An Indigenous Group Famous for Its Heart Health Started Using Cooking Oil—and Began Gaining Weight

A Tsimané  man carrying bananas.
A Tsimané man carrying bananas.
Photo: AP

A group of indigenous people in Bolivia are famous for their healthy hearts, but a new study shows that they are experiencing higher rates of obesity after the introduction of processed cooking oils to their diet.

Advertisement

The Tsimané are an indigenous group based in the South American country of Bolivia. Like several other communities in the world, the Tsimané sustain themselves primarily through the farming of small crops as well as foraging and hunting. This vanishingly rare method of survival has made them a keen area of interest for scientists, from anthropologists to biologists.

Among the fascinating discoveries made about the Tsimané and similar groups involves their hearts. While they are more likely to die young, often due to infectious disease, they famously almost never develop heart disease. And compared to every other group of people living in the industrialized world, their cardiovascular system is pristine. What makes this comparison all the more astonishing that their average level of physical activity is not that much higher than that of the average American, and they actually eat more daily calories.

Advertisement

Like so many foraging societies in the past, however, the Tsimané are increasingly coming into contact with the rest of the world. Some of this exposure is forced, as mining and lumber companies have illegally violated their land rights, devastated their environment, and pressured them to move closer to cities and urban settlements. But their overall population is also growing, putting a strain on their resources. As a result, the Tsimané are starting to take jobs to earn wages and send their children to school.

In a paper published this June in Obesity, researchers studying the Tsimané say this shift is already starting to change their bodies. They looked at eight years of data on Tsimané adults over the age of 20, dating back to 2002, when the Tsimane Health and Life History Project first began. This data not only included measurements of their heart health and body mass index, but diaries of their eating habits; all told, more than 300 Tsimané were included in the study.

In 2002, they found, 22.6 percent of Tsimané women were considered overweight (a BMI between 25 to 30), while 2.4 percent were obese (a BMI over 30). But by 2010, 28.8 percent were overweight and 8.9 percent were obese. Tsimané men, who are typically more active than the women, experienced similar but smaller increases in BMI.

Advertisement

These rates are still far below those seen in other groups of people. In the U.S., for instance, over two-thirds of adults are overweight, and nearly half are obese. And as recently as 2015, according to a 2017 study, the Tsimané still have very low rates of cardiovascular disease.

But some of the current findings suggest their heart health is likely changing for the worse, and it’s not a great sign for people living elsewhere in the world. Even though their average calorie intake didn’t change much, the increased use of cooking oil was linked to higher BMI among Tsimané women. By 2010, nearly a third of households reported using cooking oil bought from stores, and it was the only food clearly linked to increased BMI, even as other foods like sugar or refined grains were also more commonly eaten.

Advertisement

“We found that even small increases in market-based foods that are high in calories even in small servings, contributed to fat gain in this active, subsistence-based population,” study author Alan Schultz, an anthropologist at Baylor University, said in a statement released by the university. “Cooking oil adds so much flavor—we use it for a reason—but at 120 calories and 14 fat grams per tablespoon, few foods can so easily alter your diet.”

Diet alone isn’t the only thing poised to dramatically change for the Tsimané in the years to come. And certainly some aspects of modernization, such as more available health care for children, will benefit them. But given the increasingly grim research suggesting how diets rich in processed foods harm our bodies, the renowned heart health of the Tsimané might be at risk.

Advertisement

Science writer at Gizmodo and pug aficionado elsewhere

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

What makes this comparison all the more astonishing that their average level of physical activity is not that much higher than that of the average American, and they actually eat more daily calories.

This is a lie. As your own linked article notes, they walk more than three times as much per day as the average American. From the linked article:

Several years ago, Gurven had the Tsimané wear heart rate monitors and step counters: The average Tsimané adult walked 17,000 steps a day. A 2010 report in Medicine and Science In Sports and Exercise found that the Average American takes just about 5,117 steps per day.

Almost certainly this, coupled with the fact that their immune system is probably much more active means they’re likely burning tons more calories than the average American. Cooking oil does have some calories, but we burn off most of it when we cook unless you’re deep frying. One thing stood out to me about the release:

While sugar intake increased by about 13 percent annually, neither it nor refined grains had detectable associations with changes in body fat.

I’m really curious to know how they determined that.  Sugar has been behind the increase in obesity in the US more than any other factor, pointing to cooking oil is suspect to say the least.