The Gadget: The Livescribe Pulse Digital Smartpen records your notes two ways: it creates digital copies of everything you write by hand while recording audio at the same time. It also goes one step further and links the two together, so you can quickly access audio by tapping parts of your notes. All of this is uploaded to your computer where the Livescribe software archives and makes your notes fully searchable. In addition, it offers features like a calculator, translator, and a paper piano that plays a mini piano you draw on paper.
The Price: $199
The Verdict: I like the Livescribe Pulse quite a bit. I think it performs as advertised and is relatively easy to use. That said, this doesn't offer anything enticing or groundbreaking for people who don't use a pen and paper on a regular basis. It's a product for the likes of students, journalists, or even doctors, who are constantly scribbling things down with a pen. Here's a quick rundown of the pros and cons of the Pulse.
As a quick refresh, the Livescribe Pulse uses special dotted paper for spatial recognition to digitally replicate the notes. In one regard, this is good, because it doesn't require any secondary hardware. On the other hand, you cant just use any old piece of paper to make this thing fully functional. each sheet of paper has controls on the bottom, allowing navigation of the pens menu system, recording controls, bookmarking, playback controls, and speaker volume.
The note-taking/digital recording/replay function works smoothly. You hit the record button on the paper before you begin to write, then as you jot down your handcrafted masterpiece, it simultaneously records the audio and keeps the two linked. When you stop recording, you can tap anywhere in the vicinity of your notes and it will playback the audio from that moment when you were writing. It's awesome.
These can also be uploaded into Livescribe's Desktop software, which archives your notes according to the notebook they were written in and the page it was on. Text with audio linked to it appears in green, and when clicked, plays back the audio. There is also a search engine with handwriting recognition that works exceptionally well. I laid some chicken scratch on the page and it picked every word up, save for one word I couldn't even recognize. It doesn't currently support OS X right now, but they say its in the works.
Many of the secondary functions are neat, but I don't know I would use any of them on a regular basis. The Paper Piano is novel. The written calculator seems semi-practical, when in the middle of note scribbling, but the printed material on the inside cover of notebooks just isn't that useful. There's another calculator, a visual keyboard (which isn't yet supported) and status buttons for time and date. Also strange is that the settings can only be adjusted by the interfaces printed on the inside covers of notebooks. There's no on-screen system for adjusting this using the cross-based navigation.
The highly touted translator is also missing (though promised in the future), replaced with a demo that translates 20 words into Arabic, Mandarin, Spanish or Swedish. And one issue I had with the written calculator and translator was that I tend to write without picking up my pen between letters, and it couldn't recognize what I was writing. They say cursive support will come, but I'm not sure it will fix the recognition for people with poor handwriting.
The build quality of the pen is good, with a metal exterior that doesn't feel too light or heavy in the hand. It has an OLED screen that brightly displays pertinent info, stereo microphone, a loud speaker, and a magnetic dock/data connector. However, it's closer in size to a magnetic marker than a pen, and you have to hold the pen relatively high so as not to block the sensor. This feels a little cumbersome in the hand, but you mostly get used to it. Mostly.
The Livescribe Pulse is an amazing piece of tech, and I enjoy using it, but has an admittedly limited appeal. I'd love to see more creative and functional uses implemented with future "apps," and a touch of refinement in the current interface. But this is recommended for anyone who takes a lot of notes. [Livescribe on Giz]









Comments
Have any of these products ever been successful? I remember SonyEricsson had one, then Logitech, and now this thing. And they were all made by Anoto, I'm surprised they are still in business...
Hi Adrian, I don't know if I've ever seen your posts before but...lefties FTW!
So it is basically just a glorified LeapFrog Fly pen?
@sisedi: he might not be a leftie
he might be right handed so held the camera in his right :P
@LoobyLoo352: wrong.
lefties FTW!
@sisedi:
@Adrian Covert:
The greater beings, us lefties are.
hail to the lefties
This penis looking hard to handle. And it has a piano feature? So it's like having a pianist in your hand!
I'm all about tech (obviously, I'm here on Gizmodo) but I just don't see the need to technify every little thing. Pens and pencils might be at their pinnacle. Post-it notes are another. Maybe paper clips are next.
It's funny that you mention the Leapfrog Fly pen. This pen is made by the guy who made the Leapfrog Fly pen. He left Leapfrog to form his own company . . . Livescribe.
@Sora57: Punny!
As a teacher, one use that I might find for this is an easy way to take notes for students. We are often asked to provide notes for students with handwriting/processing issues. This can be a photocopy of transparencies, a handout with fill-in the blank spots to help guide the notes, or perhaps notes from a SmartBoard document. Typing notes up is not always easy, especially when you use so many math symbols.
I use the pen to make my own notes ahead of time, then just print them off--might be a useful time-saver. Of course, I'd have to choose whether I wanted to spend $200 of my own money on this...
That you have to use their special paper sucks.....it's 20$ pr. notebook
20 cents a sheet!!
Lefties are fine, but you upside-down-pointing-the-pen-at-your-junk freaks need to be rounded up and put in camps.
I lost my pen, shit.........
@Silverstone78:
Incorrect. It is $20 for a pack of 4 100 sheet notebooks. That equates to about 5 cents a sheet.
In the future they are promising the ability to print your own paper although it is not currently available. When you factor in the cost of ink, wear and tear on your printer, and time required to print 100 double sided sheets of paper, I don't conside $5 a notebook too much for the extra features and abilities it provides.
Who the hell holds a pen like that??????
I saw them at the Los Angeles Times Festival of Books last week in the Far Siberia of booths. Two women were demonstrating them. Yes, they did all this post says. And they said that you could go to their website and download the PDF for the paper - which, as we know, has tiny grey dots at regular intervals for the pen to use for orientation.
I found it extremely bulky in my (right) hand. I was also not sure about how I liked the flow of the ink, which is a major consideration when buying a pen. Even more important than paper, are the refills single-source?
Conceptually clever. If I were a Popular Mechanics reader I'd be all over it.
show me the steampunk'd fountain pen version and I'm sold.
Looks a tad-bit on the fat side. The cumbersity is a huge negative. What good is it if I can't finish my notes in time because I had a...err..middle heavy writing apperatus (aka a 'pen') ?
The idea is pretty cool though.
[www.logitech.com]
Also known as-- the Logitech io digital pen... released in 2002 for $150. What is so special and new about this idea? The Logitech pen used the same system of micro-spotted "Digital" paper way back when... the only new thing on this is the display and the microphone.
@kevincognito87: You should read before you comment. This is vastly more complex of a device.
Should I get this thing? My boss refuses to learn to type and handwrites EVERYTHING, from short emails to long papers, and I have to type it all. Either he's gonna get murdered or I will quit, which I don't want to do. I've been reading up on these types of devices but they seem either unreliable or not practical with the special custom paper.
All I want is a pen or a tablet that can take hand writing and turn it into digital characters. DOES SOMETHING LIKE THAT EXIST???
Start a discussion:
Login with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.
Forgot your username or password? New User?