• Gizmodo
  • bestmodo
  • lifehacker
  • kotaku
  • Profile logout login

#questionoftheday#zastonjfilmi

Gizmodo

Share Cancel
   
Upload an image | Add an image URL
×

logging in
  • FAQ. Include # before tag:
  • #tips,
  • #dealzmodo,
  • #rumors,
  • #broken,
  • #iphoneapps,
  • #apple,
  • etc.

New York, 2:35 PM
Sun Nov 15
16 posts in the last 24 hours

FR | IT | DE | SP | JP | AU | BR

Gizmodo Team

Tip your editors:
tips@gizmodo.com

Editorial Director:
Brian Lam | Email | Twitter

Editor:
Jason Chen
Email | AIM | Twitter

Features Editor:
Wilson Rothman
Email | Twitter

Senior Contributing Editor:
Jesus Diaz
Email | AIM | Twitter
Mark Wilson, Reviews
Email | AIM | Twitter

Contributing Editors:
Matt Buchanan
Email | AIM | Twitter
Adam Frucci
Email | Twitter
Sean Fallon
Email | Twitter
Jack Loftus
Email | Twitter
John Herrman
Email | Twitter
Dan Nosowitz
Email
Chris Mascari
Email
Danny Allen
Email | Twitter

Columnist:
Brendan I. Koerner

Interns:
Don Nguyen
Email
Chris Jacob
Email

Comment Intern:
Nick Ellenoff | Email

Heroes and Friends

Comment Account Questions:
Comments@gizmodo.com

SUBSCRIBE TO Gizmodo RSS

New: Breaking news and daily top stories via email
9515 Subscribers
Gizmodo
  • Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.
    Dsmvwl  Admin  Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×
    Image of Bokusatsu_Tenshi Bokusatsu_Tenshi
    11/14/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    I voted on brain, but if technology is in such an advanced state that we could built a device that worked exactly like a human brain, then everything could be replaced... wouldn't even need shreds of original tissue.

    Of course, this depends on the very definition of what a human is... #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    Bokusatsu_Tenshi was starred Bokusatsu_Tenshi was unstarred
    Image of dolo54 blows minds and blows engines! dolo54 blows minds and blows engines!
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    Reminds me of my favorite author, Philip Dick. Most of his books deal with the theme of what it means to be human. Often he will offer an android or alien as an example of what is truly human and a person as an example of how inhuman a person can be. His books are awesome mindbending freakouts.

    "More Human Than Human is our motto." -Tyrell (from Blade Runner)
     Reply
    Edited by dolo54 blows minds and blows engines! at 11/13/09 8:00 PM dolo54 blows minds and blows engines! was starred dolo54 blows minds and blows engines! was unstarred
    Image of dolo54 blows minds and blows engines! dolo54 blows minds and blows engines!
    11/13/09

    @dolo54 blows minds and blows engines!: And to answer the question, my answer is not on the poll. It would be, 'as long as we can feel empathy towards others.' #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    dolo54 blows minds and blows engines! was starred dolo54 blows minds and blows engines! was unstarred
    Image of Laura Woody Laura Woody
    11/14/09

    @dolo54 blows minds and blows engines!: While I agree that the capacity for the subject to experience empathy would be the individual measure of retained humanity, I wonder how such empathy could be accurately judged if the biological human identity of the subject was compromised. I am not speaking of the original consciousness but of the personal perception of belonging to the biological human race. We - biological humans - share the camaraderie of being the same species, but if such an integral part of the biological human identity is removed and replaced, would a new identity form? Would a subject no longer physiologically related to the human race retain any lingering loyalty or sense of belonging to it? Following this vein of thought, if a new identity did form and the subject no longer considered itself connected to biological humans, would the empathy be measured as directed toward other beings similarly expatriated from their biological origins? Or would the connecting empathy between the subject and biological humanity be the only measure? #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    dolo54 blows minds and blows engines! promoted this comment Laura Woody was starred Laura Woody was unstarred
    Image of dolo54 blows minds and blows engines! dolo54 blows minds and blows engines!
    11/14/09

