Build New Stories With These Games, Systems, and Engines

Captain America voice: So, you want to change tabletop systems post-Dungeons & Dragons OGL? I think I can help you out.

PublishedJanuary 27, 2023

We may earn a commission from links on this page.

Start Slideshow

Image for article titled Build New Stories With These Games, Systems, and Engines — Image: John Harper | Lumpley Games | Stockholm Kartell | Loot the Room | Jesse Ross

If you’re into tabletop games, you’ve probably heard a lot about Dungeons & Dragons lately. After io9 leaked the draft of D&D’s new Open Gaming License, the fandom immediately pushed back and forced Wizards of the Coast to retreat. But the OGL is only part of the story: attached to the OGL is a Systems Reference Document—the SRD. The SRD is what outlines and details the parts of the D&D IP that you can legally use by agreeing to the OGL.

D&D, however, isn’t the only game company to explicitly allow work to be made using rules, systems, and portions of the original game’s base framework. Independent designers and studios, as well as larger corporations, have published games and also issued default-use licenses (most commonly under the Creative Commons) in order to encourage third-party participation.

I’ve attempted to gather some of my favorite games that explicitly allow and welcome third-party content. Some of them have SRDs, some just have a CC license, but all of them have spawned numerous games based on a single system. What this means is that you can learn one game’s set of overarching rules and play many different, more specific games that riff on the basics of the system. Or, if you’re feeling bold, get inspired to write a game yourself!

Previous Slide

Next Slide

2 / 10

The Wretched (Wretched and Alone)

A single-person journaling game, The Wretched by Chris Bisette/Loot the Room games is a great entry into solo TTRPGs. Using a deck of cards and a “tumbling block tower,” the system setup creates a tense and immediate scene with a sense of personal investment that puts you fully in the moment, even as you play alone. It also has a system reference document! You can take a look at the Wretched & Alone SRD and then explore the plethora of W&A games.

The Wretched, Chris Bisette/Loot the Room
Clever Girl, Matthew Gravelyn
By the Sounding Sea, Ella Martinez
Final Girl, Ex Stasis Games
Murder!, Catscratcher Studios
And plenty more...

Previous Slide

Next Slide

3 / 10

MÖRK BORG

A simple, effective, combat-focused game, MÖRK BORG’s power comes in the compete commitment to the bit. It’s a clean, efficient system that allows for high-stakes, high-reward combat. MB also has a huge amount of resources, digital tools, and third-party adventures and content making it accessible to a wide audience. You can read through its third party license here.

MÖRK BORG, designed by Pelle Nilsson (Ockult Örtmästare Games) and Johan Nohr (Stockholm Kartell)
CY_BORG, Christian Sahlén and Johan Nohr of Stockholm Kartell
PIRATE BORG, Limithron
DUKK BÖRG, Gem Room Games
Vast Grimm, Infinite Black
Soul Burner, World Champ Game Co
Fisk Borg, Richard Kelly/Kumada
ORC BORG, Rowan, Rook and Decard

Previous Slide

Next Slide

4 / 10

Belonging Outside Belonging (No Dice, No Masters)

Avery Alder, who also designed The Quiet Year, established the token-based Belonging Outside Belonging system. Using narratives to reward people at your table, the system emphasizes interpersonal connections and relationships over anything else. Master-less (or Game Master-optional), the system allows for an intense collaboration among players, and allows for no-prep games where conflicts emerge and resolve naturally as tokens are given and spent in order to dictate narrative control within any given situation.

Dream Apart, Ben Rosenbaum
Dream Askew, Avery Alder
Wanderhome, Jay Dragon/Possum Creek Games
Thursday, Eli Seitz
Balikbayan, Rae Nedjadi
Flotsam, Joshua Fox
Volley Boys, Kevin Nguyen

Previous Slide

Next Slide

5 / 10

Cypher System

The Cypher System is one of those catch-all systems that features just the right balance of “roll lots of dice” crunchiness and the ability to improv narrative beats at the table. It’s got tiered skill set for a modular chargen, which means you can use whichever best suits your character and work your way through improvement. It asks players to roll a D20 to perform a difficulty check for most anything, and combat damage is universally assigned as either light, medium, or heavy. The Cypher System also has an open license.

The Cypher System (core ruleset), Monte Cook Games
Numenera, Monte Cook Games
Mortal Fantasy, Ganza Gaming
Mecha vs Kaiju, Jonathan Wright
We Are All Mad Here, Monte Cook Games

Previous Slide

Next Slide

6 / 10

Trophy: Dark

A play to lose game, Trophy: Dark by Jesse Ross, published by the Gauntlet and Hedgemaze Press, is an incredibly lightweight system built for short, quick, TPK campaigns. The beauty of Trophy: Dark is that each third-party adventure (called an incursion) is its own self-contained game. Play is dark and evocative, and each incursion has a built-in support system for GM’s based on tables at the core of the game design. Trophy can be distilled into a contained horror system that allows for a lot of narrative leeway and low-level fantasy. The SRD is here.

