We aren't saying the unibody MacBook isn't a reasonable choice for top laptop. And Consumer Reports' reputation as the toughest in the business (they refuse to even run ads or accept free review units, for fear of coloring their reviews) is earned. But their history with tech products hasn't been all that hot (like when their top five list of phones included four running Windows Mobile), and this list is has some serious problems.
Kinja is in read-only mode. We are working to restore service.