This looks like a great idea. I've been playing a little Audiosurf lately, and as many have already stated, this looks to be in the same vein. Awesome. #musiclibrarygame
@HeartBurnKid: Agent of R.O.A.C.H.: YES! I was trying to remember Audiosurf. You can so cheat at Audiosurf though...choose an ambient song with long loops and the track is a breeze. Metal...makes for some tough tracks at higher levels. #musiclibrarygame
@smegz: True, but considering the scoreboard only ranks you against other people doing the same track... "cheating" that way does make it easier to get all the achievements, though. #musiclibrarygame
The Beatles entire catalog is on Apple Records. This has existed long before Apple Computer. In fact there was a big trademark dispute shortly after Apple Computer Started getting big. For more history: [en.wikipedia.org]#thebeatlesappleusbstick
Danny, is this basically the "digital" stick version of what the Mono and Stereo boxset collections are? I just purchased both the Mono and Stereo sets off Amazon for a hefty $500 and I just saw the Miles Davis collection on Uncrate for $330 ( [www.uncrate.com] ). These labels need to chill for a little. I can't keep spending cash like this haha. #thebeatlesappleusbstick
@Lizard_King: Yeah it's odd. Over the past 2 years, I've had a few audio related purchases. Mostly vinyl collections and limited releases from Portishead and the like. But this is becoming insane to the point where I've spent over $1000 in less than 3 months. #thebeatlesappleusbstick
@OMG! Ponies!: Yes! Thank you for posting this. I don't understand the big deal -- isn't it better to buy nice lossless CDs, rip them at whatever bit rate you want, and then permanently tuck them away as backup?
I bought the stereo boxed set. Took maybe an hour to rip. And in a few years when we all have 32 TB music players that can hold all the uncompressed music in the world, I'll still have pristine copies of the stuff at my disposal. #thebeatlesappleusbstick
@abadomaX: From what I can tell, there is an exception for temporary, erasable copies. Because otherwise you couldn't sell (or even own) mp3 players of any kind in Europe as it necessarily requires the duplication of copyrighted material to function. #thebeatlesappleusbstick
The ad copy sounds like it was written by Smoove B. "We will use only the finest error correcting software. Also, there will be chocolate-covered strawberries.
Okay, I'm going to have to disagree with this article. All of us come here because we know our shit regarding technology, and to us this is ridiculously easy and second nature. But we are not in the majority - or at least there is a huge group who is very much unlike us.
So many people are completely uninterested in learning how to do this, afraid they will do it incorrectly, or simply don't want to spend their time doing this themselves.
My future mother-in-law uses technology all the time, but she is a serious techophobe. She really has no idea what she is doing. She gave me her camera so I could take the pictures off and email them to her. With people like this, they just don't want to put the effort into learning how to do this.
Yeah you go try telling an older person with no tech experience how to rip their own music. You'll start by telling them to download itunes or some ripping program, and once you realize that you lose them at that step, you will see that telling them about ID3 tags and different formats is way above their league.
To us, this appears like Geek Squad is taking advantage of people. In reality, this shit takes time and requires a level of understanding that a lot of people don't have. So, it makes sense to offer a service for those willing to pay for it.
@MrBlahBlah: I see your point, but if they can't figure out how to download or install itunes they probably have little use for ripped audio files, especially in DVD format. Hand this same person a DVD full of AAC files and they'll have no way to play them or load them on any portable device.
I could see this service making sense if they are purchasing an iPod at the time and having their library loaded on, but that would be a rather silly hing to do, what happens if you buy a new CD?
It's easy enough to walk someone through an iTunes install, go to apple../itunes, click download, wait, double click, done. To rip cd, insert cd, click import at bottom. Wouldn't it be better to just show them how to do this in the store? Apple does this for free. That's why this service reeks of a bad deal.
@Hooray4Zoidberg: "Wouldn't it be better to just show them how to do this in the store? Apple does this for free. That's why this service reeks of a bad deal"
The thing is, some people just don't care. They don't want to bother. Maybe the want their library loaded up for them and after that they'll hassle their son in law to help them.
