quickkill - Gizmodo

posts about #quickkill more →
Rocket Grenade Smashed to Bits In Flight By Quick Kill Defense System

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

Gann
11/21/08

In reply to Rocket Grenade Smashed to Bits In Flight By Quick Kill Defense System
I want to set one of these up to scare the piss out of the paperboy.
Reply

Gann was starred Gann was unstarred

Kaspir
11/21/08

In reply to Rocket Grenade Smashed to Bits In Flight By Quick Kill Defense System
I pity the first kid that throws a good sized rock at one of our vehicles outfitted with this system, it will be a bad day for him indeed...
Reply

Kaspir was starred Kaspir was unstarred

GitEmSteveDave_DefinesTurgid
11/21/08

@Kaspir: If that kid can throw as fast as an RPG, I think there are many a MLB team who would bring him, his family, AND his village over to the US in about three seconds.
Reply

borgseawolf
11/21/08

@Git Em SteveDave loves this guy->★: If this works on detecting missiles of certain speed only, I predict Dune-style 'slow bullet' weapons being developed as counter-measure.
Reply

borgseawolf was starred borgseawolf was unstarred

GitEmSteveDave_DefinesTurgid
11/21/08

@borgseawolf: The slow blade penetrates, eh?
Reply

russdanger
11/21/08

In reply to Rocket Grenade Smashed to Bits In Flight By Quick Kill Defense System
I wonder how many low-flying birds have gotten blown to nirvana by this thing so far.
Reply

russdanger was starred russdanger was unstarred

TerryinSt.Paul
11/21/08

@russdanger:
Alot less than Randy Johnson.

+ Watch video

Reply

TerryinSt.Paul was starred TerryinSt.Paul was unstarred

Curves
11/21/08

@TerryinSt.Paul: Was that ruled a Fowl ball?
Reply

Curves was starred Curves was unstarred

GitEmSteveDave_DefinesTurgid
11/21/08

@Curves: Excuse me, waitress, I think you may have given Curves decaf. Can she have another cup please? :)
Reply

Barry99705
11/21/08

@russdanger: I'm sure it can tell the difference between a high speed target, and a slow flying bird.
Reply

Barry99705 was starred Barry99705 was unstarred

GitEmSteveDave_DefinesTurgid
11/21/08

@Barry99705: I don't know. An unladen swallow can fly pretty fast.
Reply

godwhacker, your incandescent leader!
11/21/08

@Git Em SteveDave loves this guy->★:

so, how fast can it fly after it has been laden?
Reply

GitEmSteveDave_DefinesTurgid
11/21/08

@godwhacker: After it finishes it's smoke and nap, pretty quick.
Reply

Curves
11/21/08

In reply to Rocket Grenade Smashed to Bits In Flight By Quick Kill Defense System
The best defense is a good offense. They should have named this porcupine, since that is what it puts me in the mind of. (OK, so maybe I need more coffee, but thats what it reminded me of.)
Reply

Curves was starred Curves was unstarred

scarbrtj
11/21/08

In reply to Rocket Grenade Smashed to Bits In Flight By Quick Kill Defense System
If Matthew "Pecker" McConaughey can toss a TiVo in the path of an RPG...

then I woulda predicted that Raytheon would have no problem.
Reply

scarbrtj was starred scarbrtj was unstarred

weatherman
11/21/08

In reply to Rocket Grenade Smashed to Bits In Flight By Quick Kill Defense System
I'm no weapons engineer, but this does seem a little complicated for deployment. The timing issue is a big one - it'll work with plenty of time for detecting and acquiring the target, but in close quarters combat it would seem to inherently take too long to launch; shoot up, correct down, launch forward, explode... just too much could go wrong, especially in a combat situation.

Wasn't there another system that is already deployed - a kind of "active armor" that essentially just explodes outwards before the RPG hits? That seems like it would work more reliably in all situations. Maybe it's not as effective though. That test sure made this thing look effective!
Reply

weatherman was starred weatherman was unstarred

GitEmSteveDave_DefinesTurgid
11/21/08

@weatherman: Did you see then end of the video when they did it real time? It took less than a second for the RPG to fire and the system to explode it. As for something going wrong, if you didn't have the system, you'd be defenseless. Even if it stops the RPG 50% of the time, that's still more than no system.

I think you are thinking of reactive armor that tanks use. IIRC, it doesn't detect the inbound round, but reacts when the round imapacts it.
Reply

weatherman
11/21/08

@Git Em SteveDave loves this guy->★: yeah, you're right. I looked at it and it definitely happens really quick. Actually a heck of a lot quicker than 1 second. And if it works in combat situations, I'm all for it. More protection is more protection, after all, and we definitely need something better than the chicken wire we're using against RPGs.
Reply

weatherman was starred weatherman was unstarred

b-radicate
11/21/08

@weatherman: I wonder what'll happen if the RPG comes from another angle. Are there corrective rockets on all sides of the thing? How would it correct in another direction? Does its platform rotate super quick, too?
Reply

b-radicate was starred b-radicate was unstarred

GitEmSteveDave_DefinesTurgid
11/21/08

@weatherman: I had to watch the end a couple of times b/c I didn't understand what they were showing. The slow mo just makes it seem like what was at the end couldn;t have been what happened it was so quick, especially with the direction changes. This reminds me of a system I saw for the President which is in essence a kevlar airbag wall. If it detects a gunshot or incoming round, it inflates a vertical wall to catch the bullet. It's a stationary unit, but they said it could be used along common paths the President walk and at events.
Reply

GitEmSteveDave_DefinesTurgid
11/21/08

@b-radicate: It appears to fire straight up, then adjusts towards the target, so it might just be 360 degree.
Reply

MartinX
11/21/08

In reply to Rocket Grenade Smashed to Bits In Flight By Quick Kill Defense System
That's pretty cool.

I wonder, however, if, when it's deployed, it will still be called the "Future Combat System"?

Surely "Present Combat System" would be more appropriate at that point, but it doesn't sound as good.

Possibly they will need to give it a new name, like BANGWHAMMER or something, then the can figure out words to make that into an acronym.

I guess that's what the DoDs highly trained reverse acronym department (R.A.D) is paid to figure out.
Reply

MartinX was starred MartinX was unstarred

GitEmSteveDave_DefinesTurgid
11/21/08

@MartinX: The guy who names it should watch Spaceballs.
Reply

Cisco-Kid
11/21/08

In reply to Rocket Grenade Smashed to Bits In Flight By Quick Kill Defense System
Phase two of the system fires a second rocket at the origination of the RPG, killing the shooter.

Phase three goes after his family.
Reply

Cisco-Kid was starred Cisco-Kid was unstarred

weatherman
11/21/08

@Cisco-Kid: phase four, conceived by Dick Cheney, goes after a guy in another country who kinda reminds us of the shooter in some way because he looked at us cross-eyed once.

Sorry, it's reflexive at this point. Thank goodness I don't have to keep that up for another four years...
Reply

weatherman was starred weatherman was unstarred

GitEmSteveDave_DefinesTurgid
11/21/08

@Cisco-Kid: It then bankrupts his brothers tractor dealership.
Reply

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#quickkill

Gizmodo

Gizmodo Team

SUBSCRIBE TO Gizmodo

Rocket Grenade Smashed to Bits In Flight By Quick Kill Defense System

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment