In 1924, the skull of a 3-year-old early human emerged in Taung, South Africa. It was the first solid proof that humans originated in Africa, confirming a fundamental aspect of human evolution. Now, the so-called “Taung Child” is at it again, shaking up what we know about the early human lineage.
In a study published earlier this month in the journal npj Palaeoecosystems, researchers compared features of other early human fossils to the Taung Child. The differences they found suggest that natural climate change turned early human evolution into a chaotic web of lineages, and their research emphasizes that the human family tree in southern Africa was significantly more complicated than researchers thought.
The Taung Child was an Australopithecus africanus, a long-bygone primate species that lived in modern-day South Africa from around 3.3 to 2.1 million years ago. They had a mix of human and ape features and may have been a direct ancestor of the Homo genus, which of course includes us modern humans, Homo sapiens. There’s just one problem. In the entire known fossil record, the Taung Child is the only unequivocal A. africanus specimen.
That’s because after its discovery, experts didn’t establish determinative criteria to categorize later findings. And so paleontologists basically proceeded based on vibes, tentatively classifying similar fossils to the Taung Child as A. africanus.
“For over 100 years, we assumed the Taung Child was just one of many similar fossils from the era,” Gabriele Macho, lead author of the study and a bioarchaeologist at the Free University of Brussels, said in a statement. “Our findings turn that on its head. The human family tree wasn’t a neat, straight trunk—it was a chaotic, tangled bush driven by climate shifts.”
Macho and her colleagues redated the Taung Child fossil to between 2.96 and 3.03 million years old. By investigating tooth structure and brain and tooth development during growth, they also found that a number of adult fossils historically considered to be Australopithecus africanus actually don’t align with the iconic fossil’s developmental trajectory.
Instead, important contrasts in brain development indicate that multiple hominin species in the Sterkfontein region (northeast of Taung) lived at the same time or consecutively. So why was this part of the human tree so bushy? The team thinks natural climate change drove these evolutionary variations.
Millions of years ago, southern Africa’s landscape was shaped by wet and dry climate cycles. As hominins’ habitats consequently expanded and contracted, isolated populations diverged, interbred, and adapted to new threats. The Sterkfontein region was a dynamic area where species met and hybridized again and again over millennia. The image in my head is of a sort of climate-driven evolutionary accordion spewing out new species.
When the Taung Child was alive and kicking, South Africa was a much wetter, forested environment than it is today, according to fossilized pollen. More broadly, the team’s proposed dynamic challenges neater linear evolutionary models, much to the presumed disgruntledness of the Type A paleontologists out there.