Just cause they don't have any tech knowledge doens't mean they don't want an mp3 player.
Also, if they are willing to pay for the service, who cares? They are big people. They know they can figure it out if they want.
@MrBlahBlah: You're actually right but one thing that is pointed out in the article is that the people who are TOO LAZY will be the ones to do this. And/or the people who are totally against upgrading their computer and they cant do it on their home computer because it'll freeze, lag, crash or all of the above.
The internet's here for a reason. And google is here for a reason too.
I learned how to translate base-16 to binary code all through google x_x and i did that for my computer science class. Now i know some people might not be able to do that even though it really isnt that hard once you understand the whole concept
there are just people who are oblivious to doing things themselves. My father thinks everytime his computer slows down its because his computer has a virus. We can't forget that people like that still exist and will forever exist as long as there is technology. Maybe not the same way but people who just are incapable of doing things on their own and dont actually try to find a solution on their own.
@MrBlahBlah: True that. I've shown my wife like 15 times how to rip a CD, and she still complains that not all of her music is on the computer. It actually is, she just can't find all of it because she doesn't think to look in "Various Artist" folders and the like.
I worked as a Geek Squad agent and succeeded in ripping off the masses. There isn't a day that goes by that I don't think about what I did and ask for forgiveness. I agree with the tone of this article. Sure, Geek Squad performs a service, that's not the problem. The problem is in the way Geek Squad does it. I think it's very dishonest and we prey on the weak. The services are definitely over priced, and the goal is to justify and scare by using big tech words.
@notlikeacat: Actually, anytime someone asks me to put something on a CD for them, I charge them $40/hour in labor, with a minimum of five hours labor. Plus the cost of CDs ($5/disc) and electricity used to power the machine (we'll say....$30). As you can see, because I charge an even more unreasonable amount of money, OfficeMax has a good deal.
It is also sad that there are people who rely entirely on technology for THERE every need, and neglect other aspects of life. No need to get angry good sir, it is just a service being provided to the masses.
I could make myself a sandwich for lunch, but sometimes I like to purchase the delicious alternative at the local deli. All of this discussion is just basic economics and opportunity cost, where should I spend my time and money? Right now I think I am spending my time constructively commenting online, instead of working where I could be earning money.
@PrimroseSkunk:
It's 'their', not 'there'. Looks like you should of been not commenting on Gizmodo articles when you were in school as well. Get back to work.
@PrimroseSkunk:
The difference is that Geek Squad are just there to exploit those that don't know better. To take your sandwich analogy Geek Squad would be an overpriced sandwich shop that made substandard sandwichs at substandard speeds. Their target demographic is people that don't know how to make sandwichs and are therefore forced to pay for Geek Squads sandwich services despite how easy sandwich making is.
This is just Geek Squad dogpiling. Should do for free?! Where did you grow up Mr. Herman? In the USA man power, less it be community service or likewise, costs money. A buck just covers most CC transaction fees. It's a service that will survive or die based on demand.
This is one of those Giz "fails." No story here, except a minor service offered for an even more minor price.
@Thangka: I'm with you on this one. Ripping a CD at good quality can take several minutes. Let's say it takes 3 minutes to rip a CD. That's 20 CDs an hour = $20/hour. BB ain't going to get rich doing this for people as I see it. Even if you can rip 40 CDs an hour, it's still not excessive in my opinion for what amounts to a convenience service for the technically-challenged.
Do you know why milk costs more at a 7-11 than at the supermarket? Convenience. People are often willing to pay more for conveniences. If you don't like it, don't buy it.
Why should BB provide any service for free? They're a business, they exist to separate people from their dollars and make a profit. If you know how to rip music, great! Why don't you lease commercial space next to a BB and offer to do it for people for free.
