Let's See How Well YouTube's Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working

Illustration for article titled Lets See How Well YouTubes Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working

YouTube is notorious for its godawful, subhuman commenters. Google's solution? Implementing a new regime in which people are prompted to switch their accounts to their real name. Fortunately, the majority comments continue to be just as horrendous and offensive as ever. Business as usual!

Advertisement

Google started rolling out the change about three weeks ago, which should be a reasonable amount of time to see some tangible benefits. In fact, it's proven by our perusing of YouTube that 95 percent of comments still contain either a racial slur, a sexist tirade, is totally incomprehensible, or some combination of those. Here are some shining examples:


Illustration for article titled Lets See How Well YouTubes Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working
Advertisement

Here's the platonic ideal of a Real Name YouTube Comment. Well said, John Azevedo!


Illustration for article titled Lets See How Well YouTubes Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working

But assholes are still assholes, even when they're using their real names.


Illustration for article titled Lets See How Well YouTubes Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working
Advertisement

And the majority of people are still anonymous (racist) assholes.


Illustration for article titled Lets See How Well YouTubes Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working
Advertisement

Not to mention ignorant.


Illustration for article titled Lets See How Well YouTubes Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working
Advertisement

And creepy.


Illustration for article titled Lets See How Well YouTubes Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working
Advertisement

And underage.


Illustration for article titled Lets See How Well YouTubes Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working
Advertisement

And psychotic.


Illustration for article titled Lets See How Well YouTubes Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working
Advertisement

And incoherent.


Illustration for article titled Lets See How Well YouTubes Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working
Advertisement

And homophobic.


Illustration for article titled Lets See How Well YouTubes Real-Name Comment Policy Is Working
Advertisement

I mean, to each his own.


The point is, none of this is working, and Google is basically going to have to beg (or more likely, force) people to make the shift. Meanwhile, comments will continue to be awful as ever. Entertaining, but totally toxic.

Advertisement

Share This Story

Get our newsletter

DISCUSSION

Brian Richards

The rare time I post a youtube video, I automatically turn off comments and all other feedback.