Best Under $500

Despite a tight budget, we should all be able to end our day on a bed that offers relaxation and restorative sleep. Sleep is a crucial part of our overall health and well-being, and finding the right new mattress can help deliver this critical need of our body and mind. Unfortunately, those of us navigating the budget mattress market with limited funds may approach with low expectations and end up settling for an inferior bed than what may have been possible. However, this article may present some exciting options to help you reconsider your expectations and find an affordable mattress that fits your needs and improves your life. Here we will help you to discover some of the best mattresses under $500 available today.

The products featured in this article have been independently reviewed by the team. When you buy something through the retail links on this page, we may earn commission at no cost to you, the reader.

Our Top Picks for The Best Mattress Under $500

Best Overall Mattress Under $500 - Siena Original

Best Overall Mattress Under $500 - Siena Original

Mattress Type: Foam

Firmness: Medium (6/10)

Sleep Trial: 180 Nights

Warranty: 10-Year Limited

Mattress Advisor Score: N/A

Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Offering a supremely comfortable sleep, free shipping and a generous trial period and limited warranty make the Siena an all-around great bargain. The Siena is a five-layer cool gel memory foam mattress that, despite the price, resembles and offers many of the traits of more expensive luxury beds. Siena’s foundation consists of a shift-resistant cover to prevent sagging and movement underneath a durable foundational layer of foam that helps ensure sturdy support throughout the mattress. A two-inch dense foam at the bed’s core is designed to support the top two layers while generating broader airflow. On top are two layers dedicated to delivering maximum comfort. With a responsive memory foam layer underneath a cool and cozy mattress cover top. The Siena offers excellent pressure relief and is uniquely breathable for an all-foam bed. With the Siena offering such impressive features while maintaining a genuinely affordable price tag, we have determined it to be the best overall mattress under $500.

Notes from the Testing Team

Coming soon!

Best Hybrid Mattress Under $500 - Linenspa Hybrid

Best Mattress Under $500

Mattress Type: Hybrid

Firmness: Medium-firm (6.5/10)

Sleep Trial: 30 Nights

Warranty: 10-year

Mattress Advisor Score: 7.5/10

Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Hybrid beds are a fusion of the best qualities of all-foam and innerspring mattresses. The Linenspa is a hybrid mattress offering remarkable support and comfort without the hefty price tag. This bed-in-a-box is perfect for sleepers struggling with back pain, scoring a truly impressive 9 out of 10 for its ability to keep your spine correctly aligned as you sleep. Combination sleepers can expect consistent comfort as they move across the bed due to the Linenspa’s excellent responsiveness (9/10). Furthermore, scoring an 8.5 out of 10 in pressure relief makes the bed great for side sleepers. The Linenspa is also a go-to for couples due to the bed’s ability to accommodate various sleeper types while also scoring high in preventing disruptive motion transfer between sleepers (8.5/10). In conclusion, the bed is remarkably cheap, especially considering its competitive scores even when compared to expensive mattresses in the hybrid model.

Notes from the Testing Team

“While the price may suggest otherwise, the Linenspa’s outstanding spinal support and responsiveness are quite impressive, even when compared to more expensive hybrid models. With free shipping and returns, plus a generous 10-year warranty, the Linenspa is one of the better deals around. However, for those who need superior edge support, you may want to reconsider.”

Best Memory Foam Mattress Under $500 - Zinus Green Tea Memory Foam

Best Affordable RV Mattress - Zinus Green Tea Memory Foam

Mattress Type: Memory foam

Firmness: Medium-soft (4.5/10)

Sleep Trial: 100 Nights

Warranty: 10-Year Limited

Mattress Advisor Score: 7.8/10

Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

We tend to expect cozy comfort and pain relief when considering memory foam beds. The Zinus Green Tea all-foam mattress lives up to such expectations. For those concerned that memory foam beds do not offer adequate posture support, especially for people struggling with back pain, the Zinus Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress is CertiPUR-US® certified and may surprise you with its near-perfect 9 out of 10 score for spinal alignment. Side and combination sleepers can rest assured to experience relief and comfort across the bed’s exterior, with the bed’s 8 out of 10 scores in both responsiveness and pressure relief. Couples with different sleep patterns may also want to consider the Zinus Green Tea due to the bed’s excellent ability to deter motion transference between sleepers (9/10). The Zinus Green Tea is a four-layered memory foam bed that exceeds the expectations you may associate with its very affordable price.

