We cover a lot of toys and collectibles here at io9, which means you should trust us when we say we know what makes a good nerdy gift. The key is to recognize that fandom comes in many different forms. Some people want to show off their love for their favorite things, while others want to be a little more low-key. Maybe the person you’re buying for would love a Muppet Christmas Carol sweater, or maybe they’d rather keep cozy with a blanket that’s also a handy guide to different film aspect ratios. Either way—and whatever your price point—we’ve got you covered.
Gifts Under $50
KPop Demon Hunters Criterion Collection Edition
Animation deserves to be taken seriously—so seeing KPop Demon Hunters joining the prestigious ranks of the Criterion Collection is especially exciting. And while it’s true that you can now and forever watch the Oscar-winning movie through your Netflix subscription, the extras here are worth the cost, including a feature-length animatic, a making-of documentary, lyric videos, and a set of collectible postcards.
Spaceballs: The New T-Shirt
Merchandising! Merchandising! Merchandising! Spaceballs is all about merchandising, and with the second film coming in 2027, why not be prepared with a t-shirt?
Mixtape
One of the year’s most unforgettable gaming experiences is this unique blend of Dazed and Confused, Ferris Bueller, and about a dozen other incredible movies set in the 1980s and 1990s. It’s a journey you’ll never forget and want to take again and again. We just wish we could own it physically.
The Woobles Star Trek Spock Crochet Kit
If you have a nerdy loved one who’s looking to pick up a new hobby, this learn-to-crochet kit from The Woobles is a great choice. It comes with everything you need to crochet an amigurumi Spock from Star Trek, from the yarn to the hook to the pattern. Plus, it has detailed video instructions to guide you every step of the way.
Don't Say I Didn't 'Warren' You T-Shirt (Widow's Bay)
Apple TV has some of the best shows around, and yet the company’s insatiable zest for selling tech products has yet to translate into many official merch offerings. Fortunately, other sources are more than happy to feed the Widow’s Bay fandom. We are particularly fond of this t-shirt that looks like you picked it up on your last visit to the historical museum on everyone’s favorite cursed island.
Shudder Baby Onesie
While you wait for your favorite baby to grow up enough to fully appreciate the joys of The Exorcist or The Texas Chain Saw Massacre, you can start them on the road to horror fandom by picking up one or all of these Shudder-branded onesies. “Born to Scream” with the vampire teeth is a solid choice; alternate options on the AMC merch site include “Certified Little Monster” and “Screams on Demand.”
The Odyssey 4K
Christopher Nolan movies have to be watched in just the right conditions. So, assuming you don’t have an IMAX theater in your house, the 4K home release of The Odyssey is a solid substitute. Plus, it’s got a ton of extras exploring the behind-the-scenes of one of this year’s biggest hits.
Retro Gaming Console Trading Card Deck Box
This cute, retro gaming-themed trading card box can hold a whole double-sleeved Magic: The Gathering Commander deck (or two unsleeved decks, for those of you who like to live on the edge). It also comes in a variety of colors if mint green isn’t your cup of tea.
Project Hail Mary Rocky Plush
2026 brought us the incredible gift of Rocky, the alien creature who stole our hearts and saved a few worlds, in Project Hail Mary. Even though he’s made of rock, you just want to hug him, and you can do just that with this adorable toy.
Beadle and Grimm's Player's Journal
This journal is perfect for the tabletop role-playing game lover in your life. It’s not just a blank book with a cover: it’s divided into seven sections to help you keep track of session logs, NPCs, locations, loot, and more. There are even birth and death certificates to add flavor and help you fill out your character details and background.
Thomasin (From The Witch) Tree Topper
While Robert Eggers’ Werwulf is his ghoulish treat for Christmas 2026, his first feature will always be our darkest delight. Celebrate the 10th anniversary of The Witch with this tree topper featuring Anya Taylor-Joy’s character, hands folded in prayer as she realizes Satan is the key to escaping the hell of life in Puritan New England.
Pawlymorph Mimic Chest Dog Toy
Why get a regular, boring, unmagical dog toy when you can instead pick up this plushy, toothy chest inspired by the iconic Dungeons & Dragons monster? It comes with actual treasure in the form of four removable squeaky toys that keep the tabletop theme going, though we’re not responsible for any spells your pup conjures out of that bottle.
Dungeon Crawler Carl Action Figure
Most franchises wait until they have a TV show or movie before making action figures. But most franchises aren’t Dungeon Crawler Carl. The popular book series starring a man in his underwear and his ex-girlfriend’s cat as they traverse post-apocalyptic dangers broadcast to the galaxy is fantastic, and this toy does it justice.
Alien: Earth Sheep With the Eye Interactive Plush
Since Alien: Earth season two is still a ways off, this plush serves as an unforgettable reminder of what happened in season one. Or, at least, one very specific thing that happened in season one. And that parasite on its face? The tentacles are fully removeable and posable, so you can make them cling to the sheep however you’d like, or even shove them all the way inside its eye socket so that it looks (almost) normal. Plus, it’s pleasingly oversized at 13.”
