Senior Contributing Editors:
Jesus Diaz
| AIM | Twitter
Mark Wilson, Reviews
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editors:
Matt Buchanan | AIM | Twitter
Adam Frucci | Twitter
Sean Fallon | Twitter
Jack Loftus | Twitter
John Herrman | Twitter
Dan Nosowitz
Chris Mascari
Kat Hannaford | Twitter
Rosa Golijan | Twitter
Chris Jacob
So really Foxconn are admitting responsibility for the man's death? I'm sure things work differently in China then here in Western Europe but isn't that's a strange thing to do considering the rumours of shady goings on?
He wasn't killed in a workplace accident so there would be no reason for them to give such a payment to the family except PR, guilt and/or as a deal.
I can imagine the police investigation that follows being thwarted at every turn, a la Beverly Hills Cop III.
@Lite: That's awful. But just the kind of behaviour I'd expect from the company that helped create the G5, one of the most evil chips in the history of computing.
I believe the original prototype is currently being kept underground in a secret bunker and sprayed round the clock with liquid nitrogen to keep the chip frozen and the world safe from its terrible power.
A lump sum payment of $52K and $4K on an annual basis aint bad at all. They dont get paid a lot over there so I'm equating this as the family hitting a small lotto. Remember Foxconn did not have to pay them anything at all
Get harassed until you kill yourself in China: Get $52,600 + residuals until Foxconn kills the parents.
Die because you're an idiot and a freight car crushes your skull in the US: $200,000
Dump your fucking coffee from McDonalds in your lap because you're a tool in the US: $2,700,000
Apparently the labor in China isn't the only thing that is cheap.
@Lite: is on a boat.: To this day I pray that the lady who sued mcdonalds over the coffee spill dies a terrible and painful death. Along with any other idiot who discovers that their hot coffee is hot! (yes I know the coffee was hotter than it should have been, but I hate that this lady got so much money. 2 million of that cash should have been donated to other burn victims, her surgery and work opportunity cost probably cost her less than $700,00)
@Toastie: Actually, the woman who sued McDonalds only went after them for the medical bills alone. She didn't actually look for any profit. While that in itself may still seem questionable, at the very least, it wasn't out of greed. She was awarded a large lump sum for punitive damages simply because she was shrugged off when she approached them, but the award was reduced in appeals afterwards.
@Kaiser-Machead: Well, I silence myself momentarily in observance of my own ignorance. May she live a happy life and die peacefully in her sleep from old age. I guess the 90's is becoming a blur to me, or at least the unimportant parts of it.
If you work at apple and kill yourself, do you think Jobs provides you with a sleek aluminum casket, or does he just yell at your corpse until it spontaneously cremates?
I too visited many factories in China, and have followed the rise of the Chinese economy, both academically and casually, over the last 20 years. My dad was an expat there in the early 90's, before all the shine and glitz, and I lived in Shanghai when there were 9 kids in the American school and Pudong was just farmland. Its amazing to see how far China has come in the last 20 years, and its not just in the large cities, but even in the countryside. One of my mom's sisters was left behind on the mainland during the '49 war, and when we got her out of the country in '92, her and her family only ate rice and chili peppers. No meat, no veggies, nothing. That was how life was. Now, most Chinese people get to eat meat at least once a week, if not on a daily basis in the cities. Oppressed life in a factory, sad to say, is a step up for most people in that country, especially for factory workers, even for recent college graduates.
Yes, there is room for improvement. If the allegations of torture are true, then yes, Foxconn should be punished. That said, there HAVE been improvements. A labor law implemented in 2008 have improved labor rights and given greater protection to workers. The thing is, it will take time for these improvements to start bearing fruit, because its not just the law that needs to change, but large scale social perceptions and mindsets, and these changes take generations to change. Its hard to see the improvements at the margins, but if you look at what was happening in China 20 years ago and compare it to how conditions are today, you'll get a much better appreciation of the progress that has been made, and where progress will be 20 years from now.
BTW, I've been to that Foxconn factory before (above picture.) My company was providing SCM services to Foxconn. That's their lunch room. All employees, from the janitors and line workers all the way up to top management eat there. the company provides free lunches as a benefit to the workers. One decent meat, two veggies, rice, soup, a drink and yogurt- something completely unimaginable just 20 years ago. Also, one last thing to note, many of these OEM/ODM companies, make razor thin margins, something like 1-2%. Some even take losses. Its a highly competitive, cut-throat industry that we can't even conceive of here in the US. Power, as it is, is currently in the hands of the Apples and Microsofts of the world. They control the value in the chain. However, Foxconn and others, are slowly moving up that chain, expanding markets and margins. As they do, you can expect conditions to improve. But right now, its miserable for everyone in that company.
