Skip to content
Television

‘The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power’ Serves Up Plenty of Torture and Torment

Nobody's happy in episodes five and six as Sauron's quest cranks up the pain levels across Middle-earth and Númenor.
By

Reading time 13 minutes

After that supersized four-episode drop to kick off season three, The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power inches closer to Sauron’s creation of the One Ring—that’s no spoiler; we know he does it eventually—by bringing more misery to everyone. That includes extreme physical and mental pain in the Dark Lord’s torture chamber, but also the anguish of Elrond and High King Gil-Galad having to make nice with the odious men who rule Númenor.

Who’s hungry for sea worms? Pull up a chair and let’s dig into episodes five and six of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power season three.

Io9 2025 Spoiler warning

Marnûkh is back in Sauron’s clutches, tied up for torture. That’s not to say he’s lost his sense of humor; when the Dark Lord asks him if he’s got anything to say before his interrogation begins, the Orc replies, “My ass is itchy.” He also gets in a “Hail Adar.”

Sauron is in no mood for jokes. He needs to know where Galadriel and Celeborn went.

Marnûkh doesn’t want to spill, but Sauron has managed to suss out his weak point: his children. Who knew Orcs were so paternal? In a panic, Marnûkh blurts out that their plan was to head to the Greenwood.

But it’s all for nothing. His kids are already dead, because that’s how Sauron rolls. When the grieving Orc begs for his own swift death, the Dark Lord says, snottily, “You will live so that when the Master Ring is on my hand, you will know the privilege of obeying my every command.”

Nearby, Theo stares mournfully at Arondir’s armor. It’s in a burn pit where, we can assume, Arondir’s body was recently torched. Sauron orders the Orcs to bring the fugitive Elves back “alive and capable of speech.” Then he dramatically declares, “Let the hunt begin.”

Rings Of Power Sauron 2
© Prime Video

We get a glimpse of Celeborn and Galadriel frantically racing through a forest. Back in Mordor, Theo gets Sauron’s attention and says that since “speaking to the dead” is part of the whole Nazgnagôl deal, he’d very much like to talk to his mother.

Sauron isn’t going to allow that; reconnecting with Brownwyn would be a surefire way to turn Theo away from the Dark Lord. “Be not a fool, my servant,” is Sauron’s dismissive response. Theo gazes at the fire again, and we can tell his faith is already wavering.

We get a far more soothing setting for a flashback with Elrond and his twin brother, Elros. This is the pivotal conversation where Elros tells Elrond he’s decided to embrace the human side of their heritage—showing off his newly rounded ears—and shares his plans for Númenor, “a new land for a new kind of men, one where they can live out their lives in peace.”

Elrond can’t understand why his brother would give up immortality for men, who “fall so easily.” Elros emphasizes that these men, these Númenóreans, will be different: “They helped save Middle-earth. Perhaps one day they will do so again. They just need someone to show them the way.”

As the Elves sail toward Númenor, Elrond tells High King Gil-galad he hopes Elros was right about the men there. But he’s afraid his own worries about them might be true instead.

In the forest, Celeborn and Galadriel finally stop sprinting. She’s shocked he’s alive; he’s shocked she’s really there. She’s also shocked to hear he was at the dreaded Thangorodrim until it fell, since she was also there “searching for one of Morgoth’s leftenants.”

Celeborn says thoughts of Galadriel—alive and happy—are what gave him hope during his long captivity. She insists she hasn’t found a new partner in his absence. However, he senses “there is something you fear to tell me.” The moment is interrupted when a group of Orcs stomps into earshot.

Elrond and Gil-galad agree they’re impressed by Númenor. But they’ve both noticed “something uneasy” in the air. They suspect Pharazôn wants something from them as much as they want him to lend his army to Middle-earth’s cause. But… what?

There’s also some social awkwardness to get through. Everyone in the throne room stares openly at Elrond, who of course is an exact replica of Númenor’s first king (aside from the ears). Lord Belzagar even asks to touch his perfectly smooth face.

This awe lasts until Elrond proudly presents a very special, symbolically chosen Elven wine they’ve brought as a gift. Belzagar brushes it aside, explaining it won’t pair well with the meal they’ve planned. RUDE.

Especially RUDE when you realize they’re serving sea worms!

