Senior Contributing Editors:
Jesus Diaz
| AIM | Twitter
Mark Wilson, Reviews
| AIM | Twitter
Contributing Editors:
Matt Buchanan | AIM | Twitter
Adam Frucci | Twitter
Sean Fallon | Twitter
Jack Loftus | Twitter
John Herrman | Twitter
Dan Nosowitz
Chris Mascari
Kat Hannaford | Twitter
Rosa Golijan | Twitter
Chris Jacob
I thought it was common knowledge that AT&T's version of 3G is faster than Verizon's version of 3G. The real question is reliability and coverage. Bars don't mean shit.
"Gizmo your study sucks, sure it shows att is good in the area's tested but that doesn't mean it's good in other areas"
"Service sucks in my area so it must suck for everyone else!"
Sorry guys (the people commenting) you can't have it both ways. This study isn't representative of everyone's experience nor is your experience representative of everyone else s experience.
I can't say much for Tampa myself, but the majority of the surrounding areas work great on AT&T with my iPhone. I'm always the one in the back thinking "What are they talking about? Mine works fine."
There's a few homes that it doesn't work so great in, but take half a step out the door and it works again. Lead paint anyone?
@The Amazing Ant: That's the odd thing I have going on around here. I live about 30 minutes north of Tampa and reception is fantastic. As soon as I get into Tampa itself though...eh....not so much.
I remember waking up one morning and my computer screen looking like that first pic. I took out my video card and a few of the resistors had cracked open. It will be a while before 1080p will be a standard on netbooks, if netbooks do last that long...
I'm in Lansing, MI and was scared to switch to AT&T from Verizon, but six months ago I did, and couldn't be happier. I've never had a dropped call, not once, at average 1300 minutes per month. I've never had the data network fail, either, as far as I know.
@ducttape38: Depends on what revision. In theory Revision 0 can max out at 2.4mbps, while Revision A tops out at 3.1, and the lesser used Revision B can top out at 9.3
It would be nice if there was info about the time and day(s) these tests were performed; about 3 weeks ago or so, I saw my speed on T-Mobile jump in Portland.
I can see how the tests could be compromised if the protocols weren't exactly the same.
@IN THE FACE!: Actually the contrary - The complaints have been particularly centered around the largest metro areas with the densest population of high-rises that block AT&T's 3G signals. Like NYC, particularly Manhattan. There's physics behind it, not marketing.
I live outside Buffalo, NY. Suburban area. Second most depressed economy only to Detroit nationwide, and with a declining population as you'd expect. No carrier would have any business case for expansion here.
And we have literally 1 skyscraper, in the city metro.
AT&T coverage is flawless here. So is Verizon. I think you'd be challenged to find a dead area.
The challenges ARE the metro areas, mostly for the poor penetration (and resulting dead 'shadows') of signal through mazes of tall, large buildings.
Hence why they picked those locations for testing.
I spend most of my time in L.A. and the surrounding areas and I've never had any problems with AT&T. I regularly get about 1.5 to 1.6Mbps download and 500Kbps upload speeds around here.
@Gundem: Houston is some 60 miles inland but its still connected to water, it also processes most of the oil and gasoline you use unless you live very close to NJ, in which case Houston only supplies a large chunk of it. Your fancy pants Dell was made in Austin, you know where SXSW is? yeah the indie music Mecca? thats the one. Dallas.. well aside from the Toadies nothing good ever came from Dallas, but i only say that because i'm from San Antonio and i think the Dallas accent makes us all look stupid.
i dont live there anymore, but dont mess with Texas; cuz i'll kick your tree huggin' Volvo drivin' Cheese eatin' surrender monkey ass. ;)
01:17 AM
12:34 AM
12:36 AM
12:11 AM
12/21/09
"Gizmo your study sucks, sure it shows att is good in the area's tested but that doesn't mean it's good in other areas"
"Service sucks in my area so it must suck for everyone else!"
Sorry guys (the people commenting) you can't have it both ways. This study isn't representative of everyone's experience nor is your experience representative of everyone else s experience.
12/21/09
There's a few homes that it doesn't work so great in, but take half a step out the door and it works again. Lead paint anyone?
12:38 AM
12/21/09
12/21/09
Oh well--time to check on the cattle and oil well in my backyard.
12:12 AM
12/21/09
Wait isn't that what they were whining about with Verizion?
I'll take more 3G over faster 3G any day.
12/21/09
12/21/09
12/21/09
12/21/09
12/21/09
12/21/09
12/21/09
[www.pollsb.com]
Probably going to have problems. Poor guy/girl, doesn't stand a chance...
12/21/09
Can somebody tell me why I'm wrong?
12/21/09
12/21/09
12/21/09
12/21/09
I can see how the tests could be compromised if the protocols weren't exactly the same.
12/21/09
*Provided you live in one of the 12 largest metros in the us (and never leave them, unless you are flying directly to another one)...
**Otherwise you're iPwnt.
12/21/09
I live outside Buffalo, NY. Suburban area. Second most depressed economy only to Detroit nationwide, and with a declining population as you'd expect. No carrier would have any business case for expansion here.
And we have literally 1 skyscraper, in the city metro.
AT&T coverage is flawless here. So is Verizon. I think you'd be challenged to find a dead area.
The challenges ARE the metro areas, mostly for the poor penetration (and resulting dead 'shadows') of signal through mazes of tall, large buildings.
Hence why they picked those locations for testing.
12/21/09
12/21/09
12/21/09
Nevermind that Dallas/Ft. Worth is the 5th largest Metropolitan area in the United States... Yeah, they don't need coverage at all.
(And for the record, AT&T blows down here.)
12/21/09
12/21/09
AT&T coverage sucks ballz in KS.
12/21/09
*redneck suit on*
12/21/09
i dont live there anymore, but dont mess with Texas; cuz i'll kick your tree huggin' Volvo drivin' Cheese eatin' surrender monkey ass. ;)
12/21/09
I drive a VW R32.
12:29 AM
i kid i kid my friend for as much as i hate the stereotype i feel huge urges to play it out, satirically of course.