@Coolmodo: This doesn't make any sense...beating the shit out of somebody with a baton is more dangerous than using a taser? What about when they used guns? Wait a second. What if they are handcuffed and the officers take turns hitting them? Jeez I really don't get this. #tasers
Since we're talking about this, is there a study on the relative dangers of candle wax, whipping and voluntary asphyxiation? You never know when you might... uh, run into unexpected situations. #tasers
@Hello Mister Walrus: I just started dating this super-hot goth girl, so I will have an exhaustedly researched study in a few weeks when I get tired of her and move on to something new. #tasers
@nutbastard: No broken bones, bruises, head trauma, internal injuries, etc. When you have to violently subdue someone vs. tazing them, you run the risk of inflicting damage on them. While some cops do get taze happy and taze too much, I can guarantee you that if a cop has to use physical force, there will be much more force than is needed to take you down. I have no intention of being tazed, but I would much rather be tazed than have my ass handed to me. #tasers
@nutbastard: I think it has to do with adrenaline mixed with anger more than anything. Cops do not like to have to resort to physical confrontations as they are dangerous to them. If they do have to, that adrenaline mixed with anger at the end is likely to result in some cheap shots. Is it right? By no means, but at the same time, it is incredibly hard to control at any level of training. #tasers
i agree. it's impossible to dial in the right amount of force, and when it's your ass on the line, you tend to err on the side of excess, since the alternative could get you killed. #tasers
@Nathan Obbards: I'm not so sure about how I feel about the "... at any level of training." I've always felt like humanity should in general be better at controlling emotion and response, but more than that anyone with the right training I think should be expected to avoid "cheap shots." Those are for you and me in a bar, not for people with "potentially violent confrontation" in their job description. #tasers
@phool: I agree that they should be able to harness their emotions better, but it can be hard. Honestly, my stance is that if we actually started treating cops with more respect, it would be reciprocated, but if you are treated like shit day in day out by people, it can be hard not to let it get to you. There are some truly great cops out there and there are some people who should be behind bars, not putting people behind bars. I do stand by that claim though, that in the heat of the moment, no matter how well you are trained, it can be hard to know when to stop. I also think that, though understandable, cops who take cheap shots should be reprimanded, and not in the ''take a paid week off'' kind of way. #tasers
I guess, since a taser was used, that this is a suitable post for a gadget blog.
But, sarcasm aside, it wasn't a 'Travis County cop', just a deputy constable (they're separate offices and chains of command - just do a little research on it).
From the post: "...you could toss her in a cop car with one arm tied behind your back if you wanted to..." That's pure conjecture, especially since you've never tried to do that to someone hyped up on stubbornness and adrenaline (regardless of age): you have no idea what she was capable of - she might have hurt herself while resisting physical restraint - which could be concluded she would have resisted. Did you notice how she snatched her arm out of the hand of the officer? Besides, she was offended that she, an old lady, was pushed. It's like she choose the alternative for the cop.
Also, what would have been 'horrific' would be if, while the cop spent several minutes trying to get the granny to comply while she was still in the relative safety of her truck, he would have been struck by a passing motorist. Or, if the lady, while still being uncooperative, was struck while trying to get back in her truck.
"The best part-the cop actually expected her to put her arms behind her back after being tased." ...and she did after the being tased a SECOND time.
And finally, Adrian, here's the kicker quote for you: "At the end of the day that officer went home to his kids uninjured and that woman - although she spent a night in the Travis County Jail - she did it uninjured. She didn't have to go to the hospital."
Do you understand how important those two goals are?
@Unspellable: This entire ramble is "pure conjecture".... If you watch the snippet from the begining of what is shown, the officer is in the wrong, he already is yelling at her and pushing her without any sort of retort from her patiently leaning at the end of her truck. A different path could've been taken that could be considered, "by the book". Frankly he many paths and options, and ran himself firmly down this one. I've always been told ignorance is bliss, and I can only assume you are proudly happy with your response.
@Garrett Brooks: When she was out of the car, she was being placed under arrest, as she had just committed a crime(not signing the ticket for speeding through a active construction zone 15mph OVER the limit). As for her "patiently leaning on the truck", this was after five minutes of the cop trying to get her to sign the ticket, according to the time stamp on the dashcam. She also dares him to taze her and was already using abusive language.
@Garrett Brooks: Plus, she had already lied repeatedly to the public and news reporters saying everything shown in the dash cam which was listed on the police report was "a lie". As soon as this video was released, she cancelled all interviews and referred everyone to her attorney.
2) My mother is of a similar age. She is not a jackass like this woman is, but she also can't put her hands behind her back because she's had shoulder surgery. I hear her pretty clearly saying that she's unable to comply, so I question whether he should really be tasing her again at this point.
3) She was clearly belligerant, but he was clearly frustrated (look at how he acts when he pulls out his cuffs), so I'm thinking he's not totally blameless in this one.
@MikeK: If you check the longer videos, five minutes elapse from when he tries getting her to sign the ticket until he pulls her out to arrest her(It's against the law in TX to not sign a ticket, from what I have read). After five minutes, I'd be frustrated too if this lady was saying the same shit she was saying such as daring him to taze her.
