Am I the only person that's totally irked by having an essential peripheral that requires batteries and doesn't have a built-in way to recharge them? This is a bad solution to cable clutter.
What would be so wrong with usb-based charging? It doesn't need to last three months between charges - it just needs to charge simply and easily without an external charger or spare batteries. #magicmousereview
@Eddie Offermann: I agree completely, there's a thread over in the 'Magic Mouse hands-on' where I also stated the same thing.
Using rechargeable AAs is not convenient. I agree with the need for charging built-in. Maybe if this one is a success we will see a rechargeable version. #magicmousereview
Someone might want this mouse "supposing that they don't really care about ergonomics." That basically translates into "nobody who uses a computer for more than 5 minutes should buy this."
@ripfire: Ah, yes. I keep forgetting about the need to look good while computing. :)
It might not surprise you to know that I own exactly 3 pair of shoes. Merrells for every day, boots for outdoors, and dress shoes for those special occasions. #magicmousereview
This mouse looks decent. I would have to try it before using it as my primary mouse. I have a nice Logitech one already. Unfortunately I can't use the new MX one because I use either / both hands for mousing and I can't go with a right only one.
Yes, I sometimes use two mice at once. It's easier to use one for my primary computer, and one for the rest of them. #magicmousereview
@Jason Chen: I would still like a better top down shot of it, its like someone was *trying* not to get that shot. Great view anyways Jason! #magicmousereview
Given that you spend 99% of your time with your mouse HOLDING it rather than LOOKING at it, why the hell would you sacrifice ergonomics for aesthetics (unless you're a total tool)? #magicmousereview
Bluetooth mice tend to work very poorly with macs for me. They jump all over the screen. Has anyone tested this in comparison to other bluetooth mice? Does this one "magically" work better? #magicmousereview
@blakeharjes: Really? I use a Logitech bluetooth with my iMac and (aside from the short delay when I start) have never had a problem. #magicmousereview
@92BuickLeSabre: Ya, I tried a number of bluethooth mice, including the old mighty mouse, and they would skip all over the screen. The tracking was awful. I ended up getting the Logitech V450 Nano with a dedicated non bluetooth dongle. That works perfect. Maybe I just have a lot of bluetooth interference where I live... #magicmousereview
Plain & simple: Apple doesn't give a shit if you don't like their products.
Sure there are numerous other mice that perform better, will allow you to program 12 macros to your n00b Horde mage, allow you to scroll through a 5,423 page pdf in a breeze...that's not the point here.
This new Apple mouse is badass in appearance and is pushing the envelope with technology we see today, and will be seeing tomorrow. If you don't like it, don't buy it. Go middle click somewhere else.
With that said, I use a Razer mouse and Wacom Intuos pen/tablet while designing all day...and have no use for a lovely mouse like this.
If you haven't noticed, the people that buy iMac's and the like, aren't exactly "extreme" computer users. They have the luxury to spend 2K on a computer just to check email and occasional pr0n, and don't spend 12+ hours tied to a desk everyday. Enter: MAGIC MOUSE! #magicmousereview
@sup3rheroninja: While your anger is odd, your points are not.
That said, whose to say you can't spend 12+ hours tied to a desk checking email and occasional pr0n. Now if you'll excuse me, I need to go check my email. #magicmousereview
@Eruanno: Because for many of us, our computers and our desks and our home office chairs have become a part of our home furnishings. Especially those of us who have a computer in (or visible from) the living room, dining room, den, whatever you have.
I like that my desk looks nice. And when I got a mouse for my iMac, I went with a small white and gray Logitech (instead of a giant blue mouse with red lights everywhere) so that corner of the room looks nice.
If I were to get this (which, I probably won't, because I like a physical scroll wheel), it would be at least 50% because it looks nice on my desk.
@valenoffw: A worthy point. But not always accurate. My wife and I are the ones looking at it 90% of the time, so it's really to make us happy.
I have no idea what kind of mice any of my friends use, and don't really care.
(Unless one of them gets one of these, and then I'm going to be a horrible dinner guest and play with it for like half and hour just for fun until my wife glares at me and makes me join everyone for dinner.) #magicmousereview
@DPeezy: Damn. Excellent point. Which makes me wonder even more about why that relationship exists. One obvious answer is money. (Rich young athletes/pop stars/etc. trend "older" on your chart.)