A Feast for a Tenday (Baldur's Gate 3): The Official Cookbook
After a long night of Baldur’s Gate 3, there’s no better way to replenish your strength in the real world by tucking into one of the 65 dishes, snacks, desserts, and drinks collected in this book. Even players who don’t necessarily spend much time in the kitchen will appreciate the attention to detail—the recipes draw on ingredients and locations from the game itself—not to mention the delectable photos.
Gifts Under $100
Obsession One Wish Willow Tote Bag
You could fill stockings with replica One Wish Willows. But why risk replicating Nikki’s ordeal when your favorite horror fan could showcase their Obsession fandom in a more fashion-forward way instead? This official tote bag from Focus Features has a zippered top and sturdy construction, perfect for carrying your stuff without triggering any unbreakable curses.
Masters of the Universe Chronicles He-Man and Skeletor Action Figure Two-Pack
Whether you loved or hated this year’s Masters of the Universe movie, there’s no doubt the toys were awesome. They were crafted with as much care, if not more, than the movie itself. And this two-pack brings together the film’s most famous characters in an epic showdown.
The Muppet Christmas Carol Sweater
The best adaptation of A Christmas Carol we will ever see (featuring Michael Caine as the best Scrooge of all time) comes to life in a tastefully festive sweater decorated with wreaths, snowflakes, and Kermit-as-Bob-Cratchit faces. Disney doesn’t do a ton of Muppet Christmas Carol merch, so this would be a fun gift for the person on your gift list who quotes it the most.
Spider-Man Streetlight Desk Lamp
This fun lamp will light up any Spider-Man fan’s life. Its playful design features the Web-Slinger dangling upside-down from a streetlight. He’s fixed in place, too, so he won’t go swinging around any time your pets get a little careless with where they wag their tails. Not that we have any experience with that.
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
While a lot of people are robbing and killing in the new Grand Theft Auto VI, other gamers can spend their time robbing tombs and killing monsters in this incredible remake of one of the best video games ever made. And it looks amazing in this new update.
Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie the Box Set
After you watch one of the year’s best, funniest, most unique movies, the only thing you’ll want to do is spend more time trying in Toronto. Well, thanks to this box set, you get not just the movie but two seasons of the TV show it’s based on, available for the first time ever on physical media. It’s tailor-made for film nerds.
Godzilla Keycaps
Let Godzilla stomp all over your favorite keyboard with these officially licensed keycaps. Each set contains 173 keycaps, enough to kit out a full-size keyboard, plus a few extra novelties to fully customize your layout and look. The color scheme is meant to bring to mind a vintage movie poster, and the design is an homage to over 70 years of kaiju history.
Lucas Museum Snow Globe
Leave it to George Lucas to create a museum that looks like a space ship. And whether you’ve been to the museum or not, this globe is the perfect way to bring the structure’s unforgettable design into your home.
Ken Russell's The Devils Director's Cut - Collector's Edition
The 55-year-old cult sensation gained a generation of new fans and a fresh wave of critical respect thanks to its recent theatrical run in uncensored, gloriously restored 4K. While the long-awaited physical release technically won’t ship until April, you can pre-order it now for the cinephile in your life, even if (especially if) they probably belong on Santa’s “naughty” list.
Gifts Under $200
A24 Aspect Ratio Blanket
If trying to parse the difference between all the different formats of The Odyssey left you scratching your head, A24 has got you covered with a practical and good-looking solution. This 55″x77″ cotton woven blanket features an abstract design that also functions as a guide to several common (and some uncommon) film aspect ratios.
They Live Prop Replica Sunglasses
These officially licensed They Live sunglasses were modeled on a screen-used pair provided by John Carpenter for maximum authenticity. We can’t confirm whether or not they enable you to spot aliens in your midst, but we’d be happy to try them on immediately rather than fighting Rowdy Roddy Piper in an alley for 20 minutes beforehand.
Reversible Horror Film Work Jacket
A perfect gift for the streetwear enthusiast in your life who wants to show off their love for horror movies, this jacket features the faces of some of horror’s most recognizable characters. It’s also reversible, providing two different looks to level up any outfit.
The Sacred and The Cursed: The Joko Anwar Collection
Four standout films by Indonesian horror breakout Joko Anwar come together in this gleefully grisly set. Just the movies would be gift enough—Satan’s Slaves (inspired by a 1980 supernatural cult classic), Satan’s Slaves 2: Communion (its truly terrifying sequel), Impetigore (a cautionary tale filtered through folk horror), and Dead Time (a neo-noir thriller)—but this collection also includes over 10 hours of exclusive special features. Perfect for the person who can’t stop screaming about Ghost in the Cell, Anwar’s most recent release to hit U.S. theaters.
Star Wars Comics Library Vol. 1. 1977-1979
Every Taschen art book is gorgeous, and this one is no exception. Star Wars Comics Library Vol. 1. 1977-1979 collects the first 23 issues of Marvel’s Star Wars comics and presents them in a digitally remastered format. The collection also includes “an in-depth history by comic book historian Peter Sanderson.”
Want more io9 news? Check out the best movies and TV shows to stream this month and all the upcoming sci-fi, fantasy, and horror books that should be on your radar.