Twitter, a service that admits it sucks at dealing with trolls, just announced a new tool for reporting harassment to the police. It looks like a good step at first glance—if you ignore the fact that it's a responsibility dodging, spineless fix that's highly unlikely to help anyone being harassed or threatened Twitter. This is a PR stunt, not a solution.
The company blog post announcing the new tool says it's "Making it easier to report threats to law enforcement." Which is great! Except it really doesn't.
The new tool means that if you're getting harassed on Twitter, you can get a summary of your complaint emailed to you. That's it. That's the whole service offered.
All the tool does is save people the few seconds it takes to screenshot complaints to send to police. The user is still responsible for forwarding that email to the appropriate authorities. Twitter won't send it along for you or take any steps to make sure law enforcement prioritize or pay attention to the complaint in any way. And if those authorities do decide to look into the threat, they still have to go through the usual channels to receive additional information about the harasser from Twitter.
I asked Twitter whether it was planning to work with law enforcement to bulk up this tool, and whether it planned on contacting law enforcement to alert them to particularly aggressive threats directly. "We don't have anything to share beyond the content in the blog post. Our guidelines for law enforcement (linked in the blog post) explain what private user information Twitter has, and how authorities can request it," a spokesperson told me.
Now, Twitter is in a tough spot about harassment. If someone reports an abuser and Twitter suspends them, they can just make a new account and start spewing hate again. That renders Twitter's harassment reporting tool essentially useless. And because it's easy to sign up for Twitter using fake or burner info, it's not like there's an easy way for the service to trace abusive accounts.
If Twitter takes more stringent measures like restricting how many accounts can sign up per IP address, blocking abusive IP addresses, or requiring real-name information for registration, that will neuter Twitter's importance as a tool for political dissent and pseudonymous speech. It's a trade-off that Twitter is understandably reluctant to make: It would fundamentally change the value of the service.
At the same time, if Twitter continues to make flaccid gestures like this, its harassment and troll problems will undoubtedly continue.
There is middle ground to be explored between castrating Twitter's capabilities as a free speech machine and introducing measures that actually counter abuse. Twitter could, for instance, employ proactive abuse moderators. These moderators could cooperate with appropriate law enforcement agencies and help people getting threatened make contact with police, not by giving them a copy of their complaint but by actually setting up contact. These abuse moderators could keep tabs on IP addresses known to spawn more than one abusive account.
This isn't just Twitter's problem. Most, if not all, major law enforcement agencies are horrible at taking online threats seriously. I recognize that this won't be as easy as Twitter simply deciding one day that it's going to help people getting abused receive attention from police.
But Twitter should be actively, publicly attempting to engage law enforcement about the severity of these threats, and it should not pat itself on the back for continuing to put all the onus on the person getting abused to seek out help.
Illustration by Tara Jacoby
Contact the author at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Public PGP key
PGP fingerprint: FF8F 0D7A AB19 6D71 C967 9576 8C12 9478 EE07 10C