Notes from the Testing Team 

“This memory foam mattress offers significant comfort without compromising support. Expect great pressure relief, responsiveness and spinal support with the Zinus Green Tea. Furthermore, the bed is great at isolating motion and helping prevent couples from disturbing each other. However, if durability is a priority, you may want to look elsewhere, as this mattress may have a shorter life span than pricer versions.”

Best Cooling Mattress Under $500 - Dreamfoam Essential

Best RV Mattress for Bunk Beds - Dreamfoam Chill

Mattress Type: Memory foam

Firmness: Medium-soft (4/10), medium (5/10), medium-firm (6/10), firm (7/10)

Sleep Trial: 120 Nights

Warranty: 10-Year Limited

Mattress Advisor Score: N/A

Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

A sweaty sleep experience is certainly never pleasant. The Dreamfoam Essential memory foam mattress is an affordable bed that can help provide a refreshing night’s sleep for hot sleepers. While many memory foam beds have a poor reputation for breathability, airflow, and overheating, this mattress is built to be an exception. The Essential has a two-layer construction, with a high-density foam base layer supporting a top layer dedicated to providing comfort and cooling. In addition, the Essential’s construction consists entirely of foam specifically designed to be more breathable than other all-foam beds. The Dreamfoam Essential gently responds by contouring to your body as you move, helping to actively deliver comfort and cradles you without trapping heat. The Dreamfoam Essential is also uniquely available in five thickness sizes and four firmness levels, giving you more choices when customizing your sleep experience. The bed’s superior cooling materials and high-quality comfort at a discounted price point make the Dreamfoam Essential an excellent budget-friendly choice for hot sleepers.

Notes from the Testing Team

Coming soon!

Best Mattress for Couples Under $500 - Allswell Original

Best Mattress for Couples Under $500 - Allswell Original

Mattress Type: Hybrid

Firmness: Medium-firm (7/10)

Sleep Trial: 100 Nights

Warranty: 10-year Limited

Mattress Advisor Score: 8.2/10

Available Sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Sometimes we want to cuddle with our partner, and sometimes we just need our space. The Allswell is a highly affordable hybrid mattress that offers excellent benefits for couples who share the bed. Whether your sleeping patterns differ or you tend to wake your partner during the night, the Allswell scored an impressive 9 out of 10 for its ability to isolate motion. The mattress is also suitable for all sleeper types, helping couples to more easily settle on the Allswell when choosing a bed together due to its versatility. Furthermore, the Allswell offers great therapeutic support for sleepers struggling with back or general chronic pain, scoring an 8.5 out of 10 in spinal alignment and 8.25 out of 10 for its ability to relieve pressure points. In conclusion, the Allswell’s impressive features for couples and surprisingly affordable price make it an excellent choice for couples on a budget. 

Notes from the Testing Team

“The Allswell is an incredible mattress for couples at an unbeatable price. You get what you pay for and more! Notably, though, when choosing the Allswell, take into account that the mattress may run a little firm and also take a little extra time to break in.”

How Mattress Advisor Found the Best Mattresses Under $500

Mattress Advisor is an unbiased mattress product tester. The company invests countless hours investigating quality mattresses and consulting sleep specialists to help consumers determine which bed is right for them. 

The Mattress Advisor Testing Process

Mattress Advisor uses a comprehensive mattress review testing process when determining the quality of a mattress. Conclusions are made based on various tests focusing on a bed’s key performance features. Once sleep specialists have made all considerations after evaluating a mattress, information is consolidated and delivered to consumers to help them determine the best bed to match their needs.

