Black Friday Is Almost Here!
The Inventory team is rounding up deals you don’t want to miss, now through Cyber Monday. Click here to browse!

Best Buy Sells Egregiously Crappy, 9-Year-Old Hard Drive As New, Then Refuses Refund

Illustration for article titled Best Buy Sells Egregiously Crappy, 9-Year-Old Hard Drive As New, Then Refuses Refund

Best Buy customer Jon purchased a brand-new Western Digital hard drive for store pickup, but when he opened the (sealed) package at home, he found a 30GB, near-decade-old product instead. Best Buy's reaction? "Tough luck."


Instead of the nice, new Western Digital VelociRaptor he ordered, Jon received an ancient 30GB Quantum Fireball, a product discontinued by Maxtor nine years ago. Best Buy told Jon that WD must have packaged the oddball drive, and he should take it up with them. He stayed in the store and was shunted back and forth between Western Digital's and Best Buy's customer service lines, with nobody willing to refund his $225. Said Jon:

Finally, I spoke to a third-level Customer Service rep, who told me nothing could be done since 'it is Western Digital's responsibility', however the best he could do would be to offer me a gift card for half the value of the drive (the total purchase price was $225). I told him this was unacceptable, and that all I wanted was either the actual drive I had (tried) to purchase, or a refund so I could buy it elsewhere. He told me that was 'not going to happen'. I told him that Best Buy was, in effect, stealing my money, to which he replied 'yep, that's basically right'. I told "John" that I would be filing a police report and pursuing help from my credit card company, and left.


He's currently working through his credit card company to get his money back, but it's looking like he might have to take Best Buy to small claims court (!).

Best Buy has been known in the past to package clearly used, bizarre items as new, but this is taking it to a whole new level of abhorrent customer service. [Consumerist]

Share This Story

Get our newsletter


But wait, it sounds like it's Western Digital's fault. I understand why Best Buy would refuse, but WD is to blame so they should replace the drive.