On Second Thought, Be Evil

Illustration for article titled On Second Thought, Be Evil
Photo: AP

Google publicly supported tens of thousands of its employees walking out in November to protest working conditions, but weeks later the company pushed the National Labor Relations Board to roll back a legal protection organizers relied on, Bloomberg reports.


Documents obtained by Bloomberg via a Freedom of Information Act request reveal that Alphabet lawyers argued the NLRB should roll back Obama-era rules that allow workers to use company email addresses to organize—as they did in setting up last year’s mass walkout.

The primary motivation for this gambit had nothing at all to do with the walkout, but instead a complaint filed by a regional NLRB director in 2015. In a statement to Bloomberg, a Google spokesperson contended that the challenge to the Obama precedent was “one of many possible” strategies being employed in its defense, claiming, “We’re not lobbying for changes to any rules.”


Still, organizers within the company reportedly view this tactic as Alphabet talking out of both sides of its mouth: CEO Sundar Pichai told staffers ahead of the walkout that the company was “taking in all their feedback so we can turn these ideas into action,” but its challenge to NLRB rules could have undermined the ability for workers to organize future actions. Colin McMillen, an exiting Googler who spoke to Bloomberg, said the challenge “demonstrates that Google leadership is not operating in good faith.”

The optics and timing are terrible for Google, a company that has increasingly been viewed as shirking its (former) informal motto “don’t be evil,” whether through generous payouts to executives known to engage in sexually inappropriate behavior, or attempts to quietly cozy up to the Pentagon. That Alphabet would try a legal strategy such as this at all is more evidence that, no matter how egalitarian a corporation may try to be, it’s first and only real allegiance is to itself and its shareholders, not its workers.

A Google spokesperson provided the following statement to Gizmodo:

Google is one of the most open workplaces in the world. Employees have multiple internal forums to express their views, raise concerns and connect, including thousands of internal communities and tens of thousands of email groups. We’re not lobbying for changes to any rules. This was a legal defense that we included as one of many possible defenses in the response to a charge. This case is without merit and we are defending the claim vigorously.


Senior reporter. Tech + labor /// bgmwrites@gmail.com Keybase: keybase.io/bryangm Securedrop: http://gmg7jl25ony5g7ws.onion/

Share This Story

Get our newsletter


Manic Otti

Using company e-mail to organize? Doesn’t that just provide your company evidence to use against you? Just wondering...