datarot - Gizmodo

posts about #datarot more →
There's No Great Solution for Data Rot

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

Purple Dave
03/27/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
If your DVDs are going bad in a little over five years, then perhaps you should stop filing them in the sandbox.
Reply

Purple Dave was starred Purple Dave was unstarred

Jesse in Japan
03/26/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
For the really important data, you've got to get it tattooed all over your body.
Reply

Jesse in Japan was starred Jesse in Japan was unstarred

fuchikoma
03/26/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
I've known about this for a while, and I have ten year old CDs that have gone south (and a surprising number that are still ok...) but sadly the technology isn't there to make this feasible yet. I have spools upon spools of DVDs, and I simply can't afford to back them all up and reburn them - financially or time-wise.

Sad, but at least my interests change enough in ten years that MOST of them won't matter that much. Still, it would suck to pull one from the library and find it unreadable!
Reply

fuchikoma was starred fuchikoma was unstarred

Jonny Morris
03/26/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
This is a huge problem for government too. Back in the day, to comply with various regulations for achiving govt. publications, it was easy enough to have the GPO print off a few extra copies of any given publication and send it over to the Lib of Congress or the Nat'l Archives (depending on what it was). Now, so many agencies product papers, reports, etc. exclusively in electronic format, it's hard for them to know what exactly to save and how to save it.

I wrote a paper a couple years ago on this. Talking to library scientists and archivists (two of the most action-packed jobs in the world, I imagine), the general consensus is that in 100 years, we'll know more about govt records in the 19th and 20th centuries than our current period.

That isn't stopping the govt, however, from paying millions to contractors like Lockheed from developing proprietary storage for electronic records, along with crawlers to ensure electornic publications from govt website get stored.
Reply

Jonny Morris was starred Jonny Morris was unstarred

Sora57 is OK
03/26/09

@Jonny Morris: And don't forget microfilm and microfiche back in the day.
Reply

Sora57 is OK was starred Sora57 is OK was unstarred

Sora57 is OK
03/26/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
I archived my home movies shot on 8mm/16mm/and videotape to DVD and keep the original source material in a cool, dry dark place. In a few years, I'll copy the DVDs again and/or archive them to whatever format is current at the time. Same with a small selection of photos.

The other stuff is not worth saving. Archive only what matters, or everything gets lost in sea of crap.
Reply

Sora57 is OK was starred Sora57 is OK was unstarred

nutbastard
03/26/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
nah you gotta carve it all into stone.

100101101010010101010100000101...^999999999999999999999999999
Reply

nutbastard was starred nutbastard was unstarred

Sora57 is OK
03/26/09

@nutbastard (Everyone come to snowmodo!!!): 01110111 01101000 01100001 01110100 00100000 01110100 01101000 01100101 00100000 01101000 01100101 01101100 01101100 00100000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01110100 01101000 01100001 01110100 00111111
Reply

Sora57 is OK was starred Sora57 is OK was unstarred

Kaiser-Machead
03/26/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
Well, I also consider that any truly important documents will either be part of public record that I can retrieve, or eventually lose relevance as their purpose is outlived. Photos can pass between thumb drives. As gigabytes get cheaper by the bit, swapping and exchanging will be a breeze. As system buses get faster, transfer times will become a snap. Movies I loved on my hard drive will either lose my interest or can be repurchased or rented years later on whatever new-fangled format is out.

My porn?

Well, I could always get married, and make my own.
Reply

Kaiser-Machead was starred Kaiser-Machead was unstarred

bjarnia
03/26/09

@Kaiser-Machead: "As gigabytes get cheaper by the bit, swapping and exchanging will be a breeze."

You fail to realize that at the same time, the size of the data you are backing up will increase as well.
Reply

bjarnia was starred bjarnia was unstarred

Kaiser-Machead
03/26/09

@bjarnia: As will the size of the new external volume.
Reply

Kaiser-Machead was starred Kaiser-Machead was unstarred

nachobel
03/26/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
bring back the scribes!
Reply

nachobel was starred nachobel was unstarred

GitEmSteveDave_HatesFriday
03/26/09

@nachobel: Would you settle for Mormons? Or at least Narns?
Reply

Brazell
03/26/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
The vast majority of stuff saved on your computer is complete trash that should fade away and degrade with the medium that's holding it.

Anything truely important -- public records of land deeds, titles, wills, etc., -- are almost all stored on mediums and through solutions where a party is interested in keeping that material working and relevant.

Your Bachelor degree thesis on Crime & Punishment, saved in WordPerfect 2 format on a floppy disk somewhere in the annals of your attick? Not important, and it's better left lost and gone forever.
Reply

Brazell was starred Brazell was unstarred

Kaiser-Machead
03/26/09

@MichaelBrazell: Dang I was saying the same thing you were saying. GET OUT OF MY HEAD!
Reply

Kaiser-Machead was starred Kaiser-Machead was unstarred

Monty
03/26/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
The alternative is that our information will live on forever, and at the rate we are accumulating this data, that would probably be as bad as the concept that eventually it will rot. Converting it to different formats once a decade or so (which technology forces us to do anyway) is probably fine, and then when our bodies rot, chances are our descendants will conveniently forget to do this.
Reply

Monty was starred Monty was unstarred

Hello Mister Walrus
03/26/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
My pron! Oh noes!!
Reply

GitEmSteveDave_HatesFriday
03/26/09

In reply to There's No Great Solution for Data Rot
I always wonder if there is a Rosetta Room somewhere. Meaning a room filled with a variety of different media readers/displays and a way to power them.

The only thing I don't worry about is Macs. B/c real Mac users have at least three Macs in various forms chipmunked away under some stairs or in a display case that will still fire up and can be used.
Reply

bosskev
03/26/09

@KingBananaHammock_GitEmSteveDa...: "B/c real Mac users have at least three Macs in various forms chipmunked away..."

* scoffs *

...at least three? Three?

* scoffs again *

Try rephrasing that with double digits and get back to me.

* heads to kitchen for sandwich *

* trips over Quadra 840AV *

* landing face first into "Flower Power" iMac *
Reply

bosskev was starred bosskev was unstarred

GitEmSteveDave_HatesFriday
03/26/09

@bosskev: This the word "least". I was also referring to "Real Mac Users". Not "True Mac Fanatics", "Mac Diehards", "Apple Fanbois", etc... Those will have more. Rememeber, a Apple Fanboi is a Real Mac User, but a Real Mac User isn't a Apple Fanboi.

I need to listen to some Avril now...
Reply

crackblind
03/26/09

@KingBananaHammock_GitEmSteveDa...: You know, I've been meaning to do something with that IIe in the corner.
Reply

crackblind was starred crackblind was unstarred

RobotVampire
03/26/09

@crackblind: "that's IIe in the corner, that's IIe in the spot-light losing my data retention..."

;)
Reply

RobotVampire was starred RobotVampire was unstarred

bosskev
03/26/09

@RobotVampire: +1
Reply

bosskev was starred bosskev was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#datarot

Gizmodo

Gizmodo Team

SUBSCRIBE TO Gizmodo

There's No Great Solution for Data Rot

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment