Stealth Tech Blamed for International Sub Crash, French Crew Unaware They'd Hit Anyone for Days

Illustration for article titled Stealth Tech Blamed for International Sub Crash, French Crew Unaware They'd Hit Anyone for Days

How could two submarines end up colliding in the middle of the ocean? British military types are blaming excessive stealthiness, and the French claim they didn't realize what had happened for days.


A Royal Navy source told the Times:

It is remarkably difficult to detect a modern submarine with sonar and we work very hard with our own submarines, as do our allies, in making them as quiet as possible so they are not detectable.

And he's serious about that—even after realizing they'd hit something, the French crew couldn't tell what it was. They wrote the object off as a shipping container, only to find out that they had actually collided with another submarine upon docking three days later, after the government had deduced the collision from routine information exchanges with the British.

The problem was that both submarines use passive sonar to map out their surroundings, which doesn't give away their location with the 'pings' of active sonar, and is somewhat less sensitive. Without these 'pings', it was nearly impossible for either sub's passive sonar to detect the other's, leading to the collision and subsequent confusion.

In reality, the whole thing was a bit more subdued than initial reports (or our imaginations) led us to believe. The subs, which were traveling very slowly, just sort of bonked into on another, and the only critical damage to either vessel was to the French sub's sonar system. [Times Online]


I don't blame Stealth, I blame chance and probability. It was bound to happen, and it seems that if they would "write off" hitting a shipping container, it must happen a good amount of time. I mean hell, a US sub did an Emergency Blow once and hit a Japanese ship. Besides, Jessica Biel was totally hot in Stealth.