Senior Contributing Editors:
Jesus Diaz
| AIM | Twitter
Mark Wilson, Reviews
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editors:
Matt Buchanan | AIM | Twitter
Adam Frucci | Twitter
Sean Fallon | Twitter
Jack Loftus | Twitter
John Herrman | Twitter
Dan Nosowitz
Chris Mascari
Kat Hannaford | Twitter
Rosa Golijan | Twitter
Chris Jacob
This is a great read. I hope that Google succeeds in reigning in the ISP's by offering a phone that always has the best version of Android and therefore makes the other want to at least play catch up to match the Nexus.
By the way. I have a rooted G1 and I'm running Eclair with Google voice navagation.
My thoughts on this is that Google needs to get the other members of the Open Handset Alliance to sort themselves out. If they want to be part of the Android experience they need to support it with fast updates so that we can all have the same experience. Maybe Google needs to lay down a minimum spec for each x.0 release so that everyone moves forward together. Sure people on older devices may be upset that they are getting left behind, but that was going to happen anyway, the way that mobile tech is advancing.
@clR3vv: Yeah, the Tegra is actually the most efficient system on a chip available. It has many different smaller dedicated processors, and only throws powers towards the ones it needs at the moment. Such as the HD Video Encoder or the Decoder.
* ARM 11
* ARM 7
* GPU
* 2D Engine
* HD Video Encoder
* HD Video Decoder
* Audio
* Imaging
"The Zune HD’s battery capacity is 660 mAh, about 16 percent less than the 789 mAh battery in the new iPod touch. Yet the Zune promises a longer run time than the touch for both music and videos."
Ipod Touch Battery life:
Music 30 Hours
Video 6 Hours
I still want a Tegra-based cellphone with a hard gamepad built in (something that looks like the PSPGo) and big name studios developing games for it. I would love that.
@HeartBurnKid: Agent of R.O.A.C.H.: Sounds kind of like that nokia phone (I think it was nokia, having a tough time remembering because it was laughed into obscurity).
@zeroprime: Yeah, but that was terrible execution. It still had a shitty cellphone screen, for one, and you had to take out the battery to change games. And the thing was HUGE, by cellphone standards.
And don't forget sidetalking.
@lixiaochenx277: Include a cell-phone radio for online multiplayer and to consolidate my phone into the device, and I'm sold.
Edited by HeartBurnKid: Agent of R.O.A.C.H. at 12/16/09 3:34 PM
HeartBurnKid: Agent of R.O.A.C.H. was starred
HeartBurnKid: Agent of R.O.A.C.H. was unstarred
I'm sure the Linux fans won't be happy with the comparison, but this reminds me very much of "Linux on the desktop" - everyone gets way too many options for the source of the OS, the UI, the source of applications, and so on. You end up with a system that looks clunky, is tough to maintain, and has a whole pile of hodgepodge applications that all sorta do what you want, but now quite.
And to annoy even further, this is exactly why I made the move to OS X and iPhone - I'd rather have just a few options for my OS, each of them developed by experts in the field, and know that anything made for the OS will work well. Applications are easy to install, anything that wants to hook into the system knows exactly where those hooks are, and I don't burn any brain cells trying to figure out where the system preferences are for a particular app.
John, I appreciate your articles and you usually have one of the best perspectives IMHO of authors on this site, but I'm gonna have to partially disagree with you here.
I think that fragmentation merely has the potential to screw up the market. The statement that "it needs to be tightly controlled to remain consistent" is, itself, true. But the implication that consistency is necessary for success is a bit untrue.
The majority of users have yet to grasp that Android is a platform like Blackberry and not a phone like the iPhone. I had to explain to several people that my G1 runs the same software as the Droid (just an older version). Forget Sense, Blur, Rachael and whatever else there is.
Most people simply take whatever looks good and are happy with it.
There's two important parts that do need to be consolidated, though. For one, the developer experience. Google can speed through fifteen updates to Android a year. Small app companies can't. Google needs to make that process easier for them. Keep them updated to new developments. None of this dropping 2.0 source code and SDK a couple weeks before the Droid hits. The Market is what ties everything together. If the Market is the same (or similar enough), then users who don't realize that their Sense phone is just as Android as their friends Rachael phone won't care. This same logic extends to keeping manufacturers up-to-date enough to move their updated UIs out the door.
