Gizmodo 
Enter your username and password.
-
posts about #startrekreview more → 
Star Trek Review
Star Trek Review
Tip your editors:
tips@gizmodo.com
Editorial Director:
Brian Lam | Email | Twitter
Editor:
Jason Chen
Email | AIM | Twitter
Features Editor:
Wilson Rothman
Email | Twitter
Senior Contributing Editors:
Jesus Diaz
Email | AIM | Twitter
Mark Wilson, Reviews
Email | AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editors:
Matt Buchanan
Email | AIM | Twitter
Adam Frucci
Email | Twitter
Sean Fallon
Email | Twitter
Jack Loftus
Email | Twitter
John Herrman
Email | Twitter
Dan Nosowitz
Email
Chris Mascari
Email
Danny Allen
Email | Twitter
Rosa Golijan
Email | Twitter
Chris Jacob
Email
Columnist:
Brendan I. Koerner
Interns:
Don Nguyen
Email
Kyle VanHemert
Email
Comment Intern:
Nick Ellenoff | Email
Comment Account Questions:
Comments@gizmodo.com
| posts about #startrekreview more → |
Star Trek Review |
Star Trek Review |
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.
07/15/09
ABSOLUTELY WRONG... the Borg were not even conceived of as an entity until the end of TNGs first season by writer Maurice Hurley and others. There is some SPECULATION that Gene made that Voyager COULD have visited and photgraphed the Borg homeworld. BUt this was just SPECULATION on Gene's part. It is not canon and the machine inhabitants actions do not jibe with the Borg directive anyway.
WHY should the Borg care about a crappy damaged probe and help it? It doesnt make sense.
07/17/09
Writers for Voyager expanded on this, giving the Borg the mission of assimilating cultures in the pursuit of perfection ("Omega"), similar to V'Ger. But there is no canon connection.
07/15/09
Perhaps they had just finished assimimlating the Pakleds when they found the probe. At least they were able to make it go.
07/14/09
The only movie experience worse than that which I can recall off the top of my head was watching Leonard: Part 6....
You still owe me for that one Cosby!!
07/14/09
William Decker became William Ryker
And Ilia became Deanna Troi.
07/14/09
07/14/09
Not saying III-V are terrible (even V has its good points) though I dislike ALL but First Contact of the TNG crew. But those where the most Star Trek to me, TMP exploring strange new worlds, II and VI for the human stoy of growing old growing past yourself, and 11 for adventure as well as the humor which was always present in TOS yet never properly shown on screen.
07/14/09
I originally saw it on opening day in full 70mm with SENSURROUND right smack dab in the sweet spot seat of the theater! Somehow, I don't think my home setup could EVER top that.
07/14/09
Alien: "An alien kills everyone on a space ship".
Godzilla: "Godzilla fucks up the city but dies ultimately".
Rocky: "A determined boxer almost beats the champion".
Passion of the Christ: "Jesus dies".
Predator: "The predator kills a squad of elite soldiers but is killed by the more powerful Arnold".
07/14/09
Benjamin Button: A man is born old and ages into a baby, but is killed by the more powerful Arnold.
07/14/09
Ghostbusters: "A giant stay puft marshmallow man fucks up NYC before the guys put on a light show for the Cirque du Soleil acrobat."
07/14/09
07/14/09
Anyway, this is fun. Let me have a go:
Shawshank Redemption: A man goes to jail, escapes, sands a boat, hugs morgan freeman.
07/14/09
07/14/09
07/14/09
07/14/09
07/14/09
Ok, look. Im sorry. It just slipped out.
07/14/09
07/15/09
Jingle all the Way: Arnold finds himself surrounded by urban hijinks as he attempts to purchase a high-demand toy for his child's Christmas present, but is ultimately killed by the more powerful Arnold.
07/14/09
Not until JJ Abrams creates Star Trek with Decker/Ilia machine God progeny as the new Borg queen can you draw any linkage between V'ger and the Borg...
07/14/09
Regardless, I'm definitely siding with the "If Rodenberry speaks it, it's canon" argument. I mean Star Trek is a creation directly spawned from his mind, and he kinda gets final say on what is in and what is out.
Kinda like Lucas, although I really wish that there could be some kind of way to vote Jar Jar into a character that actually eats if for being stupid. Kinda like 80% of all the clone/stormtroopers.
07/14/09
Borg Origin
Still I don't think you can say what Brannon and Braga ultimatly turned the Borg into is what Gene intended or would of wanted. Little Borg is OK. Showing up in every episode, not so much.
07/14/09
07/14/09
07/14/09
Call me odd, but 2001 and 2010 were, I felt, superior stories and a better analysis of people under pressure...
I love Star Trek in general, but outside of being pretty, I never found the movies to be "moving". The bad guys are generally one-dimensional and over-the-top.
Rather than say, they merely believe their cause is truly righteous. Wrath of Khan was probably the closest it got to a sane, pre-meditated very bad guy being well portayed on screen.
To me ST:TMP was more a visual trip of what Roddenberry wanted us to see, with a comfortable cast (Even if the cast didn't seem comfortable working together...) that we were familiar with. "Here's what we really wanted you to be seeing all along."
ST:TNG was the whole package of a good cast that (still) had chemistry and the special effects too.
07/14/09
Now that I actually think about it, its probably one of the best Star Trek films that was made, even more so, since it kinda is a stand-alone series of events. Most people would have hated 3 and 4 if they hadn't seen 2.
Big thumbs up for Jason putting this one back onto my radar.
07/14/09
07/14/09
But after reading your review (spoiler alert?), im going to watch it this weekend for sure. To hell with my wife and her Reality TV. Top Chef Masters can wait a day or two.
07/14/09
07/14/09
Keep this in mind if you ever intend to review The Holy Bible, Citizen Kane or Pong.
07/14/09
07/14/09
http://archive.salon.com/sex/feature/2000/07/28/kane/.
Take that, you spoiler-er!
07/14/09
07/14/09
07/14/09
07/14/09
07/14/09
Now if only they'd release THAT classic action flick on DVD or Blu-Ray!
07/14/09