Neptune. (Image: NASA)

In 2015, the Hubble Space Telescope detected a strange feature in the skies over Neptuneā€”a swirling dark vortex the size of China. Packing copious amounts of hydrogen sulfideā€”the chemical ingredient that gives farts their awful smellā€”this storm is not behaving as astronomers predicted, with the latest results suggesting the dark vortex is dying.

Neptuneā€™s dark vortices were first discovered in the late 1980s by NASAā€™s Voyager 2 spacecraft. In all, only five of these dark spots have ever been documented on Neptune, the farthest planet from the sun, with the most recent one appearing in 2015 (dubbed SDS-2015, meaning ā€œsouthern dark spot discovered in 2015"). Thereā€™s literally only one instrument currently in operation that can detect and track these vortices, namely the Hubble Space Telescope. Using its Wide Field Camera 3, Hubble can see the otherwise invisible movements on Neptuneā€™s cloudy surface at blue optical wavelengths.


A close-up of the observed dark vortex (Image: NASA, ESA, and M.H. Wong and J. Tollefson (UC Berkeley))

As best as we can tell, these vortices form when clouds of gas and air in Neptuneā€™s atmosphere swirl and freeze in the cold temperatures. The frozen mass then drifts in the atmosphere like a gigantic pancake. These storms spin in an anti-cyclonic direction, similar to Jupiterā€™s famous Great Red Spot. As it churns, Neptuneā€™s vortex pulls up material from deep within the planetā€™s atmosphere, including copious amounts of hydrogen sulfide, which smells like rotten eggs and nasty farts. But unlike Jupiterā€™s spotā€”which has been lingering for at least the past 200 yearsā€”these storms are relatively fleeting, lasting only a few years. New research published in the Astronomical Journal shows that SDS-2015 is now entering into its death throes.

Observations made between 2015 and 2017 show the dark vortex fading away. (Image: Hubble/NASA/UC Berkeley)


Observations made from September 2015 to October 2017 show that the spotā€™s contrast to the surrounding area dropped from about 7 percent to 3 percent during this period. The clouds in the dark spot are still highly reflective, but slightly darker than the particles in the surrounding atmosphere. The new study, which included astronomers from UC Berkeley and Spainā€™s University of Basque Country, is the first to show a vortexā€™s death stage in action.

ā€œMany questions remain as to how dark vortices originate, what controls their drift and oscillation, how they interact with the environment, and how they eventually dissipate,ā€ write the authors in the new study. ā€œVortex behavior also provides insight into the structure and dynamics of the surrounding atmosphere.ā€

Astronomers theorize that the vortices arise from an instability caused by the sheared eastward and westward winds, and theyā€™ve created models to predict the movement of SDS-2015. But as the recent study points out, the models have not matched reality, and the spot is behaving unpredictably.


ā€œIt looks like weā€™re capturing the demise of this dark vortex, and itā€™s different from what well-known studies led us to expect,ā€ Michael Wong, a co-author of the new study and a researcher at UC Berkeley, said in a statement. ā€œ[Previous] dynamical simulations said that anticyclones under Neptuneā€™s wind shear would probably drift toward the equator. We thought that once the vortex got too close to the equator, it would break up and perhaps create a spectacular outburst of cloud activity.ā€

So the vortex, which was first seen in the ice giantā€™s mid-southern latitudes, is not going out with this expected bang, and is instead slowly fading away into oblivion. Its fate may have something to do with the unexpected direction of its drift. Neptuneā€™s gigantic fart is currently moving very slowly in a southerly direction, traversing a distance of about 1.7 degrees to 2.5 degrees of latitude each year. Unlike Jupiterā€™s Great Red Spot, which is kept in place by broad jet streams, Neptune features just three broad streamsā€”one that blows westward at the equator, and a pair that blows in an eastward at the poles. This allows Neptuneā€™s vortex to be a shiftless drifter, changing its ā€œtraffic lanesā€ in ways that are difficult to anticipate.


The latest study shows that Neptuneā€™s vortices are highly variable, transient, and recurring features; theyā€™re like snowflakes, similar but not exactly the same. The astronomers will continue to monitor the vortex with Hubble, and weā€™ll see where it goes from hereā€”and if and when a new dark spot appears.

[Astronomical Journal]