@Kai Chen: See, this is what I was talking about a couple days ago. Most people don't bother to take into account the social context under which situations like this occur. That cultural bias and tendency to view the rest of the world through the lens of one's own experiences at home is a major hurdle when discussing socioeconomic and sociopolitical issues.
Exactly, our paradigm is quite different from the Chinese worker paradigm. To put things in perspective, 30 some years ago, teachers were getting thrown out of windows in China; there were mass confessions, executions, protests, and close to a billion people in abject poverty. 20 years ago, Tiananmen happened. 15 years ago, ration coupons. 2 years ago, workers at my company weren't getting paid for overtime. Chinese history is something like 2000 years long. 30 years is a blink of the eye. In the US, that's 1/10th of our history. All of these things feed the collective psyche in China that is just so vastly different from our shared experiences. Yes, the US should be one of many models China works off of, but we can't expect China to follow the same trajectory.
As oppose to what? Digging ditches or farming at a subsistence level in China’s country side? Perspective people, perspective. Compared to the way they lived in their former life, this is a dream come true.
Riddle me this, if life is so bad at Foxconn, why don’t you leave? No one is forcing you to work there. This is not like India where you’re stuck in a caste.
Could it be because your would rather work at wonderful Foxconn than go dig a ditch?
@mpar: Who's the actual idiot here? Noobs is right. The workers there are not slaves. They can quit I'm sure if they want. The reason they are working there is because they PREFER it over any other jobs that are available to them.
You remind me of one of those useless background characters that are quickly killed in an action movie while the audience is either glad or do not care that he/she died.
@olternaut: so does that make you the guy that points out cliche characters, being a cliche himself, that somehow avoids death although the audience would have rather seen him perish than the first guy "noobs" represents in your un-starred commenting existence?
@Lance eagles3strong: I believe that you and olternault were the only two people who saw the movie. Excluding the people involved in the movie that is...
I am just back from a holiday in the US. First off: it is by far my favourite country. Second: you guys need to get your act together. How is it possible that 99% of goods I have seen there are "made in China"? I understand manufacturing prices are lower: but products don't cost less to me as a consumer... Strange... I think a little more ethics could do wonders... (there are businesses that thrive and "made in the US" or any other country besides China for that matter, but they are way to far and and inbetween)
Kaiser-Machead promoted this comment
Edited by DeusExMach wonders what the hell happened to his stapler. at 07/27/09 12:38 PM
DeusExMach wonders what the hell happened to his stapler. was starred
DeusExMach wonders what the hell happened to his stapler. was unstarred
So, is there any reason to believe that any other product "Made in China" is any better? If not, it's kind of silly to just call out Apple and Nintendo when the whole industry, international business mindset, and national trade and labor policies bear more of the blame.
I don't think it is too far off to say we all like gadgets that are low cost, but when the cost is horrible conditions that lead to at least 1 suicide that we know of, I wouldn't mind paying an extra 25/50$ per device to see the people that make my gadget get compensated a reasonable amount, and recieve better working conditions.
I mean come on, that shit is complete bull the way they treat the workers. 1 day off every 2 weeks! are you joking?
Warning: Facebook Comment and not a native speaker!
I've visited China numerous times already to start up production lines and go to fairs.
I've seen my share of factories in Guanzhou, Shenzhen, Nanchang etc...
The story the employee tells us is a regular story. As a matter of facts, allmost ALL Chinese factories have dormitories and for 'us' inedible food. Believe me, I saw kitchens over there with more rats than cooks in it.
As far as brainwashing goes. Well, this is China, brainwaching is a national sport.
Nevertheless, the places I've visited ( and some were WAY crappier than the description of Foxconn) were populated by nourrished and seemingly happy people.
It's a different culture, and it's hard to judge, keep that in mind in this Foxconn hype.
12/15/09
#iphoneleaksuicide
07/28/09
07/28/09
07/28/09
He wasn't killed in a workplace accident so there would be no reason for them to give such a payment to the family except PR, guilt and/or as a deal.
I can imagine the police investigation that follows being thwarted at every turn, a la Beverly Hills Cop III.
