The Future Is Here
We may earn a commission from links on this page

Apple Takes Developers Hostage in War on Adobe

We may earn a commission from links on this page.

We all know that you can't run Flash on Apple's mobile devices. But now Apple is trying to make it impossible to develop for iPhones in any other development environment but Apple's own. Oh boy.

There's one primary target this interferes with: Adobe, whose upcoming Packager for iPhone in CS5 lets you develop applications in Flash (or specifically, ActionScript 3, Flash's native scripting language) and then cross-compile them so that they work in both a browser's Flash plugin and as a standalone iPhone application.


The thinking goes like this: While applications written this way might not have the performance of applications written in Objective-C, the iPhone's native development language, they'd be good enough—and they'd allow developers who already know ActionScript to avoid having to learn a new language. (At least in theory. The game above, "THAT ROACH GAME", was made with Flash. One reviewer noted "The animation and fades must be computed with a hand calculator. The developer should consider some night classes.")

In iPhone OS4's licensing agreement, however, it appears that Apple is specifically proscribing languages for iPhone app creation.


How would Apple ever know what language was originally used if the end result is Objective-C (or C or C++)? From speaking to a Flash developer who may abandon an iPad application he has already been working on in ActionScript, most of the cross-compilers* use a set of unified libraries that are easy to recognize, even after the being compiled into iPhone apps.

In short, Apple is forcing a huge number of developers to change their development environment of choice simply to encourage them to move away from a competitor's platform. It is unclear if apps already on the App Store that have been developed using these tools will be banned.

Hello, FTC? Apple just passed Go. ** []

* This changed agreement affects more than just Flash developers, although it is my opinion that it is only Adobe with which Apple is concerned strategically.


** Okay, this isn't an antitrust issue, per se. But it's certainly unfair.

Update: I took out "illegal" in the lede, because that's overstating it. The DMCA does shore up some of the approach vectors from Apple's competitors here, but it's as @fraying pointed out in the comments below, it's not illegal per se to violate a license agreement.


Update 2: Gruber has posted a related consideration, "Why Apple Changed Section 3.3.1".