A Quiet Place Could Have Been a Cloverfield Movie

From A Quiet Place.
From A Quiet Place.
Image: Paramount

A Quiet Place, John Krasinski’s unsettling, low-key horror film, has been one of 2018's best, creepiest surprises. But if things had shook out a little bit differently, it could’ve been a part of a major film franchise.

Advertisement

According to a new interview with Slash Film, the screenplay, by writers Bryan Woods and Scott Beck, was at one point under consideration to be roped into the Cloverfield franchise. Since the first film, JJ Abrams’ Bad Robot has had a curious method of expanding the series, adapting existing screenplays into a sort of genre-spanning horror monster anthology series, with great results and, uh, not so great ones. And as explained by Beck and Woods, A Quiet Place could have been one of those movies:

Scott: I know! That was one of those things that, I guess it crossed our mind and we had spoken to our representatives about that possibility. It was weird timing, though, because when we were writing the script, 10 Cloverfield Lane was at Paramount. We were actually talking to an executive there about this film, and it felt from pitch form that there might be crossover, but when we finally took the final script in to Paramount, they saw it as a totally different movie. What was really incredible about the process that we feel very grateful for is the studio embraced this weird movie with no dialogue with open arms. They never thought about branding it as a Cloverfield film, I think in part because conceptually it was able to stand on its own.

Bryan: And our biggest fear was – we love Bad Robot, we love the people over there, and obviously J.J. [Abrams] is certainly a hero to us – but one of our biggest fears was this getting swept up into some kind of franchise or repurposed for something like that. The reason I say ‘biggest fear’ – we love the Cloverfield movies. They’re excellent. It’s just that as filmgoers, we crave new and original ideas. And we feel like so much of what’s out there is IP. It’s comic books, it’s remakes, it’s sequels. We show up to all of them, we enjoy those movies too, but our dream was always to drop something different into the marketplace, so we feel grateful that Paramount embraced the movie as its own thing.

At the end of the day, we’re grateful A Quiet Place got a chance to shine on its own. Original horror films are too rare these days as it is. And, honestly, it’s probably best to avoid associating too closely with The Cloverfield Paradox.

[Slash Film]

io9 Weekend Editor. Videogame writer at other places. Queer nerd girl.

DISCUSSION

franco1975
Troll

The scenes were scary and suspenseful IF the moviegoer is willing to overlook a few things.
1) how did the monsters get there? Who are they?
2) why didnt the town folk move away? Was the whole planet taken up by these monsters.
3) Whats up with the nail on the step that the wife stepped on? No one puts a nail on a step! Why didnt she cover up the nail or put a sign on it so that no one else steps on it? I found the nail scene out of place. As if the director said, ‘ not enough scary stuff so lets make her step on a nail’.
4) She gives birth and she starts talking about the dead son? Its not reasonable to suddenly speak of the dead son. You talk about the new baby.
5) The ending was crap. It implied the wife shot ALL the monsters.

I did enjoy the sound effect. It was perfect for the scenes. The movie needs 30 minutes more to explain how the monsters got there and how the wife kills the monsters.