hardware keyboard

posts about #hardwarekeyboard more →
Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

TheWerewolf - Sotto voce
07/11/09

In reply to Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard
Or in other words, there are times when the onscreen keyboard is more expedient (like a fast SMS) and other times when the keyboard makes more sense (like typing in email).

I kind of get where they're coming from though. My MDA has a slide out keyboard, and like all WiMo devices, also has an onscreen keyboard, Graffiti (like Palm), Jot/letter writing and full on handwriting reco.

I found I was using ALL of them - each one for different situations.
Reply

MaQ
07/11/09

In reply to Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard
I do not own nether iPhone nor Pre, but I did play with the iPod Touch

and enjoyed the soft keyboard, so when Pre was announced, I Pre-sumed that it would have a soft one too.

I'm a programmer

and when Pre gsm comes out, and I get it, I'll write one for myself, at least.

Don't know why it wasn't included in the first place.
Reply

MaQ was starred MaQ was unstarred

TessCulver
07/11/09

In reply to Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard
"One of the biggest, loudest complaints about all-touchscreen phones like the iPhone is its lack of a hardware keyboard, and now a survey shows Pre users most want a soft keyboard."

First I laughed long, then I laughed hard, then I laughed loudly...

I love the iPhone touch keyboard.
People whining about it still had last century's phones with about 50 too small to use plastic buttons...

You've seen the future, you don't need a zillion buttons any more...

Reply

TessCulver was starred TessCulver was unstarred

Con Seannery
07/11/09

@TessCulver: I. LIKE. MY. BUTTONS. I also haven't picked up the soft keyboard for must uses...the physical one feels better to use...G1 owner, best phone on the market.
Reply

Con Seannery was starred Con Seannery was unstarred

Identity (Metric)
07/11/09

@TessCulver: To each his/her own. I don't mind software, but I prefer hardware. Say for example you wanted to type a url into the address bar.

iPhone: click address bar, type.

Pre: type.

Sometimes it saves time, and usually it's a lot easier to type while not looking.
Reply

Identity (Metric) was starred

quayzar
07/12/09

@my secret identity: I always had trouble with small hardware keyboards so the iPhone's keyboard was just about perfect for me.

I previously had a Samsung Blackjack II and that physical keyboard that I found just awful especially since my passwords are based of a Qwerty desktop keyboard.
Reply

quayzar was starred quayzar was unstarred

Identity (Metric)
07/12/09

@quayzar: I get that. I loved the keyboard on the Blackjack I, but loathed the one on the II.

With that said though, I do like having the option, and I would like it if both (Pre and iPhone) had both.
Reply

Identity (Metric) was starred

switchblade saints
07/11/09

In reply to Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard
I was the same way with my g1 waiting for the cupcake update.

Honestly after wanting the soft keyboard so bad I think I have used it twice. I found myself using the same argument also, "the soft keyboard would be handy for quick replies..." but to be honest its easier just kicking out the keypad and typing faster on the keys. The onscreen is slower.
Reply

switchblade saints was starred

Con Seannery
07/11/09

@switchblade saints: Same here...while I bitched, I got used to the wonderful feature of a REAL KEYBOARD.
Reply

Con Seannery was starred Con Seannery was unstarred

NurseDave
07/11/09

In reply to Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard
I have a pre, and while for a short reply or typing the few letters it gets to bring up a contact it would be nice not have to slide the keyboard out, but I have no problems sliding it out and typing one handed.

...haha he said "sliding it out" Pre-reply posted for you.
Reply

NurseDave was starred NurseDave was unstarred

LeighMnemosyne
07/11/09

In reply to Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard
It's not really a preposterous thing to want. I am a Palm Pre user and when I'm typing long texts and e-mails theres no way anyone on a virtual keyboard could do it faster/more accurate. We do love our physical keyboard. But when you want to type in someone's initials real quick to find them on universal search, it's a little much to slide out the keyboard for 2 letters then close it. It would also be very handy in the browser, because a virtual keyboard could orient itself in landscape, unlike the physical keyboard which is always portrait.
Reply

LeighMnemosyne was starred LeighMnemosyne was unstarred

Monty
07/11/09

@LeighMnemosyne: I never underestimate the reality distortion field that spreads throughout our universe from the home office in Cupertino.

I can understand the desire to have an on-screen keyboard option in rare circumstances when you are driving in rush hour traffic drinking a latte and needing to send a quick text message to the arrogant mother in law and not wanting to pull out the keyboard. Or, maybe not.

