Skip to content
Gadgets

PS5 Is the Best Way to Play ‘GTA VI,’ but Not for the Reason You Think

GTA VI's performance and visuals are amazing, but can they hold up on a lower-power Xbox Series S?
By

Reading time 5 minutes

Spoiler alert: There’s a PlayStation console inside Grand Theft Auto VI. Protagonist Jason Duval’s stoner friend, Cal Hampton, plants it on your TV stand and calls it a “JoyStation.” So before you ask, no, it’s not the fabled PS6. It’s a caricature of the PS5’s whale fin and glowing light bar embellishments. After all, GTA as a series has always been a satire of our modern reality, one where an overly pretentious black-and-white walking sim game gets as much hype as a dumb-as-nails twin-stick zombie shooter.

Rockstar’s record-making blockbuster treats the JoyStation as if there were no other console in the Grand Theft Auto universe. Rockstar may be commenting on its stake in today’s console rivalry. Sony and GTA publisher Take Two Interactive had an exclusive marketing deal for the last several months. That left Xbox shipping customized alligator Series X consoles and controllers, with it unable to use any GTA VI logos in its guerrilla marketing campaign. Xbox fans don’t have to worry. I’ve played hours on both PS5 and Xbox Series X, and the game runs essentially the same across both consoles. The PS5 may still be the better fit, but not for the reasons you think.

Ignoring differences in time-of-day lighting, ‘Grand Theft Auto VI’ looks and plays the same on both Xbox Series X, left, and PlayStation 5, right. © Rockstar Games; screenshot by Gizmodo

GTA VI is locked to 30 fps no matter which console you play it on, whether that’s Xbox Series X, PS5, or PS5 Pro. Both the Series X and PS5 are making use of Rockstar’s homegrown TAA (temporal anti-aliasing) upscaling model to take the image at 1440p and transform it to fill in the pixels necessary for 4K. TAA uses motion vectors and pixel data to attempt to upscale games, though this is not the best option available. Sony recently promoted QSSR as an optional upscaler on base PS5 models, while Xbox games are now able to make use of FSR 4.1.

If that sounds like gamers are getting a raw deal, there’s more to consider here. AI upscaling like FSR necessitates consoles use some of their GPU power to run neural upscaling. GTA VI is likely pushing current consoles as hard as they can, which may not leave enough room for improved upscaling. Upscaling also introduces a certain amount of latency, and Rockstar wants to maintain a stiff 30 fps target through every moment of gameplay. Still, I suspect Rockstar may update its game later to improve visual quality across both systems.

I’ve played enough of the new game to know there’s no real difference in visual quality between the consoles. Despite what you may have heard from the talking heads on Reddit or Twitter, the Series X is not necessarily the best way to play GTA VI. Xbox consoles feature low-framerate compensation, or LFC. It’s essentially a means for games to make use of the console’s VRR (variable refresh rate) even though that VRR normally locks to a minimum of 48Hz and to a max of 120Hz. It’s a way for the console to deal with potential frame-tearing issues when games are running at these lower framerates.

‘GTA VI’ running on a PlayStation 5, left, and the game running on an Xbox Series X, right.

And despite that, I didn’t experience any noticeable screen tearing issues on PS5. Based on my own tests measuring GTA VI’s framerates in several scenarios, there’s no real difference in frame pacing between the consoles. In most areas, the game remains laser locked at 30 fps. The frame rate may dip randomly to the lower 20s, especially when in combat with swarms of cop cars on-screen. But if there’s one thing you can say about GTA VI’s performance, it’s that it’s consistent.

Here’s the thing. I would still rather play GTA VI on PlayStation than Xbox, and it all comes down to the controller. The Xbox controller is an oldie but a goodie, with its grippy feel, clacky buttons, and smooth Impulse Triggers. But GTA put a lot of thought into how you’d use a PS5 DualSense controller in-game. It’s not just for blasting any redneck or police officer that gets in your way.

GTA VI is a slow burn. It asks you to live the lives of Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos like you would in real life. So in the opening hours of the game, as you repair Duval’s house in time for Caminos to get out of prison, you’ll feel the DualShock’s adaptive triggers give you resistance as you nail in new floorboards for your deck or to repair the roof. When you have your characters do morning exercises, the weights will also give a staggered amount of motorized resistance, making pumping iron feel more lively in your hand.

The motors in the adaptive triggers also make driving more intuitive. GTA VI’s driving feels more nuanced and less arcade-y than Grand Theft Auto V‘s, and it’s a more realistic car simulation that requires you to feather the brake and gas more if you’re to keep from spinning out. That’s easier when the controller’s triggers give you more resistance when you’re trying to floor it.

There’s more to consider for Microsoft mainstays. Xbox also has its less-powerful console, the Series S, that is also available. Compared to the Series X, Grand Theft Auto VI is running at a maximum of 1080p resolution, though that’s only upscaled from 720p using AMD’s recently-enabled FSR 4.1 model.

Left, ‘GTA VI’ running on Xbox Series S; right, the game running on a PlayStation 5. © Rockstar Games; screenshot by Gizmodo

My colleague, Gizmodo’s senior reporter of consumer tech James Pero, loaded the game up on his personal Series S at home after experiencing the game on Series X. In his words, the game does not look or feel as smooth as it does on the other available systems. GTA VI on Series S seems to struggle to render scenes fast, especially when driving or when there’s too much to handle on-screen during an intense gun battle. The game can look jittery, especially when there are complex shadows involved, such as within dense foliage.

GTA VI on Series S is playable and perfectly enjoyable, though it’s not the perfect experience. For that, you’ll have to play on PS5 Pro. Stay tuned, as we’ll have more on how GTA VI on PS5 compares to the game on PS5 Pro. Here’s another spoiler alert: it’s absolutely the best way to play.

Explore more on these topics

Share this story

Sign up for our newsletters

Subscribe and interact with our community, get up to date with our customised Newsletters and much more.