Key Performance Factors that the Sleep Lab Tests

Factors They TestWhat It Means
CoolingThis is the mattress’s ability to deliver a neutral and cool sleep-friendly temperature.
Motion IsolationThis is the mattress’s ability to deter motion transference throughout its core when responding to a sleeper's movements.
Pressure ReliefThis is the mattress’s ability to evenly disperse a sleeper's body weight and help prevent or reduce inflammation.
ResponsivenessThis is the mattress’s ability to consistently provide comfort when adapting to your body as it moves across the bed's surface.
Edge SupportThis is the determination of the stability of a bed's edges when someone is sleeping near them or sitting on them.
Spine AlignmentThis is the determination of a mattress's ability to maintain the healthy alignment of the spine while sleeping.
Firmness This is the determination of a bed’s firmness. Your sleeping patterns, joint health and whether you are experiencing back pain should be the deciding factors when determining your mattress's firmness.

How to Pick The Best Mattress Under $500

When choosing a more affordable mattress, it is important to compare a bed’s attributes to its price range. Start by determining your budget and prioritized needs, then refer to reviews and tests by specialists to see which bed best lives up to both. 

Memory Foam 

Memory foam mattresses are typically more affordable and notoriously very comfortable. However, they are usually more ideal for side sleepers due to their softer firmness. In comparison, back sleepers, for example, may need a harder firm mattress associated more with hybrid or innerspring beds. 

Hybrid 

Hybrid beds combine the plush comfort of all-foam or all-latex mattresses with the breathability and support found in the pocketed coil foundations of innerspring mattresses. Furthermore, hybrids offer more versatility, making them ideal for combination sleepers or indecisive shoppers.

Sleep Positions and Why They Matter

How you sleep very much determines the type of mattress you should bring into your home.

Side Sleepers

Side sleepers tend to apply excess weight to specific points of the body for extended periods. Without a bed with adequate pressure relief, inflammation and soreness can develop and worsen over time. Side sleepers usually need a softer mattress that can relieve pressure while still providing healthy spinal support and cushioning.

Back Sleepers

Beds with a more rigid firmness tend to be the preference of back sleepers. Mattresses with a harder firmness usually help to better maintain the healthy alignment of your spine. The more firm the bed, the less likely for the unhealthy sinkage of your body that may lead to the unequal distribution of your body’s weight across the bed as you sleep (which can lead to isolated soreness or inflammation).

Stomach Sleepers 

Stomach sleepers usually prefer harder mattresses. Like back sleepers, your weight is more equally distributed across the bed than side sleepers. However, isolated pressure on the neck and shoulders can lead to inflammation over time. Therefore, stomach sleepers need a firmer mattress that offers excellent pressure relief while preventing sinkage around the waistline.

Combination Sleepers 

Combination sleepers who move around while they sleep need a bed suitable to all sleeper types. Hybrids are typically an excellent choice for combination sleepers due to their versatility. A medium-firm feel is usually preferable for combination sleepers as well, as it meets all the sleep positions in the middle.

Other Physical Considerations When Buying the Best Mattress Under $500

Sleep is an indispensable element of living a healthy life. Therefore picking the right mattress is something we should consider very important to our overall well-being.

Best Mattress for Couples

A high-quality mattress with motion isolation is something couples should look out for. Good motion isolation helps to stop couples from interrupting each other’s sleep if one tends to move around at night. This helps to prevent resentment between couples that may occur due to disrupted sleep. Additionally, couples should look into the quality of a bed’s edge support to know a bed offers consistent comfort even when you spread out.

Best Mattress for Hot Sleepers 

People who struggle to fall asleep due to feeling warm should seek a hybrid or innerspring bed due to the superior airflow in their designs when compared to all-foam mattresses.

Best Mattress for Heavy Sleepers

More rigid firmness in a mattress is typically the go-to for heavier sleepers. However, before choosing a mattress, heavier sleepers should always refer to the cited weight capacity of a bed.

Best Mattress for Sex 

When considering adult activities, you want adequate support and a strong foundation in a mattress. Therefore, a bed’s responsiveness and durability should be reviewed when choosing the right bed for sex.

Frequently Asked Questions