HBO and Friends Want Their Own Pipes for Internet TV

Just when you thought the net neutrality debate had died down, a band of content providers now want special treatment. The Wall Street Journal reports that HBO, Sony, and Showtime are asking internet service providers to be treated as "managed" services. In other words, they want dedicated bandwidth for their video content.

Now's a good time to shake your fist. If HBO and friends get their way, they'll be paying companies like Comcast for "a separate lane [that] would be exempt from monthly data-usage thresholds operators enforce for public Internet traffic." And guess who's going to end up paying for the extra cost? You are.


Don't freak out too much, though. This is not the same thing as paid prioritization, the so-called "fast lane" practice that enables ISPs to treat certain packets of data differently than others. That would be a very bad thing since internet traffic is a zero-sum game. If some packets go faster, others must move more slowly. It would also be a direct violation of the FCC's new net neutrality rules.

What these streaming video companies actually want is dedicated bandwidth. It's sort of analogous to an HOV lane, where the content providers pay for a special road for their data heavy traffic. Some companies, like those that offer digital phone and video-on-demand services, already enjoy these benefits of being managed services. However, as WSJ put it, internet TV getting the same treatment "would tap into a gray area of the debate over 'net neutrality.'" It's not paid prioritization. But it's not necessarily neutral, either.

All that said, pull up a chair because this is going to be a long battle. Content providers like Netflix already pay for special interconnection agreements with ISPs like Comcast, if only because streaming video requires so much bandwidth. (See the above chart for a rough idea of how the internet works.) Netflix basically doesn't have any other choice.


Fearing the same grim future when their customers pay to watch the word "Buffering" float on a blank screen, HBO and other internet TV companies are looking for a loophole. Managed services might be the one. Eventually, it'll probably be up to the FCC to decide if they can send traffic through it. [WSJ]


Correction: An earlier version of this post referred to the agreements between Netflix and ISPs as transit agreements. They are interconnection agreements.

Contact the author at
Public PGP key
PGP fingerprint: 91CF B387 7B38 148C DDD6 38D2 6CBC 1E46 1DBF 22


Share This Story