<![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents - Gizmodo Comments]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents - Gizmodo Comments]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> P.S. When Comcast dies, I'll piss on their grave:)

TNTBW

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @uberfu:
Comcast actually sent me a nasty E-mail a while back because I supposedly downloaded an episode of Battlestar Galactica using Bit Torrent, crying about copyright infringement blah blah blah, they threatened to cut off my service. The thing that got me so mad was that they are so retarded as to make available only the first part of a two part episode of that show on their "on demand", I waited two weeks for them to update it and they never did, so i used the means available to me to see the conclusion. My feeling is they need to get off their over paid lazy asses and provide a great service for their highly priced cable , if not, then mind their own business of raping the consumer with the monopoly on broadband they have for now, but hopefully not forever.

TNTBW

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @mrhammerstein: No he's not.

Sabre_Justice: Okay, no more long name.

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> This is good AND bad.
Good because people will have more info on the service they are paying for. Thus allowing them to choose and pay for good services.

On the other hand, good ISPs will end up having a harder time being so... because if too many heavy P2P users migrate to this or that ISP, they'll eventually have some bandwidth problems if they don't upgrade their equipment....

Bokusatsu_Tenshi

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> No Linux or Mac support either.
Would have been nice if they listed the system compatibility on the plugin website.
It's kind of a gip when a Java based application doesn't work across systems.

bunkacid

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @Jimbuck: you do know BaRRack is against free speech, right?

mrhammerstein

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> Everyone is screaming against Comcast - and according to Azureus' Wiki - Comcast only block Seeding - but only then to a certain extent_ This doesn't seem to help the case against Comcast_

I'm not too happy with them by any means - they are my service provider for internet/TV - but they may be throttling in certain locations and not others_

I can Seed/ upload/ download torrent all day long_ I typically have mine capped so they stop at a certain point - but otherwise not too many issues_

I have been talking with folks who have Comcast in various areas of the country and what we're noticing is more of a limitation on the total advertised thru-put_ My account says I should be getting 6Mbps down and 256Kbps up and I haven't noticed anything near these marks_

In contrast I work at a major university and they are on an Internet Backbone [2 of them in fact] and the up/ down thru-put is significantly different from home to office_ In one regard this should be normal - but I can use a traffic Stat monitor [same App at work and home] and it shows just how much incoming and outgoing traffic is passing by_

Comcast is a giant whore-poration_

uberfu

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @Zenshai: If you're using Az, check to see if the automated throttling is enabled. They have a function built whose purpose (I think) is to try and defeat the bittorrent throttling. You can look in the lower right corner to see what you're current throttle limit is. It gimped my downloads til I turned it off, but then again, I'm not a power downloader, so they probably don't mind as much that I max out my connection for 10-20 minutes every once in a while.

on a possibly related note, i've noticed within the last few weeks that my internet will lag horribly for no apparent reason (with no BT running). It's hard to tell if i'm being throttled by some bad algorithm, or its just shitty comcast service. the latter is always possible since they basically feel free to split their connection signals until it becomes so bad people complain. and then they usually try to tell you it would all be fine if you just had better wiring to your unit (technically possible, but it wouldn't be necessary if they didn't fuck up the source signal so much to being with)

Accelerata

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> this is good.

jkr

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> This is one of the few things that makes AT&T/Bellsouth worth it! NO throttling at all.

hammertime1994

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> if only the plugin worked for uTorrent...hope they make one.

mricyfire

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> I've worked for a few ISP's over the years. I have to chime in on this.
1st off there is no such thing as a legitimate torrent.
Before you flame me hear me out.
What the legitimate companies are doing is foisting off the bandwidth charges onto the internet provider instead of hosting a file server.
Its like people who use their residential service for business.
Its not what it was designed for.

I have a real problem with people saying this is a net neutrality issue. Its not its about a network managing the way data is run over the network not the content of the data.

Save the cries of net neutrality for when ISP want to direct legitimate content based off pay for preference. That's net neutrality.

This whole torrent argument boils down to I want something for free and now I can't get it.

Even so called legitimate torrents don't want to pay bandwidth costs they would rather have the ISP's bare that cost.
Yet people are the first to scream if the ISP raises the prices.

Its not what it was designed for.

I have a real problem with people saying this is a net neutrality issue. Its not its about a network managing the way data is run over the network not the content of the data.

Save the cries of net neutrality for when ISP want to direct legitimate content based off pay for preference. Thats net neutrality.
Please don't say well they didn't say I couldn't do that. Actually they usually do people just choose to ignore it. Most ISPs in their terms of service forbid running a server and when you do torrents you've become a server. It isn't poorly written it isn't confusing. People just don't want to read it.