Somehow, Elrond manages to use that subject as a segue into the Elves’ reason for visiting. Gil-galad explains the gravity of the Sauron situation and the peril that the Elves are in. The High King wants to know if Pharazôn will “capture the moment the ages offer him or shrink from it.”

Belzagar snips back with “It isn’t our fight.”

Gil-galad emphasizes, again, that it will be, because after Sauron conquers Middle-earth, Númenor will be his next target.

When Elrond dares to mention Míriel, Pharazôn finally speaks up, slamming his hand on the table and insisting, “Míriel is not our queen!” Then he laughs, further making things weird, and says the thought of Sauron makes him sick.

While continuing to stuff pieces of sea worm in his mouth, he says Míriel and her followers believe her claim to the throne is tied into being faithful to the old traditions. But “all that would crumble if she were ordered to rescind her claim and surrender,” he says.

Here’s what he wants: for Gil-galad to force her do that. In return, Númenor’s mighty armada will join the fight against Sauron.

This puts the Elves in quite the pickle. They really, really need those men and their ships for Middle-earth. But as Elrond says, “siding with Pharazôn against the faithful could be used to justify all manner of ill deeds.”

Gil-galad thinks Elrond—specifically, the fact that he’s a dead ringer for the island’s founder—is the key to bringing Númenor back together. He also thinks Elros would agree that the Faithful surrendering to Pharazôn, something Elrond could perhaps convince them to do, is preferable to the Elves surrendering to Sauron.

In Rhûn, we see Gandalf, in full hat-and-staff glory, dropping in on the Dark Wizard. He announces himself as “a servant of the Secret Fire” and reminds old Pallando the Blue they’re two of the five who were sent to save Middle-earth.

Everyone else in the throne room, aside from Rhûn’s in-house Nazgnagôl, wisely flees for the exits, sensing an imminent wizard brawl. “You are more than this,” Gandalf insists. He suggests they team up. Rather than marching to Mordor to join Sauron’s cause, the Dark Wizard’s followers can fight the Dark Lord’s army instead.

Rings Of Power Dark Wizard
© Prime Video

But the Dark Wizard is no longer interested in saving Middle-earth. With the Ring-servant urging him on, he tells Gandalf the Secret Fire showed him their destruction. The only thing they can do now is kneel to Sauron. The meeting ends with Gandalf being magically and violently flung around the room, with the Dark Wizard only pulling back because, as the Nazgnagôl insists, Sauron “wants him alive.”

Celeborn and Galadriel have found a hiding place above the forest floor, where Celeborn presses her about what she’s not telling him. She changes the subject. He tells her he dreamed she became “the wisest of all Elves, the Lady of Lórien.” She will eventually get there, Tolkien readers know, but in the moment, Galadriel is weeping over how she had to push memories of Celeborn away. All she’ll say about her secret is, “He was all I had left, and so I had to find him and end him.”

They kiss, but there’s a lot left unsaid.

In Númenor, Elrond is admiring the statue of Elros when a cloaked figure speaks to him. It’s Isildur, still wallowing in grief, and they chat about the pain of losing a loved one who has sacrificed their life for a greater cause. Then, a startled Isildur realizes who he’s talking to.

In the forest, Galadriel has another one of her “I’m in bed with Sauron” nightmares, this time seeing him in place of Celeborn. She’s so startled she falls out of their hiding place, blowing their cover while knocking herself out. To save her, Celeborn drops down and tells the Orcs that he’s there alone.

Just then, Sauron himself strides up. When Celeborn assumes he’s being taken prisoner as a way to get to Galadriel—”You think she’ll come for me,” he nods—but Sauron corrects him: “She’ll come to you. She’ll come for me.”

Galadriel wakes up just as Sauron’s fell-beast is flying away. She can guess what happened.

Isildur brings Elrond to meet Míriel, and this time the face-touching is the opposite of creepy, as the blind queen brushes her hands across his features, including his ears, and immediately knows him. Her first thought is that Elrond is there to lead them into battle.

Speaking of battles, Gandalf is at that moment strapped to the top of an oliphaunt, being transported to Mordor in the most uncomfortable way possible.