07/28/09
07/29/09
I believe the original prototype is currently being kept underground in a secret bunker and sprayed round the clock with liquid nitrogen to keep the chip frozen and the world safe from its terrible power.
If it were to escape ... [shudders]
07/28/09
07/28/09
07/28/09
07/28/09
Get harassed until you kill yourself in China: Get $52,600 + residuals until Foxconn kills the parents.
Die because you're an idiot and a freight car crushes your skull in the US: $200,000
Dump your fucking coffee from McDonalds in your lap because you're a tool in the US: $2,700,000
Apparently the labor in China isn't the only thing that is cheap.
07/28/09
07/28/09
07/28/09
07/28/09
07/28/09
Foxxconn employee kills himself, after being interrogated for releasing sensitive information regarding compensation of previous suicide victim.
07/28/09
07/28/09
$44,000.00 isn't very much for a life though...
07/27/09
Yes, there is room for improvement. If the allegations of torture are true, then yes, Foxconn should be punished. That said, there HAVE been improvements. A labor law implemented in 2008 have improved labor rights and given greater protection to workers. The thing is, it will take time for these improvements to start bearing fruit, because its not just the law that needs to change, but large scale social perceptions and mindsets, and these changes take generations to change. Its hard to see the improvements at the margins, but if you look at what was happening in China 20 years ago and compare it to how conditions are today, you'll get a much better appreciation of the progress that has been made, and where progress will be 20 years from now.
BTW, I've been to that Foxconn factory before (above picture.) My company was providing SCM services to Foxconn. That's their lunch room. All employees, from the janitors and line workers all the way up to top management eat there. the company provides free lunches as a benefit to the workers. One decent meat, two veggies, rice, soup, a drink and yogurt- something completely unimaginable just 20 years ago. Also, one last thing to note, many of these OEM/ODM companies, make razor thin margins, something like 1-2%. Some even take losses. Its a highly competitive, cut-throat industry that we can't even conceive of here in the US. Power, as it is, is currently in the hands of the Apples and Microsofts of the world. They control the value in the chain. However, Foxconn and others, are slowly moving up that chain, expanding markets and margins. As they do, you can expect conditions to improve. But right now, its miserable for everyone in that company.
07/27/09
07/27/09
Exactly, our paradigm is quite different from the Chinese worker paradigm. To put things in perspective, 30 some years ago, teachers were getting thrown out of windows in China; there were mass confessions, executions, protests, and close to a billion people in abject poverty. 20 years ago, Tiananmen happened. 15 years ago, ration coupons. 2 years ago, workers at my company weren't getting paid for overtime. Chinese history is something like 2000 years long. 30 years is a blink of the eye. In the US, that's 1/10th of our history. All of these things feed the collective psyche in China that is just so vastly different from our shared experiences. Yes, the US should be one of many models China works off of, but we can't expect China to follow the same trajectory.
07/27/09
07/27/09
I prefer to write visually, as if painting a picture in my mind with letters.
07/27/09
Riddle me this, if life is so bad at Foxconn, why don’t you leave? No one is forcing you to work there. This is not like India where you’re stuck in a caste.
Could it be because your would rather work at wonderful Foxconn than go dig a ditch?
07/27/09
perspective idiot perspective.
07/27/09
07/27/09
You remind me of one of those useless background characters that are quickly killed in an action movie while the audience is either glad or do not care that he/she died.
07/27/09
07/27/09
"Lady in the Water" I believe
07/27/09
07/28/09
it did seem like a quote, but i swear i've heard a few iterations of the same and made an ass of myself instead of minding my own damn business
07/27/09
07/27/09
1: where are you from originally?
2: Shut up.
07/27/09
07/27/09
07/27/09
07/27/09
I mean come on, that shit is complete bull the way they treat the workers. 1 day off every 2 weeks! are you joking?
07/27/09
I've visited China numerous times already to start up production lines and go to fairs.
I've seen my share of factories in Guanzhou, Shenzhen, Nanchang etc...
The story the employee tells us is a regular story. As a matter of facts, allmost ALL Chinese factories have dormitories and for 'us' inedible food. Believe me, I saw kitchens over there with more rats than cooks in it.
As far as brainwashing goes. Well, this is China, brainwaching is a national sport.
Nevertheless, the places I've visited ( and some were WAY crappier than the description of Foxconn) were populated by nourrished and seemingly happy people.
It's a different culture, and it's hard to judge, keep that in mind in this Foxconn hype.