11/13/09
11/12/09
11/12/09
11/12/09
11/12/09
11/12/09
What are these.... Space Invaders you speak of? #musiclibrarygame
11/12/09
11/13/09
*psh* At least you acknowledge that my bed time is measured in decades and not hours... #musiclibrarygame
11/04/09
The Beatles entire catalog is on Apple Records. This has existed long before Apple Computer. In fact there was a big trademark dispute shortly after Apple Computer Started getting big. For more history: [en.wikipedia.org] #thebeatlesappleusbstick
11/04/09
11/04/09
11/04/09
I think this is just stereo mixes - you still MUST get the mono CDs if you purchase this. #thebeatlesappleusbstick
11/04/09
11/04/09
Rip the CD #thebeatlesappleusbstick
11/04/09
11/04/09
I bought the stereo boxed set. Took maybe an hour to rip. And in a few years when we all have 32 TB music players that can hold all the uncompressed music in the world, I'll still have pristine copies of the stuff at my disposal. #thebeatlesappleusbstick
11/04/09
09/18/09
Damn, your CDs are going to get ripped. Yeah."
09/18/09
So many people are completely uninterested in learning how to do this, afraid they will do it incorrectly, or simply don't want to spend their time doing this themselves.
My future mother-in-law uses technology all the time, but she is a serious techophobe. She really has no idea what she is doing. She gave me her camera so I could take the pictures off and email them to her. With people like this, they just don't want to put the effort into learning how to do this.
Yeah you go try telling an older person with no tech experience how to rip their own music. You'll start by telling them to download itunes or some ripping program, and once you realize that you lose them at that step, you will see that telling them about ID3 tags and different formats is way above their league.
To us, this appears like Geek Squad is taking advantage of people. In reality, this shit takes time and requires a level of understanding that a lot of people don't have. So, it makes sense to offer a service for those willing to pay for it.
09/18/09
I could see this service making sense if they are purchasing an iPod at the time and having their library loaded on, but that would be a rather silly hing to do, what happens if you buy a new CD?
It's easy enough to walk someone through an iTunes install, go to apple../itunes, click download, wait, double click, done. To rip cd, insert cd, click import at bottom. Wouldn't it be better to just show them how to do this in the store? Apple does this for free. That's why this service reeks of a bad deal.
09/18/09
The thing is, some people just don't care. They don't want to bother. Maybe the want their library loaded up for them and after that they'll hassle their son in law to help them.
Just cause they don't have any tech knowledge doens't mean they don't want an mp3 player.
Also, if they are willing to pay for the service, who cares? They are big people. They know they can figure it out if they want.
09/18/09
The internet's here for a reason. And google is here for a reason too.
I learned how to translate base-16 to binary code all through google x_x and i did that for my computer science class. Now i know some people might not be able to do that even though it really isnt that hard once you understand the whole concept
there are just people who are oblivious to doing things themselves. My father thinks everytime his computer slows down its because his computer has a virus. We can't forget that people like that still exist and will forever exist as long as there is technology. Maybe not the same way but people who just are incapable of doing things on their own and dont actually try to find a solution on their own.
09/18/09
09/18/09
09/18/09
09/18/09
09/18/09
09/18/09
09/18/09
09/18/09
I could make myself a sandwich for lunch, but sometimes I like to purchase the delicious alternative at the local deli. All of this discussion is just basic economics and opportunity cost, where should I spend my time and money? Right now I think I am spending my time constructively commenting online, instead of working where I could be earning money.
09/18/09
It's 'their', not 'there'. Looks like you should of been not commenting on Gizmodo articles when you were in school as well. Get back to work.
09/18/09
The difference is that Geek Squad are just there to exploit those that don't know better. To take your sandwich analogy Geek Squad would be an overpriced sandwich shop that made substandard sandwichs at substandard speeds. Their target demographic is people that don't know how to make sandwichs and are therefore forced to pay for Geek Squads sandwich services despite how easy sandwich making is.
09/18/09
09/18/09
09/18/09
This is one of those Giz "fails." No story here, except a minor service offered for an even more minor price.
09/18/09
Do you know why milk costs more at a 7-11 than at the supermarket? Convenience. People are often willing to pay more for conveniences. If you don't like it, don't buy it.
Why should BB provide any service for free? They're a business, they exist to separate people from their dollars and make a profit. If you know how to rip music, great! Why don't you lease commercial space next to a BB and offer to do it for people for free.
/rant
09/18/09
I worked for GS