As episode six begins, Galadriel is keeping herself hidden from Orcs and Wargs using Elven magic. They scatter unexpectedly, but then we see it’s because a Ring-servant has appeared. Lucky for Galadriel, it’s Theo, who opens with “Help me,” a big ask of someone who just saw him murdering Arondir.

Theo is anxious to remove his ring, but it very much does not want to leave his finger. He knows he doesn’t have much time left; soon he will be completely subsumed by its power. He tells Galadriel that “Sauron lied to me,” something she can relate to, so she pulls the offending jewel from his hand.

Once he’s free (free-ish) of the ring, he tells her Celeborn is alive. Sauron thinks he knows the secret of the Elven rings because he was practically cellmates with the last Elven-smith, so he’s going to try and force that info out of him. Galadriel immediately mounts up on a rescue mission, with Theo in tow.

In Mordor, as expected, another torture session is about to begin. Celeborn asks Sauron something we’d all like to know: “Why are you doing all of this? When all the rings are yours and all the world is remade to your perfect design, what good will it do?”

Sauron’s answer is, “It will bring me bliss.” The greatest joy he can imagine is “to feel the precise instant another being submits his or her will to yours.”

He’s got physical torture in mind for Celeborn, but he’s also enjoying tormenting him in other ways by talking about Galadriel.

Rings Of Power Elves Kiss
© Prime Video

“It was me she wanted,” he says. “And you, she forgot.” Celeborn points out that if Galadriel wanted to be with Sauron, she would be—and obviously, she’s not.

In Númenor, Elendil asks Kemen if Pharazôn’s army will attack the Faithful, even though the king knows they’re holding his son hostage. He says yes and adds, “If you really do believe in the Valar, you’d best start praying.”

Both sides stand at the ready—Pharazôn has considerably more soldiers—but neither will make a move without royal orders. At that very moment, Elrond is insisting to Míriel that “Pharazôn does not want war with you but with Sauron.”

That’s not really the impression we got, is it? He also says if the Faithful stand down, Pharazôn could offer them “much in return,” including the prospect of a united Númenor. Isildur doesn’t want their fight to end in surrender, and Míriel agrees she doesn’t want guys like Kemen and Belzegar in positions of power.

A similar scene is happening in the capitol, where Gil-galad urges Pharazôn to hold off his attack until they hear back from Elrond. If the king’s army strikes first, he says, “You will have proven to Sauron that Númenor is fragile.” Belzegar tries to interject, but Gil-Galad fully ignores him, putting his laser focus on the king. “There is greatness in you. I see it,” he says, appealing to Pharazôn’s ego and emphasizing that this is one king talking to another king. “Let us make Sauron see it too.”

Just then, a message arrives from Míriel, requesting a parley. Progress?

In Khazad-dûm, the newly ascended King Thráin has everyone tearing the caves apart looking for the rings. Even the song of the mountain isn’t revealing their hiding place, though Disa—the most gifted of all the Stone-singers—has naturally refused to participate.

Thráin pays a visit to his brother, who’s locked up in chains, and Durin says the reason their father chose him as his successor is because he knew Thráin would always prioritize his own interests over what’s best for Khazad-dûm. That checks out. But when Durin says neither he nor Disa will ever share where the rings are, Thráin pulls a Sauron and threatens their children.

When Disa realizes the kids are in danger, she agrees to sing. When she finishes, she declares that the rings are buried deep inside one of the mines. The king allows her to lead the miners, plus the pugnacious Lady Freyja, to find them.

We cut to another dim interior, but this time it’s Barad-dûr, where Sauron is proudly showing off one of his fantastic torture machines like it’s a new car. His not-so-appreciative audience is Celeborn, who will soon be experiencing its agonizing effects.

Speaking of agony, that’s precisely what Theo feels now that he’s been separated from the ring. “Like one of my limbs was sawed off, and the rest of me is screaming for it to be rejoined,” is how he describes the sensation to Galadriel.

They ride to the very patch of land where Galadriel and Celeborn once dreamed of making their home. While Theo claws back the urge to reclaim his ring, Galadriel sings a melancholy song—adding another musical performance to this episode, and also making good on Celeborn’s praise of her voice.

Her conversation with Theo here bookends the one they had in Rings of Power’s first season, where she also talked about Celeborn. She’s realized now that she spent all that time chasing after the evil that she thought took him, because doing that was easier than facing her loss. “And after awhile, it’s all you have left of ‘em,” Theo says, finishing her thought. He knows what that feels like too. Then he asks Galadriel to help him destroy his ring.

