus and uses it to impale grubs, and chimps and gorillas strip leaves off twigs and use them to fish termites out of their burrows. THIS is tool use in it's most basic form... and simply moving coconut shells around and hiding under them does NOT qualify.
@Synthfilker: Except that Octopi don't typically use found objects as a nest, they don't typically move their nests around with them, and their nests don't typically have top halves which they use to close themselves inside. Also it appears their method of locomotion when holding the coconut was novel as well. Thus this is far closer to "tool" use than anything Octopi have done previous.
@The5thElephant: Octopi typically "nest" in crevices in reefs. Oddly enough, a reef seemed to be missing from this video, which probably explains why it was improvising with coconut shells. However, it STILL doesn't make it a TOOL. Novel hiding places and movement do NOT make something a tool. (This movement is NOT that unique - Octopi open bivalves in this manner. Also, movement of an object does NOT make the object tool.)
Hiding in a coconut shell is nothing more than nesting behavior, much like a hermit crab.
I guess now all the Watchmen-fans know why the Squid was left out, it was busy getting some quality time with an acquaintance. Getting all hot and steamy, if you know what I mean...
@TheLostVikings: really they left that out of the movie? sweet, that's the one thing I just absolutely could not see a modern movie going audience buying into...
Well, anyway, there is for all practical purposes no visual difference between 1920x1080i and 1920x1080p, and I'm even talking "visual information." Especially if you're talking 1080i60 versus 1080p24, the data rates are much the same. Most of the sources we see at 1080i are heavily compressed (broadcast) sources, so you might think 1080i is "worse" or "bad." An uncompressed 1080i versus uncompressed 1080p24 is going to be undiscernably different except in very unusually high-panning, high-motion scenes (as long as you have a capable de-interlacer).
12/15/09
Wakka wakka wakka.
12/14/09
Birds, mice, chimps and gorillas all nest. None of them do anything more than collect materials and arrange them to do so.
Call me when the octopus breaks off piece of coral and uses it like a rasp to reshape the coconut, or uses the coconut like a shovel to dig a hole in then sand. THEN we'll talk about tool use.
There ARE animals that make and use tools - there's a finch that breaks the thorns off a cactus and uses it to impale grubs, and chimps and gorillas strip leaves off twigs and use them to fish termites out of their burrows. THIS is tool use in it's most basic form... and simply moving coconut shells around and hiding under them does NOT qualify.
12/15/09
Don't be an Octoparty pooper.
12/15/09
Hiding in a coconut shell is nothing more than nesting behavior, much like a hermit crab.
Now don't be an Octopussy. ;)
12/15/09
12/14/09
12/14/09
12/14/09
12/14/09
12/14/09
12/14/09
12/15/09
12/14/09
12/14/09
12/14/09
12/14/09
12/14/09
12/14/09
04/04/09
04/04/09
04/04/09
04/03/09
04/04/09
04/03/09
So awesome.
03/22/09
03/23/09
And bagpipes.
And an accordion.
03/22/09
03/22/09
Yeah, that could never have a laser arc-welder and listening apparati attached to it to be used to hunt down humans.
03/22/09
12/22/08
12/22/08
Now, talk amongst yourselves.
12/22/08
12/22/08