Doctors Have an Alarmingly High Suicide Rate, and No One Is Sure How to Help Them

Illustration for article titled Doctors Have an Alarmingly High Suicide Rate, and No One Is Sure How to Help Themem/emem/em
Image: DarkoStojanovic (Pixabay)

Medical doctors are more likely to die from suicide than members of any other profession in the US, suggests new research presented this week at the annual meeting of the American Psychiatric Association. And worse than that, few interventions seem to have helped make these suicides less common.

Advertisement

Studies have consistently shown that doctors die from suicide at a higher rate annually than people in any other profession, and some research has found that a majority of medical professionals suffer from serious work stress and burnout. But the authors behind this latest work wanted to not only get a clearer picture of how often these deaths happen, but whether any programs have successfully helped lowered rates. So they examined relevant, peer-reviewed studies dealing with both issues over the past 10 years.

They found that anywhere from 28 to 40 doctors per every 100,000 a year die from suicide in the US (in raw numbers, that might amount to anywhere from 300 to 400 suicides a year). By contrast, the annual age-adjusted rate of suicide among all Americans was 13.42 deaths per every 100,000 people in 2016. Women doctors attempted suicide far less often than American women overall, but they died from suicide at roughly the same rate as male doctors. Generally, women are known to have suicidal ideation and to attempt suicide more often than men, but are less likely to die from it.

Advertisement

When the researchers looked at studies of interventions meant to reduce suicide ideation or symptoms of depression among doctors, they found disappointing results. Overall, there was no real reduction in suicide rates or other related metrics following the implementation of these interventions, such as physician health programs offered by hospitals.

“Suicide amongst physicians is an under-recognized public health concern,” the authors wrote in their abstract (the study in full has yet to be published in a peer-reviewed journal). “To date, treatment interventions have not lowered the rates of physician suicide.”

The review also highlighted some preventable risk factors that might make doctors more vulnerable to suicide. Prior to their suicide, many doctors had been diagnosed with mood disorders, or had alcohol and substance use problems. And the most common method of suicide was medication overdose, followed by firearms.

Many doctors struggling with suicidal ideation or depression, however, never seek any psychiatric help. One study the authors reviewed, based on a Facebook survey of over 2,000 doctors, found that half reported fitting the criteria of a mental disorder but avoided seeing anyone for it because they feared being stigmatized. That hesitance, the authors say, might be the greatest obstacle to effective, early treatment.

Advertisement

“To reduce the number of physicians taking their life, fear of stigma and other risk factors have to be addressed through more research aimed at effective and early intervention,” they wrote.

The findings, sobering as they are, weren’t entirely bleak. One study of a web-based program that provided cognitive behavioral therapy to medical interns did find it was associated with lower rates of suicidal ideation. And by showcasing their research, the team hopes more doctors will become willing to discuss their mental health issues, and that more hospitals will create evidence-based programs that can help doctors struggling with work burnout and depression.

Advertisement

If you or someone you know is having suicidal thoughts, please call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 800-273-8255 or text the Crisis Text Line at 741-741.

[APA 2018 via WebMD]

Advertisement

Science writer at Gizmodo and pug aficionado elsewhere

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

flyfunner5
flyfunner5

It’s because of work hours. Truck drivers aren’t even allowed to driver longer than 10 or 12 consecutive hours, yet residents are expected to pull 16-hour+ shifts (we get it grandpa, back in your day you worked 200 hour weeks and performed surgery backwards in the snow with a blindfold on).

Luckily, the ACGME has heard these concerns and reverted work-hour restrictions so residents can work even longer. Can’t commit suicide if you don’t have the time to, taps temporalis.

At least the residency programs are on top of it, after your 100-hour work week, you now have a mandatory well-being lecture on how to relax and stay healthy.

Then there’s the sunk-cost fallacy, you’ve already invested a decade pursuing this profession. Average debt is $250k+ and it’s not uncommon for that to balloon to 400k with interest by the time residency is done. Residents barely make minimum wage during their training even though their spots are funded by the government and they actually bring in net revenue for the hospital/program, while NPs and PAs with less training are making more money.

For more discussion, join us here: https://www.reddit.com/r/medicalschool/comments/8hwvoj/wellbeing_another_nyu_resident_suicide/