Vote 2020 graphic
Everything you need to know about and expect during
the most important election of our lifetimes

The Smell of Fear: Blu-Ray Backs Out of Open Format War Debate

Illustration for article titled The Smell of Fear: Blu-Ray Backs Out of Open Format War Debate

Today was supposed to be a fun day, a day where I moderated a discussion between HD DVD and Blu-ray, where the bullshit would be kept to a minimum as both parties insta-fact checked each other's propaganda in real time. Delicious sounding, isn't it? Well after a few months of getting them to commit, Blu-ray canceled, citing wishes not to upset their current momentum.

Advertisement

It's true, they're selling a lot of discs, but when it comes to exploring which format is more consumer friendly, Blu's cancellation isn't much of a vote of confidence in its own tech. The only reason I can think of is that Blu-ray would not be able to defend the conclusions we made in our "State of Blu-ray" piece, basically saying that there are only two major manufacturers of Blu-ray players that meet even the meager "standard" Blu-ray profile, and Sony and Pioneer aren't among them. And since studio supported evened up when Paramount went exclusively HD DVD, Blu-ray lost its main selling point.

Advertisement

Even though the BD consortium turned down the invite to discuss their format and fact check HD DVD's claims, Blu-ray has addressed this issue of tiered feature rollout once before. In their words: "Even DVD had hiccups with the format at first." True, true. But it seems like a format consortium is supposed to avoid and clean up consumer-burning hiccups, not plan for them. It just would have been cool to have video of both sides telling the other to STFU as they fact checked each other till the truth emerged. Until then, standard DVD continues to kick the crap out of both newcomers, so maybe the loss of this debate wasn't such a big deal for the average person. Until our next feature on the HD format war, just be careful what you buy.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

Here we go with the pointless arguments about which format is technically superior. More storage, sharper image, etc. etc. etc. It's all shite. In my mind it's been pretty much settled that, when it comes to actually using your eyes to watch the movies that come out of these formats, they look pretty much the same. So who friggin cares which has more storage, bitrate, whatever?

Since image quality is essentially equal, the bottom line for me is PRICE and CONTENT. Content is pretty much a wash, since each format has some of the good stuff. That's why this "war" sucks, because if you choose one format, you can't get all the movies.

Since I just set up a high end projection home theater, I had to have one of them, so I took the cheapest route at the moment (HD-DVD) so that I can watch SOME movies in high def, then I'll just sit tight for a while.