The secret to success is to fail, fail, and fail again, but in different ways each time. SpaceX hasn’t stuck a barge landing yet, but this side-by-side video comparison of each attempt reassures us that it’s getting closer.

Despite successfully landing a rocket on solid ground, SpaceX is continuing to attempt barge landings to collect rockets that have too much velocity to make a full return trip. The first landing in January 2015 came in too fast and too hard after running out of hydraulic fluid. It slammed into the deck and exploded.

The second landing attempt coming in at an angle after delivering Dragon CSR-6 into orbit. Image credit: SpaceX

The next landing attempt was in April 2015. It was softer, but carried too much lateral motion and came in at an angle. It, too, slammed into the deck and exploded.


The third landing attempt coming in after delivering Jason-3 into orbit. Image credit: SpaceX

Yesterday’s landing attempt was the first attempt in the Pacific Ocean, and the first to stream live video from the barge deck (although it glitched out at the critical moment). The rocket touched down soft enough, and upright, but didn’t stay that way. One of the four legs didn’t latch properly, with Elon Musk suggesting the rocket may have been coated in ice “due to condensation from heavy fog at liftoff.” For the first time, the rocket broke into respectably large chunks after its topple, leaving more for the team to investigate.


Pieces of the third landing attempt being towed home. Image credit: SpaceX

Contact the author at or follow her at @MikaMcKinnon.