Still, Polk makes some good point in the press release.
"most games are played through standard TV speakers, which are dismal at best."
"Music games like Beatles Rock Band® are rightfully cited for sounding as good if not better than the original releases, so why play them through toys or TVs? A high quality recording deserves a real speaker that reveals all the beauty of the original master, and this is exactly what HitMaster provides."
They may look garish, but I have to agree with Polk on this one. #polk
@Bluecold: Those would be great points if Polk was making something other than only-slightly-better-than-crappy-TV... speakers...$100 for a powered monitor is going buy you a really crappy monitor...this is a toy, no way around it. #polk
I'm going to cry and get all nostalgic for real musicians when, sometime in the far-too-near future, my kids start going to see bands with names like, "The Real Fake Band", who just play Guitar Hero type stuff on stage, with ridiculous accessories to make it LOOK like a real concert. #polk
Awesome, no all I need is for them to come out with a fisher-price lighting set and I could have a fake stage, with fake amps, and fake guitars, putting on a fake show. My fake life will. be. complete! #alteclansingstagegig
i have problems with the game registering the two finger tap and hold gestures. two finger tap is registered fine, but there seems to be like a half second delay before it recognizes the tap and hold. anyone else getting this problem? #rockbandiphone
You know, to be fair, regular stage monitors aren't guitar amps, either. They do usually have 1/4" inputs, though, and technically COULD be used as a guitar amp. That's not a bad price for a stage monitor, though, if you can get around not having standard inputs. #alteclansingstagegig
@thebigcheese: In order to use this as an amp, you're going to need a power amp to drive the speaker, and an active DI box to get the guitar up to a level the amp can deal with. And then you don't get any tone controls outside of what's on your guitar, and you don't get to overdrive it to get some fuzz.
And while $100 would be a nice price for a monitor, I will bet you anything that this will make a terrible monitor. Any $100 monitor will be terrible. #alteclansingstagegig
@badhatharry: If it had more power, this would be perfect for lots of situations... but at 40 watts, it's a bit anemic for actual stage use. For playing video games, though, this is probably pretty close to ideal.
Although, if you're using something like a Pod in a low-volume situation (think acoustic, church bands, or even park/beach with an inverter), this might not be bad.
Plus, the description on AL's site is pretty clear what this is for: it's a video game speaker, not a live audio monitor. #alteclansingstagegig
@TomXP411: I wouldn't use this in any professional or semi-professional application. It has RCA inputs. If you ever tried to use this on a stage, you would spend your soundcheck trying to get rid of hum.
As for an iPod, I would rather use computer speakers because they're cheaper, probably sound just as good, and I have two discrete channels, rather than a stereo signal coming out of one set of drivers.
And I know it's for video games. Thebigcheese was floating the idea of using it as a inexpensive stage monitor. #alteclansingstagegig
@badhatharry: Oh yes. I've been doing this a long time, and yes, unbalanced inputs=buzz and hum. :)
You could use it for low-powered acoustic situations, though, where people typically are either un-miced or they only mic the singers. It'd be perfect for my little "acoustic" Variax, which I currently use with a rather ugly Kareoke amplifier.
The thing is... Just TRY to buy a decent "non-guitar" combo amp for less than $300. It's practically impossible.
I have mixed live music for about 20 years, and I've never seen a guitar amp in this configuration. It does, however, resemble a monitor wedge, and it appears that is the intended visual reference and use. #alteclansingstagegig
Been playing with this for about an hour now. It's definitely a lot of fun. But the crummy speaker on the 2G iPhone means I probably won't be playing this anywhere except my room without headphones. #rockbandforiphone
Why wouldn't you just cradle the phone in the palm of your left hand, and 'play' the 4 buttons with the fingers on your right hand? (or the other way around for you lefties) Thumbs seem a bit cumbersome if you ask me - then again, I haven't tried it either way yet. #rockbandiphone
@Gordonium: Depends how hard you're rocking out. If you get so into it that your beating your whole fist down on it: probably. As long as you're only using your fingers I'd expect you'd do damage to them long before anything happens to the iPhone/iPod Touch itself. #rockbandiphone
@Gordonium: And why would that even become a notion? The screen IS capacitive, after all.. a light touch is all that is needed...
