Scott Pruitt's Office Is Drowning in Unfilled Records Requests

Illustration for article titled Scott Pruitt's Office Is Drowning in Unfilled Records Requests
Photo: Pablo Martinez Monsivais (AP)

As public interest in Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Scott Pruitt’s activities reaches a fever pitch, the EPA’s Office of the Administrator is getting hit with hundreds of Freedom of Information Act requests. And as a new analysis shows, the agency is struggling to keep up.


Data released Sunday by the Project on Government Oversight shows a 400 percent uptick in FOIA requests directed at the EPA Administrator’s Office between 2016 and 2017. And yet despite clear interest in everything from Pruitt’s meetings to his notoriously hard-to-get calendar (Gizmodo Media is one of many news organizations that’s requested copies of this under FOIA) to his travel habits, these requests are getting processed slowly: Just 17 percent of FOIA requests routed to the Administrator’s Office were closed under Trump’s administration in 2017. The an agency-wide closure rate? Seventy nine percent.

Andrew Bergman, Special Environmental Advisor to the Project On Government Oversight who led the analysis, told Earther that vast disparity “indicates that the evasiveness we’re concerned about is real.”

Bergman noted that many of the records requests making their way to the Administrator’s Office regard politically sensitive documents or potential incidences of misconduct, i.e. “things that are most important to the public.”

This analysis, which is based largely on records released to the Project on Government Oversight (under FOIA, no less), is ongoing, but as of yet the government watchdog has not been able to determine how that 17 percent closure figure compares with previous years. Regardless, the fraction of requests that led to the release of records from the Administrator’s Office is likely to be far lower.

“The vast majority of the 17 percent that were records were provided,” Bergman said.

It’s hard to say to what degree the inability of Pruitt’s office to fill its growing pile of public records requests can be chalked up to bureaucratic inefficiency and sheer volume (the office received more than a thousand FOIA requests last year, the agency as a whole, over 11,000), versus the evasiveness that worries open government groups and environmentalists. The EPA did not respond to a request for comment on this story.


Adam Marshall, an attorney with Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, told Earther he wouldn’t be surprised if funding, staffing, and intra-agency politics are all playing a role.

“I think certainly funding and staffing is a huge part of what makes FOIA requests take so long,” he said. “At the same time, the amount of resources an agency chooses to devote to FOIA is kind of a policy decision.”


Whatever the reason for the delays, many who are keen to pry information out of the EPA aren’t sitting idly by. A concomitant report released by Politico on Monday shows a surge in open-records lawsuits aimed at the agency last year. Fifty five public records lawsuits have been filed against the EPA since Trump’s inauguration, compared with just 57 FOIA lawsuits during George W. Bush’s entire presidency.

It may be that the only way to truly understand why the EPA Administrator always flies first class is to sue.


Maddie Stone is a freelancer based in Philadelphia.


Dense non aqueous phase liquid

When you get stuck at EPA (or ghosted as the kids say), have someone run over to DoJ Environment and Natural Resources Division. First you gotta do what every good salesperson would do to get the right point of contact - and that is find the org chart. Here it is for DoJ ENRD and it looks like Karen Wardzinski is the pertinent section chief on the topic of this post. Do a cold call.

Karen Wardzinski, Section Chief

The Law and Policy Section staff advises and assists the Assistant Attorney General on environmental legal and policy questions, particularly those that affect multiple sections in the Division. Working with the Office of Legislative Affairs, it coordinates the Division’s response to legislative proposals and Congressional requests, prepares for appearances of Division witnesses before Congressional committees, and drafts legislative proposals in connection with the Division’s work. Other duties include responding to congressional and citizen correspondence and FOIA requests, as well as serving as the Division’s ethics officer and counselor, alternative dispute resolution counselor, and liaison with state and local governments. Attorneys in the Section coordinate the Division’s amicus practice, handling many of these cases directly or together with Appellate, undertake other special litigation projects, and coordinate the Division’s involvement in international legal matters.

Let’s see if BP’s outside council, Jeffrey Bossert has made it past committee. for appointment to DoJ ENRD. Apparently not yet as of January 2018. Once he’s at DoJ ENRD - the org chart will be one box -his. Bossert is like Scott Pruitt, but with a Harvard BA and Georgetown JD. He’s also a true believer in making America great again. When clients could simply dump their shit in the river, the air,lakes, oceans and the back 40 And real Americans who truly appreciate America and living downwind, gradient and stream would like it. America First.