But since that time, it's blown up into an incredibly popular meme, morphing into hundreds of creepy incarnations, including stories, more terrifying Photoshops, and even videogames. The question is, where did that first image come from? /x/, a community devoted to urban legends and the supernatural, wanted to find out. There are a lot of theories, but one seems the most plausible — and chilling.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Writes Alfonso:

In the fall of 2008, a girl named Katy Robinson allegedly posted a grainy photo of herself taken in a closet on 4chan's random imageboard, /b/. As the story goes, the girl was bullied relentlessly for her weight and later committed suicide.

Advertisement

Redditor ninetofivehero claimed Katy's original photo was Photoshopped to create what is now considered the Jeff the Killer photo.

"In one less photoshopped version of the Jeff picture, a mole is clearly visible that's also visible in the picture of Katy," ninetofivehero wrote on Reddit. "It looks in a different position on the face, but that would be a result of the new mouth Photoshopped on to help create Jeff."

Advertisement

This is the early Photoshopped photo, which is more recognizably Katy.

As you can see, the closet scene with the shirt sleeves is retained in the final Jeff the Killer image at the top of this post, as is Katy's haircut. It does seem plausible that Katy's picture, further altered, became Jeff the Killer. This is therefore an internet legend build on another internet legend, about a teenager who killed herself after being made fun of on /b/.

Advertisement

There is a kind of "haunted Photoshop" aspect to the tale as well, with some people claiming that the final version of the Jeff the Killer face isn't Katy, but is made up of a corpse's eyes and a dog's broken jaw.

So we may have the origin of the Jeff the Killer legend — but we still aren't sure about the Katy suicide legend. Once we get to the bottom of that, we may indeed understand the true origin of this seriously creepy meme.

Advertisement

Read more on The Daily Dot