Just What Are Those White Spots On Ceres?

NASA's Dawn spacecraft is edging closer and closer to the dwarf planet Ceres, producing the best ever photograph ever taken every time it sends data home. But the more we see, the more the mystery deepens. Just what are those freaking white spots?!


I'm serious: we don't know what they are. We saw the original white splotch, a regional brightening in albedo, all the way back in 2004 when the Hubble Space Telescope produced the most detailed photograph we had of Ceres for years. Now that Dawn has taken over the title of best photographer of the largest body in the asteroid belt, the mystery is just getting stranger. Instead of one spot, we're finding freckles.

Illustration for article titled Just What Are Those White Spots On Ceres?

The spots are areas of slightly increased reflectiveness, representing barely a 9% higher albedo than the surrounding surface. The resolution of the photographs are currently at 14 kilometers (8.5 miles) per pixel, so we don't yet have enough detail to resolve if these are pinprick spots, or brighter regions that are blurring into points through our fuzzy vision.

Dawn's latest images reveal a spattering of white spots. What are they?! Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/UCLA/MPS/DLR/IDA

So, what could it be? I'm sure countless astronomers have research projects hinged on what we see as Dawn slides into position in March, but for now we can make some semi-plausible guesses:

  • At its most basic, new is shiny while old is dull, so whatever these spots are, they're likely to be younger features than the surrounding terrain. An albedo around 0.12 isn't enough to make sense for clean ice, but space is filthy so even recently exposed doesn't need to be shiny-clean.
  • We've seen ice at the bottom of craters on the moon; the same could be happening on Ceres with every splot marking a dent in the dwarf planet.
  • Ice could have caught on prominence, the asteroid equivalent of snowy mountaintops with the lack of atmosphere and weather dictating an entirely different formation mechanism.
  • Ceres could have a rock core, an ice mantle, and a thin crust of debris and dust. Meteor impacts could burst through the crust, exposing ice below. (For more on this theory, tell NASA to fund Andy Rivkin's research.)
  • Neither of these ideas mesh with our concepts of the surface temperature and internal dynamics, but bright spots can be indicative of melt ponds or even cyrovolcanics. If so, we're going to be really, really surprised by how something so cold, so small, and so far away from something massive to gravitationally massage it can have that kind of thermodynamics.
  • On a similar theory, it could be some sort of icy geyser, although if it is, we'd be just as confused about how the thermodynamics of that little system are working.
  • Secret military bases à la Ender's Game, or an inspection sticker as hypothesized by XKCD.

All the best views we have of Ceres as of February 5, 2015. Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/UCLA/MPS/DLR/IDA


Do you have any ideas? Place your bets now on what we'll see as we keep getting closer!


Twirlip of the Mists

Could they be relatively recent impact craters?

Most of the images I've seen of these spots implied that they are very reflective, and consequently I heard a lot of people suggesting water ice. So it's good to read an actual estimate of the albedo! It's still as dark as asphalt, just a bit lighter than the surroundings....

I'm guessing they are recent impact craters revealing lighter subsurface material. Like you say Asteroids become darker and redder with age. I think the favoured hypothesis is that the weathering is caused by charged particles in the solar wind darkening the regolith. It seems to take place fairly rapidly, so most of the darkening occurs within 100,000 years, meaning these would have to be very recent impacts.

It would be fantastic observing opportunity because there's a lot of debate about the cause, speed, depths and so on of the surface weathering, and a recent impact event is exactly what people have been looking for.

I Am Not An Expert so I'm just speculating, based on very old and dusty planetary science lectures and what I've recently read about the Dawn images. The spots could be something else entirely. On reflection they are probably the strangely angled ruins of long-abandoned alien cities, built by a peculiar race that slithered out of the dark between the stars when the only life on Earth oozed and crawled mindlessly beneath the slimy seas.