On the other hand, the glass on the iPhone is pretty thick, so I don't think there should be any problems there. I used to tap the screen pretty hard to temporarily get rid of dead pixels in my first gen iPhone. #rockbandiphone
@ovil200: Aha. So even moderately intelligent people should be okay. Looks like only the hard rockin' morons will break their fingers/phones.
Was more concerned about the innards of the phone, screen excluded. Vibration damage, etc. I'm not too technically inclined, if you hadn't already guessed. #rockbandiphone
@Gordonium: Considering the device is INTENDED to be shaken and tilted, I'm sure it'll be fine. In fact this game requires less shaking than some others I've seen. All that's required to deploy overdrive is a quick flick. So unless you lose your grip and throw your iPhone into the ground you shouldn't risk damaging it in any way. #rockbandiphone
@Gordonium: You jar the phone more by putting it in your pocket. Runners typically carry their iphones on their arms, me included. When you run your phone goes through way more jarring in a few minutes than it will ever see playing that game. It is made to take the abuse and even has Nike sensor made for runners. As far as the screen, it is made of glass. If you are going to hit it hard enough to shatter the glass with your finger, you are pretty much super human or a retard bashing at it with your fists. #rockbandiphone
....aaaaannnd other phones, that might actually play better because some of them have buttons. Oh yeah, I said it...but the real point is the OTHER PHONES too thing. It seems to have been ignored. #rockbandforiphone
11/01/09
11/01/09
That's not to say that the machine isn't any less impressive in its function, but c'mon.
Anyway, these little devices always have the feeling of, "I spent 6 days looking for a term paper online instead of actually doing it myself." #robots
10/25/09
"most games are played through standard TV speakers, which are dismal at best."
"Music games like Beatles Rock Band® are rightfully cited for sounding as good if not better than the original releases, so why play them through toys or TVs? A high quality recording deserves a real speaker that reveals all the beauty of the original master, and this is exactly what HitMaster provides."
They may look garish, but I have to agree with Polk on this one. #polk
10/25/09
10/25/09
10/25/09
10/20/09
10/20/09
10/20/09
10/20/09
10/20/09
And while $100 would be a nice price for a monitor, I will bet you anything that this will make a terrible monitor. Any $100 monitor will be terrible. #alteclansingstagegig
10/20/09
Although, if you're using something like a Pod in a low-volume situation (think acoustic, church bands, or even park/beach with an inverter), this might not be bad.
Plus, the description on AL's site is pretty clear what this is for: it's a video game speaker, not a live audio monitor. #alteclansingstagegig
10/20/09
As for an iPod, I would rather use computer speakers because they're cheaper, probably sound just as good, and I have two discrete channels, rather than a stereo signal coming out of one set of drivers.
And I know it's for video games. Thebigcheese was floating the idea of using it as a inexpensive stage monitor. #alteclansingstagegig
10/28/09
You could use it for low-powered acoustic situations, though, where people typically are either un-miced or they only mic the singers. It'd be perfect for my little "acoustic" Variax, which I currently use with a rather ugly Kareoke amplifier.
The thing is... Just TRY to buy a decent "non-guitar" combo amp for less than $300. It's practically impossible.
Oh well. I keep looking...
10/20/09
10/20/09
10/20/09
10/19/09
10/19/09
10/19/09
10/19/09
Anybody know? #rockbandiphone
10/19/09
10/19/09
On the other hand, the glass on the iPhone is pretty thick, so I don't think there should be any problems there. I used to tap the screen pretty hard to temporarily get rid of dead pixels in my first gen iPhone. #rockbandiphone
10/19/09
Was more concerned about the innards of the phone, screen excluded. Vibration damage, etc. I'm not too technically inclined, if you hadn't already guessed. #rockbandiphone
10/19/09
10/20/09
10/19/09
10/19/09