MPAA Still Trying to Plug Your Analog Hole with Selectable Output Control

Illustration for article titled MPAA Still Trying to Plug Your Analog Hole with Selectable Output Control

Still use component connections with your cable box? Listen up: the MPAA has again asked the FCC to let studios disable analog connections during certain on-demand movies. The FCC currently bans this, and here's why that's a good thing.

Advertisement

Lots of gear that's still kicking around only has an analog connection with a cable box: like TiVos and Slingboxes made before 2004. And what about your TV? You'd likely be forced to upgrade to gear with digital ports (like HDMI) to watch movies protected with Selectable Output Control.

The studios are desperate to show on-demand movies over cable prior to their DVD release, but claim they can't without SOC. They say the tech protects their revenue by blocking easy analog copying—the so called "analog hole". Problem is, DVDs (a supposed secure format) get ripped and shared online, anyway.

Advertisement

Not only that, but it's almost a moot point. Warner Brothers (who signed the original SOC petition last year) released Observe and Report, and Ghosts of Girlfriends Past for video-on-demand this September—before their DVDs hit stores. Consumer advocacy groups, like Public Knowledge and the EFF, also point out that Magnolia Pictures, distributors like IFC, and more recently, Starz Media, are also doing VoD before DVD.

Illustration for article titled MPAA Still Trying to Plug Your Analog Hole with Selectable Output Control

The MPAA says that the outputs would only be disabled for the new movies, and wouldn't impact any existing content. And they make the fair point that there's always a lag between new experiences early adopters get compared to those with older gear.

Advertisement

But I'm sorry MPAA, pull your head out of your arse. DVDs still get ripped, and one of the very studios you represent is still releasing on-demand movies prior to their DVD release. Why bother? Think about the huge customer base you're alienating, and stay away from the back of my TV. [Public Knowledge and PC Magazine via BoingBoing]

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

So...in other words I must buy a DVD or Blu-Ray player that was built between 1998 and the passing of this law. Then I can still pirate movies?

Don't they get the fact that most people use computer drives to make the copy? I don't know many people who are taking a Blu-ray movie and using the analog ports to copy it to VHS or DVD-R.

I guess, if I don't have the latest TV, but I have a late model disc player, I'm not allowed to watch any new movies.

It's amazing that I have to keep buying the latest stuff just to keep my shit legitimate. Remember when TVs used to last 10-20 years? I'm only 25 and I'm prefectly happy with my 52" Proscan from 1994. Picture's still great for 90% of the stuff I watch.