But I think there has to be a "need for style" aspect as well. When I was young, I could wear a torn up jacket, a baseball cap, and not shave or get a haircut for six months and still look bad ass. Now, it just makes me look like a washed up old dude.
When I was young, it didn't matter what my apartment looked like because we weren't getting back until 4 a.m., we were both drunk off our asses, we weren't looking for substance, and we had nothing to prove. Now? Every little bit helps.
Why is "Swiping is less comfortable" neutral? Wouldn't that be a negative? I dunno, maybe I'm just an oddity of nature who doesn't like uncomfortable things. #magicmousereview
@MarcusMaximus: For someone who uses back/forward buttons a lot, it might be negative. However, I never make mistakes on the Internet and thus have no use for such nonsense. #magicmousereview
10/22/09
Yeah drags a bitch, especially when I'm moving all the way over to the finder icon. #magicmousereview
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
What would be so wrong with usb-based charging? It doesn't need to last three months between charges - it just needs to charge simply and easily without an external charger or spare batteries. #magicmousereview
10/21/09
Using rechargeable AAs is not convenient. I agree with the need for charging built-in. Maybe if this one is a success we will see a rechargeable version. #magicmousereview
10/21/09
Do I want a $70 hand cramp? No thank you. #magicmousereview
10/21/09
10/21/09
It might not surprise you to know that I own exactly 3 pair of shoes. Merrells for every day, boots for outdoors, and dress shoes for those special occasions. #magicmousereview
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
@jderas001: *sigh* #magicmousereview
10/21/09
Yes, I sometimes use two mice at once. It's easier to use one for my primary computer, and one for the rest of them. #magicmousereview
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
sigh #magicmousereview
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
Sure there are numerous other mice that perform better, will allow you to program 12 macros to your n00b Horde mage, allow you to scroll through a 5,423 page pdf in a breeze...that's not the point here.
This new Apple mouse is badass in appearance and is pushing the envelope with technology we see today, and will be seeing tomorrow. If you don't like it, don't buy it. Go middle click somewhere else.
With that said, I use a Razer mouse and Wacom Intuos pen/tablet while designing all day...and have no use for a lovely mouse like this.
If you haven't noticed, the people that buy iMac's and the like, aren't exactly "extreme" computer users. They have the luxury to spend 2K on a computer just to check email and occasional pr0n, and don't spend 12+ hours tied to a desk everyday. Enter: MAGIC MOUSE! #magicmousereview
10/21/09
That said, whose to say you can't spend 12+ hours tied to a desk checking email and occasional pr0n. Now if you'll excuse me, I need to go check my email. #magicmousereview
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
I don't look at my mouse often, but I do like it to look nice or at least match my computer somewhat. #magicmousereview
10/21/09
I like that my desk looks nice. And when I got a mouse for my iMac, I went with a small white and gray Logitech (instead of a giant blue mouse with red lights everywhere) so that corner of the room looks nice.
If I were to get this (which, I probably won't, because I like a physical scroll wheel), it would be at least 50% because it looks nice on my desk.
And I have no shame about that decision. #magicmousereview
10/21/09
10/21/09
I have no idea what kind of mice any of my friends use, and don't really care.
(Unless one of them gets one of these, and then I'm going to be a horrible dinner guest and play with it for like half and hour just for fun until my wife glares at me and makes me join everyone for dinner.) #magicmousereview
10/21/09
Young, single, living in a dorm?
99% function, 1% looks
Young, attached, living in an apt.?
75% function, 25% looks
Older, married, living in a house?
50% function, 50% looks
Old, jaded, X?
"What's electronics?"
Etc, etc... #magicmousereview
10/21/09
But I think there has to be a "need for style" aspect as well. When I was young, I could wear a torn up jacket, a baseball cap, and not shave or get a haircut for six months and still look bad ass. Now, it just makes me look like a washed up old dude.
When I was young, it didn't matter what my apartment looked like because we weren't getting back until 4 a.m., we were both drunk off our asses, we weren't looking for substance, and we had nothing to prove. Now? Every little bit helps.
The accuracy of your chart is making me sad. #magicmousereview
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/21/09
10/22/09
10/21/09
JChen says it's not though...
(Also, not sure why but the first time I added this comment it showed up as "by" ArnoldEurotas.)
10/21/09