The carbon dioxide doesn't simply pass through the drink without a trace. When CO2 mixes with H2O it creates a bit of H2CO3, otherwise known as carbonic acid. This is the exact same thing that happens when you carbonate water with your SodaStream, and it's in any carbonated anything you buy. It's not dangerous in those concentrations, but it will make your drink a little more acidic (as demonstrated in the video above), and that will affect the flavor.

Advertisement

Have you ever tasted carbonated water after it's gone flat? It tastes a little more sour, doesn't it? That's the carbonic acid at work. And, as we learned when we were testing a cocktail carbonator, you have to compensate for that sourness, or your drink will be pretty foul. A Dry Manhattan, for example, just doesn't work. You need to add more sweet vermouth to balance out the tartness.

Advertisement

In other words, you'll want to taste and adjust your recipes as you go. That said, here are two drinks that work extraordinarily well with dry ice (and look good for Halloween, too).

Advertisement

The Green Beast

Oh man this stuff is delicious. We've used the Green Beast before when we were making boozy popsicles. It's a punch, so you can make a ton of it all at once pre-party, and then dole it out a cup at a time, adding a cube of dry ice per glass. The greenish hue with the fog on top makes it look like you're drinking nuclear waste, but you won't believe how good and refreshing it is.

Advertisement

Ingredients:

Mix all of the liquid ingredients in a punch bowl (or cooler, or what have you), and that's about it. Drop a couple fresh, thin cucumber slices into each cup before you serve it and add the dry ice. Don't be lazy and buy lime juice, though. Take the time and juice them fresh. It'll be worth it. This drink is always a massive hit.

Advertisement

The (Spooky) Negroni

Okay, fine, it's really just a Negroni, but it's perfect for the dry ice treatment. This dark red cocktails looks like a cup of boiling blood, but it's a wonderfully complex drink.

Advertisement

Ingredients:

Don't let the fun red color fool you, this cocktail is strong. Normally, you would mix the gin, Campari, and vermouth in a mixing tin with ice, stir it (note: there is a special place in hell for bartenders who shake all-spirit cocktails like a Negroni. That goes double for people that shake Manhattans), then strain it into a glass. For the dry ice version, though, you need to make a little adjustment.

Advertisement

Any real cocktail contains a little water. With the Negroni, it's usually achieved through dilution as the ice melts while you're stirring it. For the (Spooky) Negroni, you don't want to add any regular ice because the dry ice will make the drink plenty cold. This is why we recommend adding a little water, which will open the drink up and allow you to taste each of the components more distinctly. Somewhere between a quarter-part to a half-part should do. Start with a little and add a little more until you hit the sweet spot. This is by no means mandatory, but know that without any water you've got an extremely potent drink on your hands.

The other adjustment is that normally you want to use a little less than a full part of sweet vermouth. But because dry ice imparts the aforementioned acidity, the extra sweetness of the full part (in the 1:1:1 ratio) actually creates a perfect balance. The dry ice even carbonates the drink, slightly, making it even more enjoyable.

Advertisement

Dry ice will, of course, work nicely with other drinks as well. These are just our two favorites. You should experiment with others (and let us know which do and don't work). Just remember, as a general rule, you'll want to go a little bit sweeter than usual and you'll want to add a little more water than usual. Also, we wouldn't recommend using it in cocktails that contain milk (like a White Russian) because the carbonic acid will almost certainly create some gross curdling (at worst) and will make large, messy, exploding bubbles (at best).

Advertisement

Congratulations! You are now armed with all the knowledge you should need to make creepily delicious dry ice cocktails. Please heed our safety warnings, then go forth, and rock your Halloween party. If you end up using this stuff, we hope you'll share photos and stories below. In the meantime, have a great Halloween, and see you next week for another Happy Hour.