Senate Hits 50 Votes in Bid to Save Net Neutrality and/or Make Republicans Look Dumb

FCC Chairman and former Verizon lawyer Ajit Pai. Photo: Getty
FCC Chairman and former Verizon lawyer Ajit Pai. Photo: Getty

Senate Democrats are getting serious about overruling the FCC’s recent decision to kill net neutrality protections. Republican Senator Susan Collins has joined 49 Democrats in the endorsement of a legislative measure that would reverse the FCC’s ruling. Only one more vote is necessary for the measure to pass the Senate.


Democrats have seized on the unpopularity of the decision to repeal Title II protections that help ensure traffic on the web is treated equally. Fears that telecommunication companies will soon implement internet fast lanes to provide some websites with preferential treatment are widespread, and Republicans have already proposed Trojan horse legislation that would only serve to further entrench the substance of the FCC decision.

Democrats have decided to attempt to use the Congressional Review Act (CRA) to nullify the repeal of net neutrality, and they are surprisingly close to making it through the Senate. At this point, Vice President Mike Pence would be called on to cast a tie-breaking vote. There’s little reason to believe he’d vote against his administration’s FCC, and so Democrats will have to find one other vote if they hope to move forward.

According to the Washington Post, Senate Minority Leader Charles E. Schumer told reporters on Tuesday, “With full caucus support, it’s clear that Democrats are committed to fighting to keep the Internet from becoming the Wild West where ISPs are free to offer premium service to only the wealthiest customers while average consumers are left with far inferior options.”

Of course, even if Democrats clear the single vote hurdle they face in the Senate, they’ll still have to get through the House, and President Trump would have to sign the legislation.

“The Internet is on a mission to save net neutrality, and lawmakers that stand in our way will regret it,” Evan Greer, campaign director of Fight for the Future, said in an email to Gizmodo. “Cleanly reversing the FCC’s unpopular and illegitimate decision is, on substance, the correct policy move, and the only one that has support from voters.”

But failure may be the ultimate goal of Democrats. They may simply see an opening to make net neutrality an issue in the mid-term elections. By forcing a vote on the Senate floor, they would make members of the Senate take a side on the issue, and their decision could be used to campaign against them. If by some miracle one more Republican decides to get on board, the House would also define its position on the issue.


Between the health care battle and the tax cut fight, we’ve seen Republicans demonstrate their willingness to vote against the preference of their constituents, but it’s unclear if they have strong enough feelings on net neutrality to allow it to become yet another wedge issue in 2018.

[Washington Post]




Please, PLEASE don’t make this an “us vs them” battle between Dems and republicans.

This is one of the few issues I think most would agree on. Common ground is sparse these days and we need more of it. Inflammatory headlines are short-sighted click grabs that are ultimately hurtful to this cause.