    @Laura Woody: @jrghoull: @punknubbins: Actually my answer is one of PK Dick's answers. I don't think there is a "right" answer. But thinking about it that way makes you realize just how difficult a question it is. It may become a serious issue in the future if we do create an AI or have humans whose conscious is completely removed from their original physical bodies. How will these new thinking, feeling creatures be treated? What sort of rights will they have? If you kill an AI that has self-awareness, human or greater intelligence and feelings, is it murder? What if we have genetic experimentation on animals that creates a dog with human level intellect? No easy answers here, but you certainly can't draw the line at some arbitrary percentage of biological makeup. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    dolo54 blows minds and blows engines! was starred dolo54 blows minds and blows engines! was unstarred
    Image of nutbastard nutbastard
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    human != homosapien

    to be human is to have sentience, reason, and language, and to reside in this universe. no animal or computer yet fits the bill. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    nutbastard was starred nutbastard was unstarred
    Image of newgalactic newgalactic
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    I would argue that the % is lower then the poll eludes. The "body" has more ties to the "mind/soul" then we realize.

    If I replace almost my entire body, enabling my static personality/mind to live forever, and I still human? The possibility of Death may contribute to being "human".
     Reply
    Edited by newgalactic at 11/13/09 6:44 PM newgalactic was starred newgalactic was unstarred
    Image of newgalactic newgalactic
    11/13/09

    @newgalactic: Here's another thought.

    ***huge generalization coming up***

    Assuming that the majority of Gizmodo readers are "dorks/nerds" ("dorks/nerds" being less physically blessed. Yes, huge generalization/sterotype), would a "Brad Pit" type be more inclined to attach his humanity to his physical body? #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    newgalactic was starred newgalactic was unstarred
    Image of Shamoononon: I shave my legs. Shamoononon: I shave my legs.
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    I'm going to break everyone's heart here and go with, 'when you have a robotic ding dong'... since that didn't come up like fifty times this week. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    Shamoononon: I shave my legs. was starred Shamoononon: I shave my legs. was unstarred
    Image of NeoAkira NeoAkira
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    I think this depends on what you consider "human" to be. Personally, I hold a very biological view of what a human is (ie the species Homo sapien).

    As such, I would say you're no longer human if you don't have all of the following:

    Your original organic brain, and your original organic reproductive system. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    NeoAkira was starred NeoAkira was unstarred
    Image of pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq
    11/13/09

    @NeoAkira: So what if you got a hysterectomy? Are you saying my mother is no longer human in your eyes? #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    NeoAkira promoted this comment pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq was starred pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq was unstarred
    Image of NeoAkira NeoAkira
    11/13/09

    @pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq:

    aha, I knew someone like you might make a response like that.

    This article is talking about replacing parts of our body with robotic components. Does your mother have a robotic uterus now? #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    NeoAkira was starred NeoAkira was unstarred
    Image of pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq
    11/14/09

    @NeoAkira: True, however, your parameters for what is human did not include the replacement of natural part with robotic. You merely stated that humans are brains and reproductive organs. You statement was that the basic fundamentals a person needs are quality of organic reproduction (period) and a organic brain (period) to qualify for club of humanity "you are no longer human if you lack...". Not "if you replaced with artificial..." Your vagueness was the cause of my query, and not reason enough to be snarky.
     Reply
    Edited by pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq at 11/14/09 7:06 AM pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq was starred pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq was unstarred
    Image of NeoAkira NeoAkira
    11/14/09

    @pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq: If you had read my comment without having actually read the article, and thus completely out of context, then I'd understand.

    But otherwise, no.
     Reply
    Edited by NeoAkira at 11/14/09 11:03 AM NeoAkira was starred NeoAkira was unstarred
    Image of Hello Mister Walrus Hello Mister Walrus
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    Maybe we're looking at this the wrong way. Maybe it's an outward, rather than inward classification. For instance, if we have a robot that is indistinguishable from humans, i.e. you can dissect it and it looks human, it behaves exactly like a human etc., then maybe we should call it human. Our interactions with this robot, after all, would be exactly the same as our interactions with a human. So to us, other definitions, such as what the robot is actually made of, would be immaterial. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    Hello Mister Walrus was starred Hello Mister Walrus was unstarred
    Image of pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq
    11/13/09