Tasering the elderly is probably a bad idea in general, right? I mean, there's a fairly good chance that they have pacemakers, right? It's my understanding that zapping the shit out of old folks with electrically sensitive equipment keeping them alive is probably a bad idea.
Tasering was a bad idea. Cuffin' and stuffin', as Roscoe P. Coltrane would say, would have been a better one.
@TonyRockyHorror: A pacemaker can withstand a defibrillator. A tazer put nowhere NEAR the power out that a defib does. You can hold a person being tazed. You can't hold a person getting defibbed. Which is why they say "CLEAR!!" before doing it.
This cop went by the book. If you actually watch the video you'll see that she makes her way closer to the road numerous times, putting both her and the cop in danger. Also, if he were to force her arms into place to cuff her, he could have broken her bones.
The best thing to do was to immobilize her and cuff her.
Also, she was being an unruly bitch. Never be an unruly bitch to someone with legal power over you in front of a video camera. If she does press charges, she will lose because it was her own damn fault.
And those of you advocating pepper spray, have you been pepper sprayed? It burns like hell. Pepper spray is far more brutal than a TASER.
@eriklindemann: I agree. I have said here MANY times that if you are calm, and the tape is shown in court, then guess who wins? Remember the football player who's Mother In Law died? He was calm throughout and he got an apology. But he also didn't fight with the cop like this lady did. If you watch the video in the comments above, you can see 5 minutes of tape tick by as he tries to get her to sign the ticket before her pulls her out. 5 MINUTES?!?! That's A LOT of slack the cop is cutting you. Then she goes on TV and LIES ABOUT IT! Of course, since the tape was released, she has not spoken. Hmmmmm
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/18/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
@00000000: Here. #tasers
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
in colleges, it's "don't haze me, bro!"
for native americans, it's "don't maize me, bro!"
you could threaten a snot rocket: "don't nase me, bro!"
or try to shave them against their will:
"don't raze me, bro!"
in an art museum: "don't vase me, bro!"
when dealing with an unaccepting orphan:
"don't raise me, bro!"
11/17/09
11/17/09
While being hit in the face, it's "don't daze me, bro!"
While being Steve Jobs, it's "turtlenecks ARE TOO 2009!" #tasers
11/17/09
11/17/09
so what, they miss 65% of the time? because as far as i can tell, getting tased has a 100% chance of causing injury.
11/17/09
11/17/09
true true. cops and football players have a tendency to give 110%. #tasers
11/17/09
11/17/09
i agree. it's impossible to dial in the right amount of force, and when it's your ass on the line, you tend to err on the side of excess, since the alternative could get you killed. #tasers
11/17/09
"'Scuse me, sir? I think you dropped this."
Oh, my. Thank you. It would have been a very long flight. #tasers
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
11/17/09
06/17/09
I guess, since a taser was used, that this is a suitable post for a gadget blog.
But, sarcasm aside, it wasn't a 'Travis County cop', just a deputy constable (they're separate offices and chains of command - just do a little research on it).
From the post: "...you could toss her in a cop car with one arm tied behind your back if you wanted to..." That's pure conjecture, especially since you've never tried to do that to someone hyped up on stubbornness and adrenaline (regardless of age): you have no idea what she was capable of - she might have hurt herself while resisting physical restraint - which could be concluded she would have resisted. Did you notice how she snatched her arm out of the hand of the officer? Besides, she was offended that she, an old lady, was pushed. It's like she choose the alternative for the cop.
Also, what would have been 'horrific' would be if, while the cop spent several minutes trying to get the granny to comply while she was still in the relative safety of her truck, he would have been struck by a passing motorist. Or, if the lady, while still being uncooperative, was struck while trying to get back in her truck.
"The best part-the cop actually expected her to put her arms behind her back after being tased." ...and she did after the being tased a SECOND time.
And finally, Adrian, here's the kicker quote for you: "At the end of the day that officer went home to his kids uninjured and that woman - although she spent a night in the Travis County Jail - she did it uninjured. She didn't have to go to the hospital."
Do you understand how important those two goals are?
06/17/09
06/17/09
06/17/09
06/17/09
2) My mother is of a similar age. She is not a jackass like this woman is, but she also can't put her hands behind her back because she's had shoulder surgery. I hear her pretty clearly saying that she's unable to comply, so I question whether he should really be tasing her again at this point.
3) She was clearly belligerant, but he was clearly frustrated (look at how he acts when he pulls out his cuffs), so I'm thinking he's not totally blameless in this one.
06/17/09
06/17/09
Tasering was a bad idea. Cuffin' and stuffin', as Roscoe P. Coltrane would say, would have been a better one.
06/17/09
06/16/09
The best thing to do was to immobilize her and cuff her.
Also, she was being an unruly bitch. Never be an unruly bitch to someone with legal power over you in front of a video camera. If she does press charges, she will lose because it was her own damn fault.
And those of you advocating pepper spray, have you been pepper sprayed? It burns like hell. Pepper spray is far more brutal than a TASER.
06/17/09