YouTuber Count Dankula Convicted of Hate Crime for Video of Pug Making a 'Nazi Salute'

Image for article titled YouTuber Count Dankula Convicted of Hate Crime for Video of Pug Making a 'Nazi Salute'
Screenshot: Count Dankula (YouTube)

A Scottish YouTube comedian, Mark Meechan, was found guilty of a hate crime on Tuesday for posting a video of himself training his girlfriend’s pug, Buddha, to mimic a Nazi and respond to commands the court ruled anti-Semitic.


In the video from April 2016, Buddha is shown watching Adolph Hitler speaking at a rally at the 1936 Olympic Games in Berlin, raising its paw at the command of “Sieg Heil,” and becoming alert every time Meechan says “gas the Jews”—a trick Meechan demonstrates a dozen times.

Meechan, whose YouTube account name is Count Dankula, praises Buddha in the video by saying, “Who’s a good wee Nazi!”

At the end of the video—which is still up on YouTube in restricted mode and has been viewed more than 3 million times—Meechan says he’s not a racist, he just wanted to piss off his girlfriend.

He provided the same explanation in court, according to BBC.

Ephraim Borowski, head director of the Scottish Council of Jewish Communities, spoke at the trial, according to The Times. He told the court that his family members died in the Holocaust and he could not see how it could be made into a joke.

Ross Brown, defending Meechan, said Meechan did not expect the video to go viral and insisted Meechan’s girlfriend saw it as an example of his humor.

But Sheriff Derek O’Carroll, who was judging the trial, found Meechan guilty of being grossly offensive, a violation of the UK’s Communications Act.


O’Carroll said that he did not believe the sole purpose of the video was to pester his partner, since he had left it on his page where it could continue to bring traffic to other videos. “This court has taken the freedom of expression into consideration,” O’Carroll said. “But the right to freedom of expression also comes with responsibility.”

[BBC, The Times.]




People in the United States don’t often realize that we’re the only country that expressly permits free speech, legally.

Even when used for vile shit like this, it’s a blessing to have- something not to be taken lightly. Criminal punishment for this is absurd, as is merely taking freedom of expression “into consideration” and punishing someone criminally for their speech.

I’m not condoning what he said, just his right to say it. Social punishment is acceptable here, not criminal.