Apple and Palm: The iTunes Syncing Fight Is Officially Dumb

Illustration for article titled Apple and Palm: The iTunes Syncing Fight Is Officially Dumb

OK Palm, it was cute the first time you cracked iTunes to sync with the Pre. And Apple, I guess I can understand why you'd want to keep control over your software. But really guys? Still? You look silly.


Even Palm, who used this feature as a symbol of their underdog status, repeatedly defied a notoriously litigious behemoth and just wanted to give their users an easy way to sync music? Yes. It's a clear stunt to garner sympathy as a scruffy up-and-comer, it's in defiance of published USB standards, and Apple is clearly never, ever going to stop patching this "bug." You've got bigger things to worry about.

And even Apple, who's just trying to maintain control over a proprietary media player, and who has every right to do so? Yes. To users, the updates look weirdly protective, and make the company seem dickish, which here, they kind of are.

It's like watching children locked in a yes/no argument over whether or not licorice tastes good, and both parties should just leave it. I don't say this because I prefer Palm users to be locked out of iTunes or something—it's just that that's where things stand right now, it's the status quo and devoting any more energy to this protracted fight would be a waste. Apple can ignore this, because it shouldn't matter to them, and Palm should tell Prefolk to sync with doubleTwist, because that works—now even with the Pixi—just fine. Thanks in advance! [PreCentral]



I said it a hundred times and I will have to say it again until the Palm people who read this article puts it in their heads:

Palm has no business to break their USB agreement and go after iTunes. Instead, they should have sent 1-2 engineers at the [] team in downtown San Francisco to finish up that app. Not only they would help themselves this way, the right way, but they could even work with Google and other companies to foot the bill for that project. I mean, I am sure Android needs an iTunes-wannabe too, it's not just Palm that needs it, right?

In other words, get an app that's 80% there, and finish it up, and you don't need iTunes anymore. With the Amazon addon/plugin for Songbird, you won't even need the iTunes Store either!

I disagree with the article about using doubleTwist, since that's not open source, and it's not 100% legal either (AFAIK). It would be a mistake to go with that solution instead of an OPEN solution like Songbird is, that has more features and abilities to grow than doubleTwist, and a solution that would help other platforms too.

Instead, we get a cat and mouse game, which is ridiculous, and it only empowers Apple, not Palm.