In Mordor, Celeborn is doing a frankly incredible job enduring Sauron’s squashing machine. We’re still not sure if he even knows anything about the Elven rings in the first place. Sure, he and the Elven-smith had long conversations over the years. But: “We’re Elves. We talked about trees and stars,” he insists.

In Númenor, Gil-galad rides to Míriel’s camp and lets her know Pharazôn will meet. Isildur is instantly, angrily suspicious. Elrond diffuses the situation by asking Isildur to show him Elros’ belongings that are being kept there. And he soothes the hot-tempered warrior, saying that working with Pharazôn isn’t negating all that the Faithful have sacrificed; it’ll be worth it if he agrees to protect them.

Meanwhile, Gil-galad reassures Míriel that she’s doing the right thing—and he gives her an incredible gift by restoring her sight. Pharazôn is startled by the revelation when he sees her, but he looks pleased that she’s been healed. Belzagar, on the other hand, puts it down to “elf sorcery!” and tries to call off the negotiations as Isildur reaches for his sword.

Míriel steps in and says she and Pharazôn must talk in private. Once they’re alone, she tells her cousin that she’ll stand down, leaving his army free to sail to Middle-earth. What’s more, her legions will join them. “One army. One Númenor. A force so mighty it could fell even the Lord of the Rings himself,” she says. If he does this, Pharazôn will be remembered as “the mortal man who saved Middle-earth.”

In return, she wants freedom for the Faithful.

The king is listening, but he doesn’t think that will be enough. To make both sides fall in line, they’ll need a bigger gesture. Something more than just a regular alliance. Instead, how about… a proposal?

In Mordor, Sauron has a proposal of his own. He’s starting to believe the Orcs who say if Celeborn knew anything, he would have talked by now. But Sauron would still like to hear his prize prisoner beg for mercy. In response, Celeborn spits blood in his face, and Sauron licks it off, saying, “Now we are one. Now we are joined. Now we can begin.”

In the depths of Khazad-dûm, Disa leads the miners toward the rings’ hiding place—or so she says. In fact, they’ve arrived outside of Durin’s cell, and the husband and wife easily overpower everyone. But Durin makes a mistake when he tells Disa that the rings are hidden in their home, because we see a still-conscious Lady Freyja has heard every word.

Rings Of Power Durin
© Prime Video

In Númenor, Isildur delivers the devastating news to Elendil. Not only have Míriel and Pharazôn formed a political alliance, they’re also getting married. Elendil, who has been pining for the queen for who knows how long, gallops off to try and stop her.

A ragged Celeborn has finally been allowed to collapse in a cell. He opens his eyes when he hears a commotion: a guard yelling and swords clanging. A freshly decapitated Orc head rolls into view. Then Galadriel appears. As she’s trying to get him up and out of the cell, he reassures her, “I never told.”

We just had Durin blabbing out of turn about where the Dwarven rings were hidden. Now we have Celeborn revealing he’s known the secret of the Elven rings all along. The key component, the thing that Sauron didn’t know about, was Galadriel’s dagger. It once belonged to her brother and was made of gold and silver from Valinor.

Thank goodness he didn’t share that with Sauron, right? They kiss. They kiss again. And then… oh, jeez, that’s not Galadriel. It’s Sauron in disguise. Noooo!

And Sauron just so happens to have something made of gold and silver from Valinor: Celebrimbor’s hammer. But there’s a slight problem. It was designed to be unbreakable. It can’t be melted, not even by dragon fire.

Celebrimbor’s ghost pops up to taunt Sauron and ask, “How will you harness enough heat? It does not exist, not outside of…” He trails off there, a worried look on his face. Sauron, alone again as the vision of Celebrimbor vanishes, faintly smiles. The camera zooms out and up and all but points a neon arrow toward the fires of Mount Doom.

The final two episodes of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power arrive November 25.

Want more io9 news? Check out the best movies and TV shows to stream this month and all the upcoming sci-fi, fantasy, and horror books that should be on your radar.

Share this story

Sign up for our newsletters

Subscribe and interact with our community, get up to date with our customised Newsletters and much more.