The other important part is the Google Experience brand. There's off-shoots of Android that can lag a version behind without major consequence (though Sense phones still being at 1.5 while we're on the brink of 2.1 is unacceptable), but the Google Experience phones need to be unified. If the Nexus One is a Google Experience phone (and I'm certain it is), then it needs to be running whatever the Droid is running. Whether that means the Nexus One gets 2.0 or the Droid gets a quick update to 2.1. And as many other Google Experience phones as possible, too. I realize the G1 has its own memory issues, but the MT3G has no such problems.
The Google Experience brand will be the flagship for Android. The other brands stick with their "with Google" subtitle and quietly build up Android's marketshare and app opportunities. Some users will know, others won't. Doesn't matter.
I think you're right that some other companies are dropping the ball on this, but I think that Google has made more than a few mistakes with Android, too. The process leading up to 1.6 was fairly open. We knew a lot of what was coming before it got there. Devs (whether UI or app) need to know what's coming. Well in advance. They didn't with 2.0, and 2.1 isn't much better. And the leaks are showing 2.1 to add more than just a little polish.
Honestly, I think that whatever backroom deals there were that kept the Droid so hush-hush created more of a problem than a lack of control.
Either open up or shut down, but both at the same time is destined to confuse people.
@OCEntertainment: Yeah, I didn't mean to exonerate Google here, because as you mentioned, even plain vanilla Android devices are fragmented. That's all Google.
That said, Google is notorious for being internally uncommunicative, and the dev periods for the Droid and Nexus One almost certainly overlapped. Im see this more as an admission of fault, or an attempt to right the ship. And there really isn't a graceful way to transition from the old Android model--the one that Google came up with a few years ago, before we had a strong precedent for the benefits of platform control--and a completely new one.
So Google didn't know that carriers don't push updates even though they're supposed to?
The only phone I've ever owned that got a firmware update was the iPhone. My old Curve was stuck on 4.2 for ages, in no small part because RIM sat on their ass (though T-Mobile wasn't exactly prodding them along).
"Smartphone software is finicky and complicated, and so is the experience of using it. It needs to be tightly controlled to remain consistent, and because apps are the most important part of a smartphone platform nowadays, consistency is life or death."
Interesting how this argument is diametrically opposed when it needs to be to counter or support claims to the contrary.
Tight-knit ecosystem? Open it up so all can party and play!
Haight-Ashbury free-for-all? Close it up, the contact buzz is too much!
@LangleyAlcyone: Because you have to go to one of the extremes, right? You can't have an ecosystem that both allows developers flexibility and keeps a leash on them, right?
i realize its classics BUT!!!
NEEDS::
1-Captain Falcon &/or Sonic &/or Fox
2- LBP
3- JOKER & Two-Face & Batman
4- Roshach (Watchmen guy, however ya spell his name)
5- Subzero/Scorpian/Reptile/Kano
6- Cloud/Sephiroth
7- B-Bomb & Chopper
8- ANY CLASSIC FEMALES, so i can get my GF one, so we can have matchin shirts
The only ones I knew 100% is Donkey Kong and Kirby. Who's the first one that looks like Dilbert with an eye patch?
Okay, after I looked at them further I can guess at Street Fighter, Picachu, Bowser, and Snake. I guess I'm not as lame as I thought I was (unless those are wrong, of course).
06:29 PM
I don't know if there are 4,000 of them, but still.
04:33 PM
By the way. I have a rooted G1 and I'm running Eclair with Google voice navagation.
Root your phone at your own risk folks!!!
[forum.xda-developers.com]
04:58 PM
All the hard work to make shitty WinMo less shitty.
02:53 PM
02:10 PM
02:53 PM
[apcmag.com]
The eight cores are:
* ARM 11
* ARM 7
* GPU
* 2D Engine
* HD Video Encoder
* HD Video Decoder
* Audio
* Imaging
"The Zune HD’s battery capacity is 660 mAh, about 16 percent less than the 789 mAh battery in the new iPod touch. Yet the Zune promises a longer run time than the touch for both music and videos."
Ipod Touch Battery life:
Music 30 Hours
Video 6 Hours
Zune HD:
Music 33 Hours
HD Video 8.5 Hours
01:59 PM
02:49 PM
02:59 PM
03:32 PM
And don't forget sidetalking.