    @Hello Mister Walrus: We differentiate species by very minor dissimilarities. Is a Neanderthal human? Being completely artificial might warrant a different name or even kingdom. Homo Robotus perhaps? #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    met2art promoted this comment pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq was starred pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq was unstarred
    Image of Hello Mister Walrus Hello Mister Walrus
    11/13/09

    @pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq: I guess my original post was a bit disorganized. What I was trying to say is that maybe classification differences are irrelevant if they do not affect the outside world. Perhaps we should instead classify things based on their functions and appearances, not their origins, since functions and appearances are the only things that have any effect on our lives. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    Hello Mister Walrus was starred Hello Mister Walrus was unstarred
    Image of pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq
    11/13/09

    @Hello Mister Walrus: I'm not sure if that is completely true. I would certainly want my wife to love me and not just act like it. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq was starred pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq was unstarred
    Image of Hello Mister Walrus Hello Mister Walrus
    11/13/09

    @pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq: But if you never know, then how would it affect you, and if it doesn't, how could it be good or bad?
     Reply
    Edited by Hello Mister Walrus at 11/13/09 7:43 PM Hello Mister Walrus was starred Hello Mister Walrus was unstarred
    Image of pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq
    11/13/09

    @Hello Mister Walrus: I think people deep down value the genuine. If you thought your wife was faithful, would that be enough for you? How heart wrenching is it when you find out she had been deceiving you for years? Is the mere illusion enough for you? Or does truth extend beyond what you can see and detect? Would a faked mona lisa be of the same value to you as the original? Would a fake Macbook be of same value to you? Is truth something in itself, or just what I see right now? The point is, if it looks like a duck, walks like a duck, quacks like a duck and its a robot, its still a robot. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq was starred pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq was unstarred
    Image of Hello Mister Walrus Hello Mister Walrus
    11/13/09

    @pɹɐoqʎǝʞuǝʞoɹq: I still subscribe to the belief that what you don't know and doesn't harm you doesn't harm you. However, I can respectfully understand other people valuing intangible things that cannot be observed. It looks like we'll have to leave it at that for now. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    Hello Mister Walrus was starred Hello Mister Walrus was unstarred
    Image of Hobolicious Hobolicious
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    At what point would our cyborg-selves cease to be human?

    I think humor has to be involved somehow, as it generally relies on an understanding of at least some sections of a social construct.

    If you get to the point where you're just seeing data without seeing the overlying social connections, you're probably pretty robotic and not cyborg-ey.

    Examples of robotic humor:

    Robot Seinfeld: I'VE GOT THIS PAIN ALL ALONG THE DIODES IN MY LEFT ARM. WHAT IS THE DEAL WITH THAT.

    Robot Internet Humor: ALL YOUR BASE 10 ARE BELONG TO US. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    Hobolicious was starred Hobolicious was unstarred
    Image of Homo_erectus Homo_erectus
    11/13/09

    @Hobolicious: is that base ten or two? #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    Hobolicious promoted this comment Homo_erectus was starred Homo_erectus was unstarred
    Image of Jaredu Jaredu
    11/13/09

    @Hobolicious: if that is the case, then I am a robot.

    I recognize pain, but I don't really care that it's there.

    I often don't catch the punch-lines in jokes and I'm more intensive at looking at data than google.

    I'm made of pure flesh though.. except my fillings.

    I laughed at the base 10 joke xD #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    Hobolicious promoted this comment Jaredu was starred Jaredu was unstarred
    Image of Hiphopopotamus Hiphopopotamus
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    Once you start dreaming of electric sheep, game over... #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    Hiphopopotamus was starred Hiphopopotamus was unstarred
    Image of met2art met2art
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    From a biological standpoint I would submit that as long as viable DNA for reproduction is still part of the equation, then we retain our "badge" of humanity. However far we might go with merging our bodies and consciousness with inorganic structures, we are still human if we retain the ability to reproduce evolutionarily unique (and mutable) offspring. If we upload consciousness into a computer, retaining no original genetic material then we cease to be human by any biological standard, and must make a new determination on what we have become. At that point organic natural selection is no longer in effect. All reproduction (or replication) becomes a byproduct of our own styled algorithms and datasets, a purely intellectual exercise (even if based on algorithms that mimic biological processes).