I agree with your point. On screen keyboards can be useful, but not practical for real typing, in my opinion. Still, I suspect most iPhone owners would argue that point, so - what do I know? I just need to suck in that tasty field energy and go with the flow.
Reply

Edited by Monty at 07/11/09 4:00 PM Monty was starred Monty was unstarred

Con Seannery
07/11/09

@Monty: I got dinged by that field near an Apple store... I ALMOST went in, too. Fortunately, I had my G1 in my pocket to protect me and I was just driving by...ALMOST pulled into a space, but I was about 8 feet from that door. I wasn't right for the rest of the day...rampant typos, a faint headache, losing my train of thought more often than normal... Powerful fields, man.
Reply

Con Seannery was starred Con Seannery was unstarred

Bobby Woods
07/11/09

In reply to Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard
This really doesn't surprise me.. But they should've known what they were getting in to. I think having both would just be weird.. I'll take my iPhone keyboard any day. It's much easier to tap a screen than it is to push a button. That's why the fastest texters are on the iPhone..
Reply

Bobby Woods was starred Bobby Woods was unstarred

Con Seannery
07/11/09

@Bobby Woods: Well, that, and you don't have to get anywhere close to being right on the spelling and it'll fill it in for you...on a non-predictive touch keyboard and a non-predictive physical keyboard, I can blast out some text much faster on the real keyboard...throw in the G1's suggestions (no autocorrect, I don't think...I haven't actually tried it to see, I always go back to fix the mistakes...) and it's close to as fast as the physical keyboard...
Reply

Con Seannery was starred Con Seannery was unstarred

[Medic]iEro-Sennin
07/11/09

In reply to Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard
Shows that no matter what you do, there will always be some people complaining about it.

What a sad world we live in. :'(

WHERE IS THAT PREVIEW BUTTON; GOD DAMNIT?!
Reply

[Medic]iEro-Sennin was starred

Nick
07/11/09

In reply to Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard
sometimes i drop my pants and sometimes i just undo the zipper. i think it's the same principle here.
and no, not all the way down to my ankles.
Reply

Nick was starred Nick was unstarred

MeanMF
07/11/09

@Nick: You might find typing easier if you use your thumbs.
Reply

MeanMF was starred MeanMF was unstarred

SysRq
07/11/09

@Nick: It's actually more like that than you think.
Reply

SysRq was starred SysRq was unstarred

Invisible-Echidna
07/11/09

@Nick:

It sounds like AT&T users drop them all the way down to the ankles.
Reply

Invisible-Echidna was starred

Nick
07/11/09

@MeanMF: easier for you maybe, but that's why the ladies love me.
Reply

Nick was starred Nick was unstarred

Con Seannery
07/11/09

@Invisible-Echidna: With those prices, they've gotta open the backdoor for the Death Star...
Reply

Edited by Con Seannery at 07/11/09 6:24 PM Con Seannery was starred Con Seannery was unstarred

TheShredder
07/11/09

In reply to Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard
I dont think it's a ridiculous complaint. Why slide out the keyboard every time?
Reply

TheShredder was starred TheShredder was unstarred

NurseDave
07/11/09

@TheShredder: Because that's where it is.
Reply

NurseDave was starred NurseDave was unstarred

SysRq
07/11/09

@TheShredder: Because you don't have an iPhone.

This is a good example of people whining because they didn't do their research. They knew the Pre didn't have an onscreen keyboard, just like iPhone owners know the iPhone doesn't have a physical keyboard. And yet the chose the phone they did because of...well, who knows why. Shut up and enjoy your damn phone.
Reply

SysRq was starred SysRq was unstarred

PhineasJW
07/11/09

@SysRq: Not an entirely good analogy. An onscreen keyboard is just software, therefore, it only takes an OS update. A phone that never had a hardware keyboard (iPhone) can never have a hardware keyboard.
Reply

PhineasJW was starred PhineasJW was unstarred

Con Seannery
07/11/09

@SysRq: Well, you know, some people like a phone that can actually do...anything. They also don't care to look like a complete tool when they take a phone call, and they like having more than one button. Throw in the fact that AT&T blows, the iPhone is all hype and no value, and there are better phones out there in all areas from all carriers, and you've got yourself an answer.
Reply

Con Seannery was starred Con Seannery was unstarred

TheWerewolf - Sotto voce
07/11/09

@SysRq: Actually - *I* have an iPhone. And two WiMo phones, one with and one without a slide out keyboard.

And simply put: the reason you don't get it is because you've never tried it.

Which makes owning an iPhone the cellphone equivalent of only eating at McDonalds and suggesting that no one really likes Beef Wellington because it has that icky liverwurst inside.
Reply

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#hardwarekeyboard

Gizmodo

Gizmodo Team

Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard

#hardwarekeyboard

Gizmodo

Gizmodo Team

SUBSCRIBE TO Gizmodo

Palm Pre Users Complain About Lack of On-Screen Keyboard

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment