Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything - Gizmodo Comments

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

editor58 — Tue, 17 Apr 2007 21:20:36 EDT

Lower Prices Mel? Two Words!! Bull SHIT!
You, Mel are a Business GENIUS, and a Bull Shit Artist. I worked for you! And you're still the best at Shoveling Manure to your employees and the stockholders. Stern 500 Million? How about Darfur or hell… Flint, Michigan, or Louisiana? Mel, go to hell!
Your merger testimony was only missing one thing… a PIG SUIT.

editor58

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

Skeptical_Geezer — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 16:36:41 EST

1) Anti-monopoly laws do NOT apply only to necessities.
2) Based on Karmazan's reasoning, it would be fine to allow only one automobile manufacturer, because there are also motorcycles, buses, bicycles and trains.

Skeptical_Geezer

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

HelperMonkey — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 13:53:34 EST

@strider_mt2k: I really disagree. I think the Stern show is better than it's ever been and has really hit it's stride on satellite.

HelperMonkey

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

Worf — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 13:32:41 EST

And if they get rid of Cinemagic, I'm dropping my XM sub. It's one of the few channels that is completely unique to XM (Sirius doesn't carry anything close). All the other music channels have Sirius equivalents... as are all the other channels.

Worf

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

Hat Trick — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 12:03:20 EST

God forbid the FCC "protects" us from the ramifications of a combined company, thereby preventing better programming choices for consumers and profitability for shareholder.

The only way this market is profitable is if they combine operations and spread their considerable fixed costs over a wider user base. The Stern deal was insane money, yes, but an act of desperation to get subscribers over to Sirius. And guess what: it worked. A combined company will be in a much better position to market premium content that you can't replicate via mp3/podcast/etc.

Hat Trick

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

strider_mt2k — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 11:09:34 EST

I signed up for Sirius to follow Howard over, but I haven't listened to the show in over 6 months because it hasn't changed one iota since the switch.

I find the music channels to be awesome because they play music that ISN'T on my MP3 player.

Okay and the Jack Benny Program on Sirius Radio Classics is kinda funny too.

Man, that guy was cheap!

strider_mt2k

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

lschofield — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 11:02:26 EST

Flawed business plan executed poorly. They them both go down in flames, and let a better business person pick up the pieces for cheap and prosper. They screwed themselves when they thought paying Stern all that money was the path to salvation.

Because here's how this repeats itself. They'll promise great new things like satelite video if they could only merge. Then, they'll decide to pay billions of dollars to woo talent to that channel, then they'll go bust again.

Side note: satellite video already exists for your car... http://www.mobilevideo4less.com/tracvision.html

lschofield

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

fastm3driver — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 10:44:37 EST

They need to require them to offer a 20 station minimum free service that is add supported.

fastm3driver

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

vinnygny — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 10:15:19 EST

I like Inajeep heard Martine this morning too. I'm all for the merger.

vinnygny

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

vinnygny — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 10:09:29 EST

There is absolutely no logical reason why they should not allow this merger. If anyone can come up with one, let me know. Don't give me the monopoly BS. Satellite radio is a pay service, not a necessary commodity. I don't think monopoly should apply. Sattelite radios original patent (Sirius) was supposed to be for a full range of frequencies. The government decided to split it in half and let 2 competing companies have a go at it. I say let them merge and give one company the full range as was originally intended. I want to watch streaming video in my car

vinnygny

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

liquidsoapdispenser — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 09:47:06 EST

I say the merger may be the only thing will save either company. I'm glad I am not a customer of either, but who knows, in the future if they combined thier talent and cut costs, maybe enough people would subscribe that they could turn a profit.

Ehhh, they'll probably go broke whatever they try; too many other ways for consumers to get on-demand programming.

liquidsoapdispenser

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

inajeep — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 09:44:01 EST

I listened to Martin(inventor of satellite radio) on Howard Stern this morning and found out something interesting. When the FCC decided to split the Sat radio freq. it actually limited it's functionality. If the freq are combined again, streaming sat video will be more capable.

The reason Sat radio is becoming so popular is because of the content. Stern, Baseball, NASCAR. Not canned music that you could play on your iPod.

It's not a monopoly because you don't have to pay for it. There is also free radio. This is not Cable which is a monopoly because I don't have any choices.

inajeep

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

trunk666 — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 09:37:30 EST

they are BOTH in debt big time.

If they take away the metal station (Hard Attack) on Sirius I'm going postal.

trunk666

Mr. Karmazin Goes to Washington: Siriusly You Guys, Let Us Merge! We'll Do Anything

Trojan — Thu, 01 Mar 2007 09:27:09 EST

The first question is... "why" does he want this so bad?

Forget about regulatory hurdles, the Sirius stock values are depressed because they cannot make money with their current model... XM is not that far behind, but seems to be more frugle with the money being thrown at talent or content. In the end, both companies original models projected profitability at 10mm subs.

That model was thrown out the window when SatRad started competing for "talent" like Howard.

The question then becomes, can one company be viable with 14-18mm subs? Mel knows that one of the two companies will crumble under the weight of the costs associated to their bloated contracts, and Sirius is closer to this scenario than XM is.

Protect the stock holders at all costs... forget about the services and customers, a monopoly protects the revenue stream.

Yea, I'm a little pissed about the merger.

Trojan