    I'm not saying that's good, bad, right, or wrong... just my opinion on classification of our species. We could still refer to ourselves as human, (and I think we would) but I think there would be a new classification. Homo Sapiens Secundum Corporis, perhaps? #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    met2art was starred met2art was unstarred
    Image of Erik Dell Erik Dell
    11/13/09

    @met2art: are you saying that what distinguishes us as a species (biologically) is the ability to reproduce? I can think of a few other ways to distinguish myself from a beaver (the kind with lots of hair that eats wood, hah!). #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    met2art promoted this comment Erik Dell was starred Erik Dell was unstarred
    Image of met2art met2art
    11/13/09

    @Erik Dell: No, I was merely ilustratin gmy opinion of the point at which we cease being organic beings, and when our DNA, which defines us Homo Sapiens, ceases to be apropos to our replication.

    If a human brain is uploaded into the same hardware as a self-aware artificial intelligence, and both have the capability to replicate themselves (identically, or with approximations of generational mutation) how do you define the distinction between them? If both have the same levels of perception, the same ability to make judgments, and moral decisions... how do you distinguish which one is human, except by accepting a declaration of such? In a purely digital existence where any bits can be shifted to represent any dataset, how can a purely digital version of humanity be distuinguishable from an artificial intelligence which can replicate the same dataset and exhibits the same behavior? It's my opinion that at that point, the essence of humanity is altered and requires new classification, even if it still behaves in ostensibly "human" fashion. However, I believe that there would be many fundamental alterations in perceptions of behavior, morality, thought and action with such a massive change. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    met2art was starred met2art was unstarred
    Image of negated: has star powah negated: has star powah
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    We are human, after all
    Flesh uncovered, after all #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    negated: has star powah was starred negated: has star powah was unstarred
    Image of ripfire ripfire
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    When you lose the urge to masturbate. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    ripfire was starred ripfire was unstarred
    Image of Hello Mister Walrus Hello Mister Walrus
    11/13/09

    @ripfire: What if someone chops off your testicles? #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    Hello Mister Walrus was starred Hello Mister Walrus was unstarred
    Image of ripfire ripfire
    11/13/09

    @Hello Mister Walrus: Doesn't matter. As long as you still get urges triggered by the hypothalamus, you could be wanking off to your phantom penis.

    Huh. I guess my answer falls into the "As long as you still have your brain" category. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    ripfire was starred ripfire was unstarred
    Image of KhaiJB KhaiJB
    11/13/09

    In reply to At What Point Would Our Cyborg-selves Cease To Be Human?
    thinking back to the old Starlord/2000AD strip .. to quote

    "Ro-Busters is a commercial rescue organisation run by Howard Quartz, known as "Mr. 10 Per Cent" because 90% of him is robotic (a 'person' must have at least 10% organic matter to qualify as human)." #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    KhaiJB was starred KhaiJB was unstarred
    Image of Michai Michai
    11/12/09

    In reply to What Ability Would Be Your First Choice For Cyborg Enhancement?
    Neurological enchantment. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    Michai was starred Michai was unstarred
    Image of The5thElephant The5thElephant
    11/12/09

    In reply to What Ability Would Be Your First Choice For Cyborg Enhancement?
    A button to clench or relax my cremaster. #thiscyborglife
     Reply
    The5thElephant was starred The5thElephant was unstarred
    Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

Login

Enter your username and password.

Please enter a username.
Please enter your password.
logging in
Login via Facebook | Sign Up | Forgot Password?

Reset Password

Please enter your email address to have your password reset.

Please enter your email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
requesting password reset

Register

Registering will give you a user profile and the ability to add other users as friends. To become a commenter, however, you need to audition.

Want to know more? Consult the Comment FAQ and legal terms.

Please enter a username.
Please enter a password.
Please confirm your password.
Passwords are not identical.
Please enter a valid email address.
registration sent, waiting for reply

Submit Your Comment

You don't need to login to comment. Just enter your email address below.

See how your address will be displayed in the Comment FAQ.

Please enter a valid email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
logging in

Login with your Facebook or Gizmodo account.

Sign up here.



  • Archives
  • About
  • Advertising
  • Legal
  • Help
  • Report a Bug
  • FAQ
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.