Trophy: Dark, Jesse Ross
Sunken, Clear Keep
Penumbra, Jordan Boschman
Devil, Aim For Me, Michael Van Vleet
The Paperflesh Advent, Speak the Sky Games

(Fun fact! My first foray into game writing was built on the Trophy: Dark system!)

Previous Slide

Next Slide

7 / 10

Mothership (Panic Engine)

Mothership, the sci-fi/horror game, burst onto the scene a few years ago and has inspired tons of designers to try their hand at a D100 system. It uses the Panic Engine, and the chargen ensures that there’s paths to min/max your build. It’s lightweight and powerful, and forces characters into tough decisions immediately. Tuesday Knight Games also sells third-party content on its site.

Mothership, Tuesday Knight Games
Thousand Empty Light, Alfred Valley
Dissident Whispers, Whisper Collective
Desert Moon of Karth, Joel Hines
Knights of Lazarus, Spicy Tuna
Black Pyramid, Skull Dixon

Previous Slide

Next Slide

8 / 10

Blades in the Dark (Forged in the Dark)

Blades in the Dark is one of those games that I feel like everyone should learn just because it’s such a masterclass on game design. Perfectly suited to heists, intrigue, and faction play, the dice pool system makes every roll feel like a gamble. With hugely popular third-party market based around its Forged in the Dark license, there is no end to the hijinks you and your crew can get up to. With customizable playbooks and an ingenious flashback mechanic, this low-prep heist system is an excellent one to add to your arsenal.

Blades in the Dark, John Harper
Brinkwood: The Blood of Tyrants, Far Horizons Co-Op
Band of Blades, Off Guard Games
Scum and Villainy, Off Guard Games
Court of Blades, A Couple of Drakes

Previous Slide

Next Slide

9 / 10

Apocalypse World (Powered by the Apocalypse)

Based on the system engineered for Apocalypse World by D. Vincent Baker and Meguey Baker, Powered by the Apocalypse systems are typically a narrative-focused, high-stakes adventure system that easily allows for genre emulation and evocative, character-driven storytelling. It has no SRD (although the Bakers are working on one), but it does have an open use policy, detailed on their site. Because of this, there is no set definition of a PbtA game, as the Bakers have stated that “[Powered by the Apocalypse] signifies ONLY that the game was inspired by Apocalypse World in a way that the designer considers significant, and that it follows our policy [with regard to] others’ use of our creative work.”

Most PbtA games do have some familiar elements: archetypal chargen using playbooks, “moves” rather than skill checks, an item system that utilizes tags, and combat that goes for a vibe check more than a protracted, hours-long whittling down of a BBEG’s hit points. This system typically uses 2D6 and ensures that every single roll will have narrative consequences. With a lightweight framework and the possibility of high-impact narratives PbtA games are incredibly popular and learning this system opens the door to hundreds of other games. One of my personal favorite systems, I will always default to a PbtA game when offered a choice of games.

Monster of the Week, Michael Sands
Thirsty Sword Lesbians, April Kit Walsh
Monsterhearts, Avery Alder
Interstitial: Our Hearts Intertwined, Linksmith Games
The Sprawl, Hamish Cameron

Additionally, the RPG company Magpie Games almost exclusively uses the PbtA system, and it has produced work like Masks, Urban Shadows, Pasion de las Pasiones, Cartel, Bluebeard’s Bride, and more—all written by different authors who work with Magpie as a publisher/producer.

I’ve left out quite a few notable systems, and I know it! However, I hope to update this slideshow to feature as many systems and SRDs as possible, including favorites like Lasers & Feelings, Cairn, Troika, and many, many more! That said—anyone who comes into the comments to say GURPS or THAC0 will be sprayed with a water bottle.

Want more io9 news? Check out when to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s next for the DC Universe on film and TV, and everything you need to know about the future of Doctor Who.

10 / 10

Build New Stories With These Games, Systems, and Engines

*Captain America voice:* So, you want to change tabletop systems post-Dungeons & Dragons OGL? I think I can help you out.

The Wretched (Wretched and Alone)

The Wretched (Wretched and Alone)

MÖRK BORG

MÖRK BORG

Belonging Outside Belonging (No Dice, No Masters)

Belonging Outside Belonging (No Dice, No Masters)

Cypher System

Cypher System

Trophy: Dark

Trophy: Dark

Mothership (Panic Engine)

Mothership (Panic Engine)

Blades in the Dark (Forged in the Dark)

Blades in the Dark (Forged in the Dark)

Apocalypse World (Powered by the Apocalypse)

Apocalypse World (Powered by the Apocalypse)

Captain America voice: So, you want to change tabletop systems post-Dungeons & Dragons OGL? I think I can help you out.