@lixiaochenx277: Include a cell-phone radio for online multiplayer and to consolidate my phone into the device, and I'm sold.
01:10 PM
And to annoy even further, this is exactly why I made the move to OS X and iPhone - I'd rather have just a few options for my OS, each of them developed by experts in the field, and know that anything made for the OS will work well. Applications are easy to install, anything that wants to hook into the system knows exactly where those hooks are, and I don't burn any brain cells trying to figure out where the system preferences are for a particular app.
12:58 PM
I think that fragmentation merely has the potential to screw up the market. The statement that "it needs to be tightly controlled to remain consistent" is, itself, true. But the implication that consistency is necessary for success is a bit untrue.
The majority of users have yet to grasp that Android is a platform like Blackberry and not a phone like the iPhone. I had to explain to several people that my G1 runs the same software as the Droid (just an older version). Forget Sense, Blur, Rachael and whatever else there is.
Most people simply take whatever looks good and are happy with it.
There's two important parts that do need to be consolidated, though. For one, the developer experience. Google can speed through fifteen updates to Android a year. Small app companies can't. Google needs to make that process easier for them. Keep them updated to new developments. None of this dropping 2.0 source code and SDK a couple weeks before the Droid hits. The Market is what ties everything together. If the Market is the same (or similar enough), then users who don't realize that their Sense phone is just as Android as their friends Rachael phone won't care. This same logic extends to keeping manufacturers up-to-date enough to move their updated UIs out the door.
The other important part is the Google Experience brand. There's off-shoots of Android that can lag a version behind without major consequence (though Sense phones still being at 1.5 while we're on the brink of 2.1 is unacceptable), but the Google Experience phones need to be unified. If the Nexus One is a Google Experience phone (and I'm certain it is), then it needs to be running whatever the Droid is running. Whether that means the Nexus One gets 2.0 or the Droid gets a quick update to 2.1. And as many other Google Experience phones as possible, too. I realize the G1 has its own memory issues, but the MT3G has no such problems.
The Google Experience brand will be the flagship for Android. The other brands stick with their "with Google" subtitle and quietly build up Android's marketshare and app opportunities. Some users will know, others won't. Doesn't matter.
I think you're right that some other companies are dropping the ball on this, but I think that Google has made more than a few mistakes with Android, too. The process leading up to 1.6 was fairly open. We knew a lot of what was coming before it got there. Devs (whether UI or app) need to know what's coming. Well in advance. They didn't with 2.0, and 2.1 isn't much better. And the leaks are showing 2.1 to add more than just a little polish.
Honestly, I think that whatever backroom deals there were that kept the Droid so hush-hush created more of a problem than a lack of control.
Either open up or shut down, but both at the same time is destined to confuse people.
01:05 PM
That said, Google is notorious for being internally uncommunicative, and the dev periods for the Droid and Nexus One almost certainly overlapped. Im see this more as an admission of fault, or an attempt to right the ship. And there really isn't a graceful way to transition from the old Android model--the one that Google came up with a few years ago, before we had a strong precedent for the benefits of platform control--and a completely new one.
12:36 PM
The only phone I've ever owned that got a firmware update was the iPhone. My old Curve was stuck on 4.2 for ages, in no small part because RIM sat on their ass (though T-Mobile wasn't exactly prodding them along).
12:44 PM
01:06 PM
12:36 PM
Interesting how this argument is diametrically opposed when it needs to be to counter or support claims to the contrary.
Tight-knit ecosystem? Open it up so all can party and play!
Haight-Ashbury free-for-all? Close it up, the contact buzz is too much!
12:48 PM
12/15/09
12/15/09
12/15/09
I know I had to look up the one from Killzone, but where are people getting Snake and Link from?
12/15/09
12/15/09
NEEDS::
1-Captain Falcon &/or Sonic &/or Fox
2- LBP
3- JOKER & Two-Face & Batman
4- Roshach (Watchmen guy, however ya spell his name)
5- Subzero/Scorpian/Reptile/Kano
6- Cloud/Sephiroth
7- B-Bomb & Chopper
8- ANY CLASSIC FEMALES, so i can get my GF one, so we can have matchin shirts
12/15/09
12/15/09
Okay, after I looked at them further I can guess at Street Fighter, Picachu, Bowser, and Snake. I guess I'm not as lame as I thought I was (unless those are wrong, of course).