This whole torrent argument boils down to I want something for free and now I can't get it.

Even so called legitimate torrents don't want to pay bandwidth costs they would rather have the ISP's bare that cost.
Yet people are the first to scream if the ISP raises the prices.

So please let it rest find some other loop whole to bog down the network till the companies find a way to plug it up.









Dtarot

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @michaelportent: maybe they shouldn't oversell their capacity then? it is hardly something the consumer should be blamed for. either sell what you say you will sell or don't. but make it clear upfront.

x23

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> The problem is, BitTorrent users ARE actually gobbling up bandwidth from other broadband customers. Especially in rural areas where bandwidth is at a premium.

But the responsibility lies with the provider to guarantee their up/down speeds regardless of what sort of usage is occurring. And sapping bandwidth from anybody is an awful practice.

michaelportent

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> I dont know what it is then... I'm on Cablevision's Optimum Online and my torrents never go over 200kbps. I was sure they were being throttled but according to the wiki thats not the case.

Anyone know what else it could be? Or is that just the kind of speeds everyone gets on public torrents?

Zenshai

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> uTorrent FTW

MrBlahBlah

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> Qwest DSL does too.

I've found this out by doing my own testing by using www.speedtest.net.

chiablo

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @lafond66: My friend has had cablevision for a while and he has optimum boost and whenever he uses limewire or a torrent program he gets a not saying that if he keeps using those programs (he's a power downloader btw) they'll be forced to send his isp and information to the FCC
he basically gets 5 chances every month.
Maybe they just dont like him.
Too bad i dont like azerus i never got good download speeds with them even when i tweaked the settings.

SneakerFiend

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @do_tell: Time to switch!

Kaiser-Machead's Chips Ahoy!

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @Kaiser-Machead:
On Verizon's FiOS in NYC I was getting about 2MB/s from private torrent sites.

A Puckish Satire of Contemporary Mores

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @lafond66:
I'd say preventing seeding is pretty bad.

A Puckish Satire of Contemporary Mores

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @lafond66: So does mine. Often I've had large multi-GB files coming in at over 200kb/s with no problem. It's great.

Kaiser-Machead's Chips Ahoy!

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @Monty: YEARRGH!

Way

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @ViperBorg: Phonetically, I placed the additional R in there to give it more emphasis. Similiar to the way tony the tiger insists on telling everyone how "Grreat!" his frosted flakes are. I do appreciate the gesture Viper. :)

Jimbuck

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> It could be worse. Comcast suspended my connection for excessive bandwidth usage, citing a terms of service agreement that may be changed at any time.

This isn't too much of an issue yet, however with HD video becoming more prevalent I think more users will have similar problems in the future.

tanukineri

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @Jimbuck: You mean Barack?

ViperBorg

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> I'd gladly share those sort of datums to help out Azureus, except their client is so inferior to uTorrent it isn't really worth it.

mhlaxp

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> Well shiver me timbers. Nice to see the pirate ships have a new weapon.

Monty

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> The multimedia battle continues...It's absolutely amazing to think about how these situations with OpenNet and censorship will affect us in 5 years....I don't want to get political but...ok, i do. Go BARRACK! Yes, I said it.

Jimbuck

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> pretty sure ACS in Alaska recently started doing this. first it was just bittorrent traffic. but now it seems that when i have bittorrent running at all my entire connection goes in the shitter.

spending $100/mo for a 3Mb internet connection is already pretty outrageous... even more so when i find out i'm not actually paying for a real-life internet connection at all but rather a "whatever-the-phone-company-thinks-i-should-be-allowed-to-use-it-for-based-on-random-whims" connection.

good thing my contract just ended. going to move to a cable modem as soon as i can get the line installed. faster and for $30 more than i already pay i can get cable television and a DVR (less torrents needed then anyway).

x23

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> Awesome.
I mean the Wiki link not the fact that the bastard POS ISPs are trying to choke out torrents.

It's a good link for the fact that we have Cox where I am and it looks like they only limit bandwidth for accounts with a high traffic volume, and don't put a cap on torrents or deny seeding. Good 2 know, as I have had suspicions of Cox sabotaging my torrents but I think at the time, now that I think about it, it must have been a setting on my end.


Out2gtcha

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> @lafond66: All cable vision does is prevent seeding, I see nothing wrong with that.

lafond66

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> No Mac Version yet. But they say its coming.

SgtBeavis

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> Cablevision? really? My torrents go incredibly fast with Optimum Online. Faster than they do here in college.

lafond66

]]> <![CDATA[BitTorrent Plugin Detects ISPs Raping Your Torrents]]> Love the Wiki list. DAMN YOU, COGECO!

Etruscan

]]>