Detective Pikachu's Creative Team Considered Danny DeVito to Star (aka We Could Have Had It All)

A very sad Pikachu.
A very sad Pikachu.
Image: Warner Bros.

Those of us who’ve been fans of Detective Pikachu since his video game days know that even though Ryan Reynolds is voicing the character in Warner Bros.’ upcoming film adaptation, the assumption was that the electrical crime sleuth was meant to be played by one Danny DeVito. Apparently, the film’s production team understood this as well.


In an interview with Game Informer, Detective Pikachu producer Cale Boyter explained that very early on in the film’s production process, the studio was aware of the public’s desire to see DeVito portray the world-weary Pikachu and even went so far as to cut together a reel with the film’s take on the character spliced together with lines from DeVito’s performances in other things. Boyter explained:

We definitely thought about it and how it might inform the spirit of it. Danny is incredible by the way. I am a huge fan of Danny DeVito.

It was really very funny, so I couldn’t speak to all the reasons why it wasn’t Danny DeVito cast. I love Danny and some point maybe after the movie comes about, we can share those early tests. It’s absolutely hilarious.

I can’t give away too much, but in terms of where the story goes and how it evolves, we had to sort of look at everything, including what fans weren’t seeing yet to make the decision. But that spirit of Danny DeVito, I promise you, is still inside of Pikachu.

While Reynolds is almost certain to handle the role perfectly well, there’s no way you won’t ask yourself “what would Detective Pikachu be like if this adorable monster had the voice of a diminutive 74-year-old man known for playing people with anger issues?” when Detective Pikachu hits theaters May 10.

For more, make sure you’re following us on our new Instagram @io9dotcom.

Charles Pulliam-Moore is an NYC-based culture critic whose work centers on fandom, pop culture, politics, race, and sexuality. He still thinks Cyclops made a few valid points.



I missed this. Why exactly was everyone expecting/hoping for DeVito? Did he say in the past he wanted to do it? Has he voiced the character before?