Of course, soon, nearly everyone with any sort of connection to the event began claiming that it had to be a hoax. Santili, then, admitted that most of the "original footage" was of such terrible quality that he just had to have portions reshot by reenacting the supposedly actual events—a sort I Didn't Know I Was Pregnant except instead of babies you have E.T.'s entrails. Eventually, artist and sculptor John Humphreys also came clean, admitting that he'd constructed two extraterrestrial bodies and filled them with a tasty little mixture of sheep's brains, jelly (flavor unspecified), chicken entrails, and knuckle joints. You know, alien stuff.

Advertisement

Despite all these admissions and the evidence to the contrary, Santilli continues to maintain that the film is a 100% accurate reconstruction of the original, conveniently-degraded-beyond-repair footage.

Morristown, New Jersey

But it's not just our gullible, less-jaded grandparents that fell for UFO scares. As recently as 2009, the residents of Morris Count New Jersey spent January and February mystified over five strange lights that consistently appeared in the night sky. Even workers in control towers couldn't figure out where the lights were coming from—nothing showed up on their radars. So of course, the next logical conclusion was aliens.

Advertisement

However, on April Fools' Day, two young men admitted to perpetrating the hoax. Attaching simple lights to helium balloons, they had sent the faux-spacecrafts on their way above the town in an effort to show how easy it is to incite a UFO scare. And it certainly worked.

Advertisement

Since we know for 100 percent certain what actually happened in this case, the extent and variety of people's reactions proved just how unreliable and inconsistent people's accounts of alien sightings can be. Though there had been nothing more than a few hovering lights, some people claimed to have never seen anything quite so scary in their lives; some outright refused to believe the cause had been balloons; and one man even insisted that he had seen nine, scattered lights eventually come together in a line and start communicating with one another. So no matter how sincere the story may sound, people are absurdly unreliable narrators when it comes to an alien encounter.

Still, even if you can check off most supposed sightings as military aircrafts, bizarre cloud formations, weather balloons, meteorites, satellites, planets, festive Chinese lanterns, or hoaxes, there will always be at least some unsolved mystery that seems to carry with the promise of alien contact. Even if it's just the smallest of possibilities, that's all some people need to get the conspiracy train rolling. Which means these supposed UFO sightings won't be going away anytime soon.

Advertisement

[UFOs: Fact or Fiction, Reanalysis of the 1965 Heflin UFO Photos, Picture Proof: A History of Fraud and Contrivance in Photojournalism and Documentary, UFO Casebook]

Advertisement

Image: Shutterstock/sad444